Live data from Hacker News

Leaking the email of any YouTube user for $10k

brutecat.com

11–20 of 487 posts

Re: Leaking the email of any YouTube user for $10k

#11
post #6

This is a puny payout IMO. If they poked around a bit more they may have found a better GAIA->Email vulnerability or perhaps could just use the one they found. A database of emails for every major youtube channel would be worth an awful lot.

the burden of being consciencious, i guess

Re: Leaking the email of any YouTube user for $10k

#13
Very nice breakdown. But while 10,000 dollars seems like a decent sum, I expected more for a bug of this severity, if I'm being honest. Especially as they initially only awarded 3100. But I'm not sure how much is usual for such cases. Almost 150 days also seems kind of a long time for fixing it imho.

Re: Leaking the email of any YouTube user for $10k

#14

I’d misunderstood the title to refer to $10k of GPU compute or something like that. Unfortunately I suspect there’ll be tens or hundreds of occurrences of this bug given that they just picked one old Google product and immediately found a hole.

> given that they just picked one old Google product and immediately found a hole.

This is just not how it works. Most likely author spent weeks or months digging into different products until he found something worthville.

Re: Leaking the email of any YouTube user for $10k

#15
post #9
post #2

Am I very naive expecting the payout to be significantly higher?

Unfortunately high payouts is just not how cyber security industry work. Instead of high payouts you get vanity and higher chance to get well-paid job.

You can get a high payout if you're also willing to risk your life. Companies are relying on researchers doing the ethical thing instead of the profitable thing.

Re: Leaking the email of any YouTube user for $10k

#17

Breaking the email system so that it's not sent is the cherry on top. With companies as big as Google who have developed so many products, "security" feels fake. If every line of code is a possible vulnerability, with millions it's just inevitable. It feels like the only way is to keep things simple (e.g., deprecate the recorder site), but even then.

Unfortunately with the number of users Google has, any deprecation will be met with cries of pain / I-rely-on-the-spacebar-to-heat-up-my-computer. See https://killedbygoogle.com/ .

Side note, what is that reference from? Searching "i rely on the spacebar to heat up my computer" directs me back to this comment (6 mins ago).

Re: Leaking the email of any YouTube user for $10k

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unfortunately with the number of users Google has, any deprecation will be met with cries of pain / I-rely-on-the-spacebar-to-heat-up-my-computer. See https://killedbygoogle.com/ .

Side note, what is that reference from? Searching "i rely on the spacebar to heat up my computer" directs me back to this comment (6 mins ago).

[deleted]

Re: Leaking the email of any YouTube user for $10k

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unfortunately with the number of users Google has, any deprecation will be met with cries of pain / I-rely-on-the-spacebar-to-heat-up-my-computer. See https://killedbygoogle.com/ .

Side note, what is that reference from? Searching "i rely on the spacebar to heat up my computer" directs me back to this comment (6 mins ago).

[deleted]

Re: Leaking the email of any YouTube user for $10k

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unfortunately with the number of users Google has, any deprecation will be met with cries of pain / I-rely-on-the-spacebar-to-heat-up-my-computer. See https://killedbygoogle.com/ .

Side note, what is that reference from? Searching "i rely on the spacebar to heat up my computer" directs me back to this comment (6 mins ago).

It is a reference to the following XKCD comic: https://xkcd.com/1172/
Post reply on HN