Live data from Hacker News

Copilot for Everything: Training your AI replacement one keystroke at a time

substack.com

71–80 of 90 posts

Re: Copilot for Everything: Training your AI replacement one keystroke at a time

#71

All humans need to start being compensated for all the data they generate that gets collected. Start giving fractions of stock or whatever for all human input which can now more than ever be endlessly productized.

I had a similar thought recently[0], though I was thinking about it more from the copyright side. I think there needs to be some kind of additional tax taken from AI profits, possibly justified by copyrights, because otherwise the economic impact might end up being nuts.

[0] https://jackson.dev/post/generative-ai-and-copyright/

Re: Copilot for Everything: Training your AI replacement one keystroke at a time

#72
This is overwrought. I have a lot of content on the Internet and am not replicable by machine, sadly. I would gladly have an immortal MM/Acevedo of myself running around. I would be quite happy to be able to snapshot my current self to talk to him later and so on, but the best I can do is write as much of myself down as possible. Currently, with a few MCPs I can have Claude on the desktop search my written stuff and my CRM and all that and have some useful conversations but impersonating me seems out of reach.

I have no doubt it will happen one day and I'm happy to submit myself to it. If nothing else, if I die prematurely my children will be able to get some sense of the kind of person I am and the kind of people I want them to be.

Re: Copilot for Everything: Training your AI replacement one keystroke at a time

#73
post #20

Udemy has recently forced all Instructors to accept the AI mode for their content. So expect soon the courses to be 100% GenAI. Expect the same coercion, for a future role at any company: "We will record all you do to train your GenAI replacement". Maybe it will apply to the C-Suite... https://www.aiaaic.org/aiaaic-repository/ai-algorithmic-and-...

> Maybe it will apply to the C-Suite... Of course it won't, though those roles are probably the most suited to being replaced by a not-so-bright chatbot.

I've actually used it to generate business plans and strategies for some technical work I've done. I've not followed up but the options it created were all credible and would definitely lower the bar for someone less commercially oriented to get up and running with a business idea.

Re: Copilot for Everything: Training your AI replacement one keystroke at a time

#74

> the thing that scares me about the existence of this data is that it seems well within the capabilities of current technology to train a model that can replicate me , in some sense There’s already all of your posts on social media accounts, all your emails on various servers, all of your text messages, all the notes you’ve written anywhere in any form that might end up in some database in the future. It does make m…

The first time I changed a system prompt, I changed it to "You are George Carlin." So, I think we're already doing that, in a way.

Re: Copilot for Everything: Training your AI replacement one keystroke at a time

#76
I have a problem with many text replacement systems. Enough that I turn every one off (still can't figure out iPhone [0]). The major problem is it'll replace a word and I'm typing so don't notice and help going only to go back. All under a second. Beginning the next word appears to reinforce the prior words appearance. So now "and" I always type manually because it always appears as "ABs" "Ave" or something else. Words which are far less[1] common. It increases my workload, not decreases.

[0] Apple settings make no sense. How do I still get two word replacements (see [1]) when I turned off autocorrect? Predictive text? Check spelling? I've tried them all! And why the fuck does "auto capitalize" not capitalize the letter i? It's so prolific you can identify an iPhone user by that single error. How the fuck does no one think to fix this?

[1] "far" was accidentally swiped as "fast" then as I typed "less" it became "day less". Stop changing two words! 95% of the time it is erroneously changing a word. 4% of the time it's a case like this where the first word was wrong anyways but never gets the right word. Give me a prompt to change and let me accept, not force this on me. Idk, a blue squiggle. Jesus fuck, why is trying on a phone harder than it was a decade ago when swipe was introduced?!

Re: Copilot for Everything: Training your AI replacement one keystroke at a time

#77

> the thing that scares me about the existence of this data is that it seems well within the capabilities of current technology to train a model that can replicate me , in some sense There’s already all of your posts on social media accounts, all your emails on various servers, all of your text messages, all the notes you’ve written anywhere in any form that might end up in some database in the future. It does make m…

Our social media personas are also tiny subsets of our actual personalities. I think most people don't reveal their full character in any one medium. now phone conversations—that would be a goldmine and a nightmare.

[dead]

Re: Copilot for Everything: Training your AI replacement one keystroke at a time

#78

The flip side to this is that if you come to depend on a companies AI, then if you leave or are let go, you are leaving a significant part of yourself behind that you cannot take with you. This is a real problem companies need to address before I even begin to trust or rely on these tools. It's going to lead to massive growth of shadow IT.

Anecdote: I recently opened VScode on my personal laptop for the first time in a year or two and, having got used to the internal AI assistance we have at work, my own non-AI-enhanced VScode felt so primitive. Like using Win95-era notepad.exe or something. It was palpable - that was "a moment" for me. Programming has changed.

You have just made me realize that I did the same thing a couple weeks ago, and didn't even notice that the AI integration was missing.

(I find it moderately useful at work, but apparently not enough to realize it's missing unprompted).

Re: Copilot for Everything: Training your AI replacement one keystroke at a time

#79
post #27

Funny how automation is only a problem because workers don't own much of anything they create. Meaning, if I owned my business then automating myself away would be a dream! But for most people, automating yourself away means a complete loss of income. I'm sure there's an economic lesson, here, our country will completely ignore.

There's nothing preventing people from creating employee-owned co-ops. In fact there are some large and successful ones, like WinCo. We did learn an economic lesson from countries that tried to make employee ownership of the means of production mandatory, and more especially we learned lessons from the mountains of skulls those countries left behind.

Workers at a worker cooperative would similarly resist automation out of the fear of machines getting personhood thereby diluting the existing ownerships.

Re: Copilot for Everything: Training your AI replacement one keystroke at a time

#80

Until you have an AI manager that calls out your bullshit and fires you without having to worry about the messy human empathy aspect.

Until AI learns higher-order empathy and concludes humans are actively harmful.
Post reply on HN