Live data from Hacker News

More users are watching YouTube on TV than mobile

engadget.com

71–80 of 89 posts

Re: More users are watching YouTube on TV than mobile

#71
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Terrible headline - the article says nothing about users. It does not link to Youtubes finding that TV is overtaking mobile. That news is here, and it's by WATCH TIME, not user count as claimed. https://blog.youtube/inside-youtube/our-big-bets-for-2025/ I think TV>Mobile for watch time is less surprising because of the nature of content you'd watch on the TV (longer form, background stuff). User count would be surpri…

Fair points. I'm still surprised at how strong television viewership remains, but my guess is that is poor priors on my part? Specifically to youtube, I am also a bit surprised at it being used heavily on televisions. It is not a pleasant experience there. I have a hard time on phone, but at least there the popup keyboard is a bit more usable. Granted, saying that, it occurs to me that i don't actually know the usage…

Depends on the content. There is a lot of long form content but yeah shorts and other types of things ("how do I do xyz", etc.) is just not the type of thing I'm looking to watch on a TV.

Re: More users are watching YouTube on TV than mobile

#72
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I turn it on at night and listen to 8-10 hours of sleep sounds.

What are "sleep sounds"? Like sounds of others sleeping? Do you experience silence anything during the day or any other time? I couldn't imagine having sounds while trying to sleep, it's my quiet time when I can fully focus on what's inside my head, and outside sounds tend to be distracting. But still interesting how we all are very different, no right or wrong :)

Yes, the sounds of intense sleep apnea. Typically recording 4 or 5 people snoring overlaid into a harmony of sleep sound

Re: More users are watching YouTube on TV than mobile

#73
post #27

Regularly watching YouTube on Apple TV, but.. does it play ads more frequently compared to on desktop OS? (makes sense, since context switching to another form of entertainment in another tab doesn't exist there - still, I wish it would be en par)

I’m not sure if the amount of ads is different, but the quality of ads is definitely different. The ads on TV are “skippable” in the sense that you watch 2 minutes of ads, and then in the last 10 seconds, you can skip to the end.

Any time I use my TV for YouTube now, I just connect my laptop to the TV so I don’t have to deal with those insane ads.

It’s extremely clear that YouTube is trying to maximize ad watch time, while keeping the acknowledgment by the user that they watched the ad, by acknowledging they’re paying attention enough to press “Skip”

Re: More users are watching YouTube on TV than mobile

#74
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What are "sleep sounds"? Like sounds of others sleeping? Do you experience silence anything during the day or any other time? I couldn't imagine having sounds while trying to sleep, it's my quiet time when I can fully focus on what's inside my head, and outside sounds tend to be distracting. But still interesting how we all are very different, no right or wrong :)

Yes, the sounds of intense sleep apnea. Typically recording 4 or 5 people snoring overlaid into a harmony of sleep sound

Understandable! I have my wife to reproduce the same setup so I guess I'm lucky to not having to depend on extra technology for the same thing.

Re: More users are watching YouTube on TV than mobile

#75

- Youtube pre-installed on smart TVs everywhere - Bigger screens are more enjoyable - Much lesser strain on hands compared to holding a phone means longer periods of watching - More friction in switching apps on a TV compared to a phone and unless you are casting, much smaller selection of apps - Fewer distractions like notifications on a phone - Sofas are comfy; also, autoplay can keep going even if you fall asleep…

Also, you can watch YouTube on your TV and then fiddle around on your phone without being left with a floating window that both obscures your other content and is too small to see some details in the video.

Think that's more to the point. Where people watch YouTube on TV, instead of traditional channels or cable, and they are free to screw around on their smartphones. There is no telling what people are actually paying attention to, because it seems many are just running multiple devices for the sake of it. Devices are always on, then used or watched whenever something comes to mind or catches their attention.

Re: More users are watching YouTube on TV than mobile

#76
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

yeah, don't know, it was just an example. People stream YouTube while doing other things (playing, working, coding) all the time. I didn't want to put too much focus on the "Let's Play" part, it was the first thing that came to my mind :) We have a handful of coders in our company and it's rare to enter their offices and not see something playing on the second screen.

> yeah, don't know, it was just an example. People stream YouTube while doing other things (playing, working, coding) all the time. I didn't want to put too much focus on the "Let's Play" part, it was the first thing that came to my mind :) That'd be very distracting to me, programming is (usually) a deep focus thing for me, having moving pictures right next to where I work would lead me to getting nothing done :P In…

you might not be aware of things like LoFiGirl[1], which is especially designed for such a use-case and not distracting at all. In any case you could always just minimize the tab and listen, that wouldprobably also cound as "watching" in YouTube's statistics

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jfKfPfyJRdk

Re: More users are watching YouTube on TV than mobile

#77
post #46

I wonder what the actual numbers are, especially considering PC viewers. My guess is that it's something like 15% on mobile, 16% on TV, and 69% on desktop/laptop etc. At least if you consider played minutes. I know many people watch short clips etc. on their phone, but the sheer amount of people watching let's plays while working, or streaming lo-fi music while coding is probably immense compared to that

I think your stats are way off when you consider how many kids are being babysat all day by YouTube videos on an iPad or the TV.

yeah that's why I think the actual numbers would be interesting. Are there more kids being fed YouTube on a tablet, or developers/students listening to lo-fi while coding/learning/writing essays :)

In any case, what numbers would you assume?

Re: More users are watching YouTube on TV than mobile

#78
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Terrible headline - the article says nothing about users. It does not link to Youtubes finding that TV is overtaking mobile. That news is here, and it's by WATCH TIME, not user count as claimed. https://blog.youtube/inside-youtube/our-big-bets-for-2025/ I think TV>Mobile for watch time is less surprising because of the nature of content you'd watch on the TV (longer form, background stuff). User count would be surpri…

Fair points. I'm still surprised at how strong television viewership remains, but my guess is that is poor priors on my part? Specifically to youtube, I am also a bit surprised at it being used heavily on televisions. It is not a pleasant experience there. I have a hard time on phone, but at least there the popup keyboard is a bit more usable. Granted, saying that, it occurs to me that i don't actually know the usage…

[deleted]

Re: More users are watching YouTube on TV than mobile

#79
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I turn it on at night and listen to 8-10 hours of sleep sounds.

What are "sleep sounds"? Like sounds of others sleeping? Do you experience silence anything during the day or any other time? I couldn't imagine having sounds while trying to sleep, it's my quiet time when I can fully focus on what's inside my head, and outside sounds tend to be distracting. But still interesting how we all are very different, no right or wrong :)

I throw on video game let's plays or long form retrospectives. If I'm left to myself, I'll end up keeping myself awake thinking about stuff.

Funny enough, I usually spend more time picking what to sleep to than I actually spend awake once it starts playing. Most times I'm dead asleep within the first minute or two after spending five minutes making selections. If it goes quiet, I wake up.

Re: More users are watching YouTube on TV than mobile

#80
post #52
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not to mention people falling asleep means that all ads will play unskipped, regardless of length. That means they have data that non-zero amounts of people are watching the whole of the extremely long skippable ads that get placed (more than once I've seen 90+ minute ads appear).

Muted ads playing to the sleeping. Great business for youtube, not so great for the advertiser. (people who use youtube as a sleep aid - don't you get woken up by ads?)

> people who use youtube as a sleep aid - don't you get woken up by ads?

I pay for Premium for that reason. I don't have any other TV/streaming services, so while I don't especially like giving Google money, I use it enough that the expense is well-justified.

Post reply on HN