Live data from Hacker News

Let my Wi-Fi go: FCC rules Verizon can't charge for Wi-Fi tethering

zdnet.com

1–10 of 146 posts

Re: Let my Wi-Fi go: FCC rules Verizon can't charge for Wi-Fi tethering

#3
post #2

What about AT&T? Will the FCC force them to stop charging too, or is there some reason why it's different?

It seems like the ruling was based off of particular regulations for the 4G (LTE) spectrum. I have a feeling it would not apply to 3G spectrum.

Re: Let my Wi-Fi go: FCC rules Verizon can't charge for Wi-Fi tethering

#4
post #2

What about AT&T? Will the FCC force them to stop charging too, or is there some reason why it's different?

Seems like this is thanks to the open applications rule of the 700MHz spectrum auction, Block C[1], that Google lobbied to include and then bid to ensure that it would apply. That spectrum was bought by Verizon for the contiguous 48 states.

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_2008_wireless_spe...

Re: Let my Wi-Fi go: FCC rules Verizon can't charge for Wi-Fi tethering

#5
post #2

What about AT&T? Will the FCC force them to stop charging too, or is there some reason why it's different?

It seems like the ruling was based off of particular regulations for the 4G (LTE) spectrum. I have a feeling it would not apply to 3G spectrum.

That's depressing. Charging for wifi tethering is ridiculous.

Re: Let my Wi-Fi go: FCC rules Verizon can't charge for Wi-Fi tethering

#6
post #2

What about AT&T? Will the FCC force them to stop charging too, or is there some reason why it's different?

It seems like the ruling was based off of particular regulations for the 4G (LTE) spectrum. I have a feeling it would not apply to 3G spectrum.

Right - Thank Google for this one. This was one of the conditions Google received from the FCC in exchange for placing their bid.

http://afp.google.com/article/ALeqM5iMbsPSv2vatAVvbz_8n0xU3M...

Re: Let my Wi-Fi go: FCC rules Verizon can't charge for Wi-Fi tethering

#9
post #4
post #2

What about AT&T? Will the FCC force them to stop charging too, or is there some reason why it's different?

Seems like this is thanks to the open applications rule of the 700MHz spectrum auction, Block C[1], that Google lobbied to include and then bid to ensure that it would apply. That spectrum was bought by Verizon for the contiguous 48 states. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_2008_wireless_spe...

I guess we can hope that competitive pressure will encourage AT&T to offer Wi-Fi tethering at no additional charge. My guess is that both carriers will raise their base rate and offer it "free".

Re: Let my Wi-Fi go: FCC rules Verizon can't charge for Wi-Fi tethering

#10

Does this mean that they can simply charge more for the base fee instead?

Probably, but since tethering is probably a feature 10% of their data subscribers are interested in, they would also raise the data price on the 90% that don't need it (who are also be more likely to walk away if prices go up.)
Post reply on HN