Live data from Hacker News

Evidence that Neanderthal and Homo sapiens engaged in cultural exchange

phys.org

11–20 of 100 posts

Re: Evidence that Neanderthal and Homo sapiens engaged in cultural exchange

#11

I mean, we already knew that we exchanged genes so is it not therefore self-evident that we also exchanged memes?

Plunder/Raping raids don't necessarilyead to trading and meaningful conversations do they?

Ask the Vikings.

Re: Evidence that Neanderthal and Homo sapiens engaged in cultural exchange

#12
so we are all part, Ugg, or is it part Ugg-et, or is it both?, ie: y and x chromasones have nieanderthal bits?, if its both, then that is a strong indication that things were pretty casual, ,hanging out partying, looks like Ugg and Sue are hitting it off, some tasty mastadon on the fire, heard you and the other nieandethals got a saber tooth cat last week

Re: Evidence that Neanderthal and Homo sapiens engaged in cultural exchange

#15

so we are all part, Ugg, or is it part Ugg-et, or is it both?, ie: y and x chromasones have nieanderthal bits?, if its both, then that is a strong indication that things were pretty casual, ,hanging out partying, looks like Ugg and Sue are hitting it off, some tasty mastadon on the fire, heard you and the other nieandethals got a saber tooth cat last week

There is no Neanderthal Y chromosome (male line) DNA in modern humans, and also no Neanderthal mitochondrial (female line) DNA in modern humans, but about half of Neanderthal DNA is still around scattered between different modern humans. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/how-human-y-chromo..., https://theconversation.com/modern-human-dna-contains-bits-f...

Neanderthals and mastodons never met, as they were on different continents.

Re: Evidence that Neanderthal and Homo sapiens engaged in cultural exchange

#16

[flagged]

Genetic differences do exist among different human populations. Even so, attributing broad behavioral traits to Neanderthal ancestry is not supported by science.

Human behavior is shaped by many factors like genetics, culture, environment, and social structures. No credible geneticist argues that Neanderthal ancestry “explains large portions of variances in human behavior.”

As for your comment that “Biologists know this, you won’t catch them saying it in public though.”, this is a classic conspiracy-style statement. You’re suggesting that experts are hiding the “truth,” which is a tactic often used in pseudoscience and race-related theories.

Re: Evidence that Neanderthal and Homo sapiens engaged in cultural exchange

#17

I mean, we already knew that we exchanged genes so is it not therefore self-evident that we also exchanged memes?

Plunder/Raping raids don't necessarilyead to trading and meaningful conversations do they?

You have be able to communicate with your slaves.

Re: Evidence that Neanderthal and Homo sapiens engaged in cultural exchange

#18
post #16

[flagged]

Genetic differences do exist among different human populations. Even so, attributing broad behavioral traits to Neanderthal ancestry is not supported by science. Human behavior is shaped by many factors like genetics, culture, environment, and social structures. No credible geneticist argues that Neanderthal ancestry “explains large portions of variances in human behavior.” As for your comment that “Biologists know t…

The interpretation of "you won’t catch them saying it in public though" that you offer is NOT the only one. The one the OP most likely meant is: "out of fear for their careers and livelihoods, they will not state such things given that such facts are outside of the current overton window"

Re: Evidence that Neanderthal and Homo sapiens engaged in cultural exchange

#19
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Genetic differences do exist among different human populations. Even so, attributing broad behavioral traits to Neanderthal ancestry is not supported by science. Human behavior is shaped by many factors like genetics, culture, environment, and social structures. No credible geneticist argues that Neanderthal ancestry “explains large portions of variances in human behavior.” As for your comment that “Biologists know t…

The interpretation of "you won’t catch them saying it in public though" that you offer is NOT the only one. The one the OP most likely meant is: "out of fear for their careers and livelihoods, they will not state such things given that such facts are outside of the current overton window"

Controversial scientific topics are actively discussed in academic journals and conferences. Scientists regularly publish challenging or provocative findings, even those outside mainstream acceptance… Provided they’re backed by credible evidence. The absence of discussion here isn’t due to fear of consequences. It’s because the scientific community hasn’t found convincing evidence linking Neanderthal DNA to major behavioral differences.

Re: Evidence that Neanderthal and Homo sapiens engaged in cultural exchange

#20
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wouldn't captives carry memes?

Only if you and your captives are able to communicate. If you have a fish tank, do your fish give you memes?

People can learn from just seeing stuff. You watch a guy preparing food in a different way, now you know that there's a different way. He wears a funny hat, maybe you try and make a copy, etc. Chimps and some other animals do this too.
Post reply on HN