Live data from Hacker News

The IRS Is Buying an AI Supercomputer from Nvidia

theintercept.com

41–50 of 74 posts

Re: The IRS Is Buying an AI Supercomputer from Nvidia

#41
post #29

Audits for everyone

correct - as long as they don’t make 7-figures. anyone over 7-figures is auto-exempt

"Last September the IRS announced it would hire 3,700 new agents to help increase scrutiny of taxes paid by corporations, wealthy people and the private investment funds they increasingly favor. " [https://www.icij.org/inside-icij/2024/02/inside-the-irs-unit...]

"IRS launches new effort aimed at high-income non-filers; 125,000 cases focused on high earners, including millionaires" [https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-launches-new-effort-aimed-a...]

"The Internal Revenue Service today announced the agency has surpassed the $1 billion mark in collections from high-wealth taxpayers with past-due taxes. " [https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-tops-1-billion-in-past-due-...]

--

Your ideological view of reality and what the IRS are objectively doing do not seem to remotely line up.

Re: The IRS Is Buying an AI Supercomputer from Nvidia

#43
post #2

This will not end well. The IRS has tried many times to replace their mainframe systems and failed. So they are upgrading to AI ? I thought Trump was the "save waste" guy. These are finanical systems, they need to add/subtract and multiply/divide lots of transactional data. AI not needed.

They never actually define what “efficiency” means, so it can be anything they want, and then they can claim any victory they would like by playing with numbers and definitions.

Re: The IRS Is Buying an AI Supercomputer from Nvidia

#45
post #33

Isn't the IRS on the chopping block? I know they killed the free tax filing feature for citizen. I cannot keep track anymore. Reading through the article, it's not one or two machines but 8 Blackwell nodes, so quite some firepower for compute. Wonder what part of the audit or tax prep requires a GPU farm.

If you're wondering if the "Efficiency Department" is actually about efficiency, or if they're just cosplaying political Santa Claus, look for cuts to the IRS. The IRS is the most bang for the buck government department. Every dollar spent there nets out many more, because they're chronically under-resourced to audit the whales who can trivially hide their tax obligations. Naturally whenever there's a hint that the d…

The IRS Individual Master File, running on IBM mainframes, may be the oldest software alive. Perhaps there's a need for an update. https://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/world-records/636196-ol...

Re: The IRS Is Buying an AI Supercomputer from Nvidia

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

correct - as long as they don’t make 7-figures. anyone over 7-figures is auto-exempt

"Last September the IRS announced it would hire 3,700 new agents to help increase scrutiny of taxes paid by corporations, wealthy people and the private investment funds they increasingly favor. " [ https://www.icij.org/inside-icij/2024/02/inside-the-irs-unit... ] "IRS launches new effort aimed at high-income non-filers; 125,000 cases focused on high earners, including millionaires" [ https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs…

did you just provide links from Biden administration and have missed we have a new President? :)

Re: The IRS Is Buying an AI Supercomputer from Nvidia

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you're wondering if the "Efficiency Department" is actually about efficiency, or if they're just cosplaying political Santa Claus, look for cuts to the IRS. The IRS is the most bang for the buck government department. Every dollar spent there nets out many more, because they're chronically under-resourced to audit the whales who can trivially hide their tax obligations. Naturally whenever there's a hint that the d…

The IRS Individual Master File, running on IBM mainframes, may be the oldest software alive. Perhaps there's a need for an update. https://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/world-records/636196-ol...

Yeah, I'm sure there are no weird edge cases in America's byzantine tax laws that have been spotted and squashed in the software

Sounds like fun to find and fix them all again though!

Re: The IRS Is Buying an AI Supercomputer from Nvidia

#48
post #9
post #2

This will not end well. The IRS has tried many times to replace their mainframe systems and failed. So they are upgrading to AI ? I thought Trump was the "save waste" guy. These are finanical systems, they need to add/subtract and multiply/divide lots of transactional data. AI not needed.

> These are finanical systems, they need to add/subtract and multiply/divide lots of transactional data. AI not needed. The IRS gets 125 million paper forms every year: https://www.cnn.com/2024/01/29/politics/tax-season-irs-digit... They tried and failed to scan some of them with OCR: "OCR – This project involved extracting machine-readable data from low-resolution and poor-quality images (both digital and paper) wit…

[deleted]

Re: The IRS Is Buying an AI Supercomputer from Nvidia

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

AI is GREAT at porting software to new languages. That's like one of the things it is best at.

> IBM says GenAI can convert that old COBOL code to Java for you https://www.theregister.com/2023/08/22/ibm_says_genai_can_co...

All well and good, but the system deals with money. You cannot have rounding issues. For non COBOL systems, rounding issues are a big issue.

Re: The IRS Is Buying an AI Supercomputer from Nvidia

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you're wondering if the "Efficiency Department" is actually about efficiency, or if they're just cosplaying political Santa Claus, look for cuts to the IRS. The IRS is the most bang for the buck government department. Every dollar spent there nets out many more, because they're chronically under-resourced to audit the whales who can trivially hide their tax obligations. Naturally whenever there's a hint that the d…

The IRS Individual Master File, running on IBM mainframes, may be the oldest software alive. Perhaps there's a need for an update. https://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/world-records/636196-ol...

I agree! However, the brain trust Musk is running is absolutely not qualified to do it. They're getting tripped up on basic COBOL trivia[1].

[1] https://www.fastcompany.com/91278597/elon-musk-doge-cobol-la...

Post reply on HN