Live data from Hacker News

El Salvador abandons Bitcoin as legal tender

ticotimes.net

21–30 of 930 posts

Re: El Salvador abandons Bitcoin as legal tender

#21

Nobody wants to spend it anyway, just hoard or sell it to the next sucker willing to shell more $. Among all the crypto shills I know I'm probably the only one who has used it for trade (0.25ish Bitcoins for a computer on caseking.de in late 2017 and few goodies on local bitcoin in the same year).

Mostly because transferring BTC is very expensive. Every time I’ve done it I’m shocked at the fees that sites like Bitbuy requires. So if you’re going to do it then it has to be for a good reason.

Re: El Salvador abandons Bitcoin as legal tender

#22

> The government, she assured, will continue buying bitcoin and having reserves in this cryptocurrency Sounds like the term "Failed Experiment" is the writer's assertion and not the government official position.

Imagine you have 6,050 bitcoins but they didn't work out for you the way that you hoped. The most reasonable thing to do is to still advertise a bullish position because otherwise you are devaluing your own asset.

There is a strong sentiment around bitcoin in El Salvador and it can make them money; but the experiment around it being a legal tender, well, failed.

Re: El Salvador abandons Bitcoin as legal tender

#26

> The government, she assured, will continue buying bitcoin and having reserves in this cryptocurrency Sounds like the term "Failed Experiment" is the writer's assertion and not the government official position.

That's probably why OP chose a highly editorialized "Tico Times" article as the source for this. What's even funnier is it's a Costa Rican newspaper. So one Central American country publishes an article smearing another Central American country, and then HN sees the bias-confirming headline and tries to glean some economic lesson from it. Classic.

Re: El Salvador abandons Bitcoin as legal tender

#27

> The government, she assured, will continue buying bitcoin and having reserves in this cryptocurrency Sounds like the term "Failed Experiment" is the writer's assertion and not the government official position.

From the article:

> Salvadorans, with the exception of a few, never embraced Bukele’s initiative, who enjoys enormous popularity for his war against gangs, which dropped homicides to historic lows in El Salvador. A recent survey by the Central American University (UCA) revealed that 92% of Salvadorans did not use bitcoin in their transactions in 2024.

I would say this points to an actual failed experiment, if true.

Re: El Salvador abandons Bitcoin as legal tender

#28

Misleading. Under the new rules, bitcoin is no longer considered "currency," though it remains "legal tender." https://reason.com/2025/02/03/el-salvador-walks-back-its-bit...

They literally removed the term "moneda de curso legal", which translates as "legal tender", from Article 5.

https://x.com/monicataher/status/1884971499129610322

Re: El Salvador abandons Bitcoin as legal tender

#29

Misleading. Under the new rules, bitcoin is no longer considered "currency," though it remains "legal tender." https://reason.com/2025/02/03/el-salvador-walks-back-its-bit...

“The reform eliminated the word “currency” when referring to bitcoin, but says it is “legal tender.” Despite the lack of clarity, it lifts, as required by the IMF, the obligation to accept it in transactions or debt payments, a key condition for it to be “legal tender,””

Edit to add a quote from your preferred link:

“Another change makes using bitcoin entirely voluntary. (Previously, the law mandated that businesses accept bitcoin for any goods or services they provided.) Additionally, bitcoin can no longer be used to pay taxes or settle government debts.”

If I can't pay my taxes with a token of economic exchange, and people aren't required to accept my tokens of economic exchange, the only remaining sense I can make of it being “legal tender” is that it is not illegal to use it, but that's not what “legal tender” means.

Re: El Salvador abandons Bitcoin as legal tender

#30
post #8

They have made just over 300 Million off the initial BTC purchase, and as of 15 minutes ago, continue to buy BTC everyday. They even have their own tracker, https://bitcoin.gob.sv/

Seems a bit dodgy to refer to state assets as if they were the personal possessions of Bukele in the way which that site does.
Post reply on HN