Live data from Hacker News

Peter Thiel’s startup class notes in PDF

klinger.io

21–30 of 35 posts

Re: Peter Thiel’s startup class notes in PDF

#21
post #16

This is awesome. But, I hope Blake is fine with this. I did the same thing earlier, scraped the posts and created a epub. He immediately sent me an email: Please remove the ePub version of my notes that you put on Github. Peter Thiel, Clarium, and I are still figuring out what to do with the content. Very likely we will be publishing something ourselves. As you do not own the content and did not ask for permission, p…

Thanks for mentioning. I hope i didnt crossed a line. I will remve the dl link tomorrow (as soon as i have a proper laptop in front of me)

I hope Blake Masters & Clarium come up with their own version soon. It is easier to be consumed on iPad/Kindle than on web.

Re: Peter Thiel’s startup class notes in PDF

#24
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for mentioning. I hope i didnt crossed a line. I will remve the dl link tomorrow (as soon as i have a proper laptop in front of me)

I hope Blake Masters & Clarium come up with their own version soon. It is easier to be consumed on iPad/Kindle than on web.

I'd love for them to make a Leanpub version (PDF + EPUB + MOBI). I've tweeted at Blake asking him if he's interested, and obviously anything that is made should be done with Peter Thiel's approval.

It would have taken us 5 minutes to make a Leanpub version, but we respect copyright, both Blake's and Peter's, so we haven't :)

Anyway, Blake, please email me (peter@leanpub.com) or tweet me (@peterarmstrong) if you're interested...

Re: Peter Thiel’s startup class notes in PDF

#25

How does this not violate the No Derivatives portion of the content license?

Given that this is licensed Creative Commons under Attribution, Non-Commercial, and No Derivative Works, -- and notwithstanding a general desire to respect the authors wishes (http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/22922727433/read-share-p...) -- it becomes a question as to whether it is a truly derivative work.

Since the meat-and-potatoes of the work is entirely textual, and faithfully reproduced, you could argue that work is non-derivative and within the license.

CC puts two additional restrictions on “transformation” and “alteration,” but it is not clear on what those would be. It would be reasonable to argue in the spirit of the license, that as long as we do not alter the meaning, intent, or spirit of the original work we did not alter or transform it. Any stricter interpretation would like defeat the purpose of licensing something CC, as any form of distribution requires some, however small, amount of altering (eg, I have to convert it to photons before I can hit your retinas).

There are precedents for what is considered a “derivative work” in the US, but usually as to define “new” works that may desire protection, but not likely as many in this reverse situation where we wish to argue that a slightly altered version is equivalent.

If I made printed-to-PDF from my web browser, is that a derivative work? a transformation? a substantial alteration?

If we take a strict (perhaps stretched) interpretation of Masters desires: you should read it only on my website and share only links to it from there? Then why license it as CC BY-NC-ND? Such interpretation of the license gives you no rights you did not have before under fair use (or fair dealing).

Re: Peter Thiel’s startup class notes in PDF

#26
post #16

This is awesome. But, I hope Blake is fine with this. I did the same thing earlier, scraped the posts and created a epub. He immediately sent me an email: Please remove the ePub version of my notes that you put on Github. Peter Thiel, Clarium, and I are still figuring out what to do with the content. Very likely we will be publishing something ourselves. As you do not own the content and did not ask for permission, p…

Thanks for mentioning. I hope i didnt crossed a line. I will remve the dl link tomorrow (as soon as i have a proper laptop in front of me)

Andreas, rdd.me has a very nice facility for sending web pages to the Kindle.

Also, here is what @bgmasters has already said about reproducing the content: http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/22922727433/read-share-p...

Re: Peter Thiel’s startup class notes in PDF

#27

And the same thing in "book" version ready to print/read: http://img.atlastory.com/PeterThielOnStartups.pdf

Ah sorry had to take it down, didn't know about the terms attached.

I made the PDF personally to turn into a printed/binded copy (I like physical books) with nice typography and after seeing the HN post thought I'd share.

If anyone still really wants this fancier version follow/msg me on twitter: @maxolson

Re: Peter Thiel’s startup class notes in PDF

#28
post #16

This is awesome. But, I hope Blake is fine with this. I did the same thing earlier, scraped the posts and created a epub. He immediately sent me an email: Please remove the ePub version of my notes that you put on Github. Peter Thiel, Clarium, and I are still figuring out what to do with the content. Very likely we will be publishing something ourselves. As you do not own the content and did not ask for permission, p…

Hah! What a dork. These cult-leader types always want to control the message.

Re: Peter Thiel’s startup class notes in PDF

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for mentioning. I hope i didnt crossed a line. I will remve the dl link tomorrow (as soon as i have a proper laptop in front of me)

Andreas, rdd.me has a very nice facility for sending web pages to the Kindle. Also, here is what @bgmasters has already said about reproducing the content: http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/22922727433/read-share-p...

Then his stated goals shouldn't prevent people making conversions to other formats. You just have to be careful with not misrepresenting the work, something that is already part of the non-transferable author rights in a few countries.
Post reply on HN