Live data from Hacker News

Apple Invites

apple.com

141–150 of 956 posts

Re: Apple Invites

#141
post #138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How is this the wrong thread? Apple Invites is exactly like what I was doing with Midjourney a GenAI image generator.

I had a hard time connecting your comment to an event booking app. But I guess you are talking about the Memoji integration?

[deleted]

Re: Apple Invites

#142

Unfortunately, I have to hope this doesn't see widespread adoption. If this becomes the standard it will just add to already existing social pressure to get an iPhone in the US.

To me this argument makes no sense. Apple should never introduce any new features or services to their ecosystem because it might increase “social pressure” to get an iPhone?

Re: Apple Invites

#143
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s based on the new GroupKit API, which sounds like something that would be available to other apps in the future. Otherwise it would just use some private API.

You're being disingenuous, or you're incompetent, if you think Apple isn't going to keep this API in their closed garden.

It’s not the first time that a new API is used in a first party app and then opened to all developers.

Re: Apple Invites

#144
post #52

It's always nice to see some first-party apps from Apple[0], but historically the "iPhone-only social networking" hasn't been very successful — iTunes Ping or Game Center haven't been a huge hit, while group messaging in iMessage has only gained some traction within the US and virtually non-existent almost everywhere else. --- [0] One can even say "first first-party party app" in this case :)

Fortunately you don't need everyone to be on iOS to reply. So you can send your Android using friends invited and they'll just get a weblink.

Will it show them as green or blue though? :)

Re: Apple Invites

#145

Unless they add some basic functionality to include Android users, this is the evilest use of their walled garden yet.

The EU needs to regulate this

They don't need to. Android users can do the most important thing advertised here (RSVP) without the app or an iPhone. Also, hopefully the EU has better things to do than constantly force Apple to support Android users (for free!) at the same level of quality as their own customers.

Re: Apple Invites

#146
If anyone's looking for an open source alternative (and maybe wants to contribute to it) we're working on it here! [1]

We actually started before this was announced, and initially it was developed for a somewhat different use case (more focusing on "recurring invites"), but since it was asked a few times, I think we can offer a good alternative with it. [2]

[1]: https://github.com/gruprsvp/grup.

[2]: https://github.com/gruprsvp/grup/discussions/148

Re: Apple Invites

#147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fortunately you don't need everyone to be on iOS to reply. So you can send your Android using friends invited and they'll just get a weblink.

It still requires people to read a text message. It may as well be delivered via carrier pigeon outside the US.

Genuine question, is SMS text delivery unreliable where in certain countries?

Re: Apple Invites

#148

Brilliant move. The transition of the major social networks over the last 10-15 years -- from being a space for friends to interact to being a space to consume content produced by "unconnected" entities like influencers -- has created a huge opening for someone to claim the friends and family network. There is no one better positioned (at least in the U.S. where iPhones are the majority handset) than Apple.

Group texts and shared albums (iPhoto or Google photo if you have androids in the mix) are most of my social interaction already..

Re: Apple Invites

#149

Unfortunately, I have to hope this doesn't see widespread adoption. If this becomes the standard it will just add to already existing social pressure to get an iPhone in the US.

Im literally sick over the thought of the increased social pressure

Your friends joking with you to get an iPhone is making you sick?

Re: Apple Invites

#150
post #106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A (for most of the world, in any case) possibly surprising fact about the US is that WhatsApp is not very popular there. This indeed causes problems when wanting to create a quick ad-hoc group for a party invitation etc., if at least one of the invitees is not an iPhone user.

It causes problems if one of the iPhone owners isn't an active iCloud+ subscriber: > Creation of invitations requires an iCloud+ subscription. This isn't about making life easier on people, this is about getting you to subscribe to Apple's services for access to a REST API. Apple gets some benefit of the doubt, but this is literally Slop-as-a-Service.

I can't tell what you're arguing here – are you misunderstanding what you quoted from the FAQ? Only the person who creates the event needs to have an iCloud+ subscription. Everyone else can RSVP to it regardless of whether they have an iCloud+ subscription or even an Apple device at all.

> Do invitees need to have an Apple device with the app to attend an event?

> Apple Invites is for everyone. Guests don’t need the app, an Apple device, or an account to RSVP to an event.

Source: www.icloud.com/invites

Post reply on HN