AI Is Making Developers Dumb

This is something that I struggle with for AI programming. I actually like writing the code myself. Like how someone might enjoy knitting or model building or painting or some other "tedious" activity. Using AI to generate my code just takes all the fun out of it for me.

I'm in full agreement with this, and it's part of the reason I'm considering leaving the software engineering field for good.

I've been programming for over 25 years, and the joy I get from it is the artistry of it, I see beauty in systems constructed in the abstract realm. But LLM based development remove much of that. I haven't used nor desire to use LLM for this, but I don't want to compete with people that do because I won't win in the short-term nature of corporate performance based culture. And so I'm now searching for careers that will be more resistant to LLM based workflows. Unfortunately in my opinion this pretty much rules out any knowledge based economy.

I think "AI makes developers dumb" makes as much sense as "becoming a manager makes developers dumb."

I was an engineer before moving to more product and strategy oriented roles, and I work on side projects with assistance from Copilot and Roo Code. I find that the skills that I developed as a manager (like writing clear reqs, reviewing code, helping balance tool selection tradeoffs, researching prior art, intuiting when to dive deep into a component and when to keep it abstract, designing system architectures, identifying long-term-bad ideas that initially seem like good ideas, and pushing toward a unified vision of the future) are sometimes more useful for interacting with AI devtools than my engineering skillset.

I think giving someone an AI coding assistant is pretty bad for having them develop coding skills, but pretty good for having them develop "working with an AI assistant" skills. Ultimately, if the result is that AI-assisted programmers can ship products faster without sacrificing sustainability (i.e. you can't have your codebase collapse under the weight of AI-generated code that nobody understands), then I think there will be space in the future for both AI-power users who can go fast as well as conventional engineers who can go deep.

Or it makes dumb people become developers ;)

I use LLMs for generating small chunks of code (less than 150 lines) but I am of the opinion that you should always understand what generated cide is doing. I take time go read through it and make sure it makes sense before I actually run it. I've found that for smaller chunks of code it's usually pretty accurate on the first try. Occasionally it can't figure it out all all, even with trying to massage the prompt to be more descriptive.