Live data from Hacker News

The curious surge of productivity in U.S. restaurants

bfi.uchicago.edu

11–20 of 280 posts

Re: The curious surge of productivity in U.S. restaurants

#11
post #6

My favorite ~75 year old BBQ place here in Pasadena has half the bar (where you'd sit and eat and socialize if you were eating alone) reserved to give space for all the take-out orders and uber-eats pickups flowing through. I see single people come in and, without a space at the bar, take a seat at a booth alone. I don't blame restaurants for this at all, it's a tough business, but I do think it's about time we apply…

You'd think the extravagant markups, missed deliveries, and cold food would be enough.

Re: The curious surge of productivity in U.S. restaurants

#12
I'm not an academic economist, so what do I know, but I think the authors aare missing something else.

I think the productivity was in some part driven by minimum wage laws. At lower wages, developing, installing and maintaining ordering kiosks and smart phone ordering apps makes less sense, because fast food cashiers are so cheap. When fast food cashiers become more expensive (and the technology costs come down) kiosks and apps make more sense. The same amount of food sold without the cost of cashiers is the resultant increase in productivity.

So my theory in a nutshell was that cashiers added little value. Substituting capital for labor led to labor productivity gains.

Re: The curious surge of productivity in U.S. restaurants

#13
post #2

i'm not sure how this is anything to do with productivity surely that's when the same product or service is delivered more cheaply the starting question must have been more like 'why are restaurants more profitable now' and it's because restaurants are now selling more take-out meals; essentially a different product, which has lower overheads

Labor productivity is just a technical term in this case.

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/labor-productivity.asp

Re: The curious surge of productivity in U.S. restaurants

#14
post #6

My favorite ~75 year old BBQ place here in Pasadena has half the bar (where you'd sit and eat and socialize if you were eating alone) reserved to give space for all the take-out orders and uber-eats pickups flowing through. I see single people come in and, without a space at the bar, take a seat at a booth alone. I don't blame restaurants for this at all, it's a tough business, but I do think it's about time we apply…

If the comment reflects the culture of the people sitting and eating at the bar, a preference to forgo sitting and eating at the bar seems quite rational to me.

I'm not a regular/local. Why would I go where I am not welcome?

If I owned the restaurant, why would I cater to an unwelcoming crowd?

Re: The curious surge of productivity in U.S. restaurants

#15
Abstract: "We document that, after remaining almost constant for almost 30 years, real labor productivity at U.S. restaurants surged over 15% during the COVID pandemic. This surge has persisted even as many conditions have returned to pre-pandemic levels. Using mobile phone data tracking visits and spending at more than 100,000 individual limited service restaurants across the country, we explore the potential sources of the surge. It cannot be explained by economies of scale, expanding market power, or a direct result of COVID-sourced demand fluctuations. The restaurants’ productivity growth rates are strongly correlated, however, with reductions in the amount of time their customers spend in the establishments, particularly with a rising share of customers spending 10 minutes or less. The frequency of such ‘take-out’ customers rose considerably during COVID, even at fast food restaurants, and never went back down. The magnitude of the restaurant-level relationship between productivity and customer dwell time, if applied to the aggregate decrease in dwell time, can explain almost all of the aggregate productivity increase in our sample."

Huh. Interesting!

The finding is consistent with both the changes, since the pandemic, in my own eating-out habits and the behavior of other customers I see at restaurants I visit regularly.

Nonetheless, seeing it validated with an analysis of largish-scale data is worth the read.

The question is whether eating-out habits have permanently changed, or whether they will eventually revert to pre-pandemic patterns.

Thank you for sharing this on HN!

Re: The curious surge of productivity in U.S. restaurants

#16
post #4

My take away is that the overall labor per customer decreases because workers are spending less time on non-cooking/serving tasks. The paper implies the efficiency gain is in how labor is used rather than production or serving efficiency. This seems like an anticlimactic conclusion.

Yup, they pretty much state that explicitly right in the abstract. I think we have a relatively rare example of a clickbait scientific paper title, here!

“If everyone’s doing takeout, you need fewer employees” isn’t exactly a shocking revelation.

Re: The curious surge of productivity in U.S. restaurants

#17
I would have guessed that the surge had something to do with faster payments, namely contactless and the wireless terminals. In a way, it's even broader than that: if you order for pick up and prepay, payment is pretty much out of the picture entirely, replaced by just verifying that you are getting the right order. Then you're avoiding the productivity losses in serving the dishes, washing the plates, etc.

Re: The curious surge of productivity in U.S. restaurants

#18
post #6

My favorite ~75 year old BBQ place here in Pasadena has half the bar (where you'd sit and eat and socialize if you were eating alone) reserved to give space for all the take-out orders and uber-eats pickups flowing through. I see single people come in and, without a space at the bar, take a seat at a booth alone. I don't blame restaurants for this at all, it's a tough business, but I do think it's about time we apply…

"I do think it's about time we apply just an ounce of shame to people who uber-eats every meal they eat from restaurants clearly designed for eating-in"

Help me out here. What negative effect does that behavior have on the world such that people should feel shame for doing it?

(I'm still Covid cautious enough that I avoid dining indoors in places where I share air with strangers. This is a huge lifestyle limitation, but I enjoy not having to deal with long Covid very much.)

Re: The curious surge of productivity in U.S. restaurants

#19
> The restaurants’ productivity growth rates are strongly correlated, however, with reductions in the amount of time their customers spend in the establishments, particularly with a rising share of customers spending 10 minutes or less. The frequency of such ‘take-out’ customers rose considerably during COVID, even at fast food restaurants, and never went back down. The magnitude of the restaurant-level relationship between productivity and customer dwell time, if applied to the aggregate decrease in dwell time, can explain almost all of the aggregate productivity increase in our sample.

One restaurant near me ditched its dine-in service entirely during COVID. They never went back; the dining area is now some odd mix of storage/prep/work area, and they're still take-out only.

Which is a bit sad; the dine-in area was a pretty cozy experience, and you'd get free tea with the meal. (It was a Japanese restaurant.)

Post reply on HN