Live data from Hacker News

Our channel on YouTube has been deleted due to “spam and deceptive policies”

bsky.app

61–70 of 119 posts

Re: Our channel on YouTube has been deleted due to “spam and deceptive policies”

#61
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For anyone who hasn't seen this before, it's from an IBM internal training document in 1979. Sadly the original source was lost in a flood and IBM archives do not have a copy: https://twitter.com/jonty/status/1798170111058264280 Edit: here's a better link https://simonwillison.net/2025/Feb/3/a-computer-can-never-be...

Seen what, all I see is a tweet that there isn't an archive? Or is that tweet about the parent post?

I just pulled together a bunch of notes here, since linking to Twitter sucks now (logged out users can't navigate conversations): https://simonwillison.net/2025/Feb/3/a-computer-can-never-be...

Re: Our channel on YouTube has been deleted due to “spam and deceptive policies”

#65
When Poland was in the Soviet bloc (post-WWII until 1989), there was the "Main Office for the Control of Press, Publications, and Performances." Every censor working there was known by their full name, and you could even negotiate with them on certain issues when publishing a book, movie, etc. This was classic censorship but based on some old-fashioned rules.

Now, Big Tech can censor your work while providing only a vague explanation, with no clear feedback channel to protest or request more information. How would you call that?

Re: Our channel on YouTube has been deleted due to “spam and deceptive policies”

#66

Might be moot, but the shutdown email mentions "spam, scam or deceptive practices", not just "reasons". Without any context about the owner of the channel, the reader has no way to know how unfair the shutdown is. I understand from the HN thread that the dev is well known and that the shutdown seems unfair - but it's always hard to share the outrage in this situation. Best of luck to the channel's owner - let's hope…

I'm astounded by how crap the ads on Youtube now are. Back when the Adcopalypse happened they stated they were going to clean up the ads shown, but now it's just AI generated crap.

Re: Our channel on YouTube has been deleted due to “spam and deceptive policies”

#67

This happens all the time in Google Play, how do you protect against random take downs? You have several copies of your dev account or channel. That's it, you become a spammer to defend against the bot that "protects" us from spammers.

People uploading the Hollywood library do it like this:

Have channels with playlists and channels with 1 movie each. Add one of the playlists to the description (that playlist may not contain that movie)

The movies one by one vanish from the playlists and are uploaded again on new channels.

The playlist channels seem to last for a really long time.

Re: Our channel on YouTube has been deleted due to “spam and deceptive policies”

#68

[flagged]

This is what I've had to do. I got my channel banned from YouTube despite never getting a strike, and only one warning. Admittedly some of my videos can be a bit provocative but nothing too bad, and many not even that. When they've been flagged before I had appealed and gotten them reapproved, so I was under the impression that I was following the community guidelines appropriately. A sudden ban was unexpected.

Worse though is that banning your channel actually disables your entire YouTube account so I can't even watch YouTube with that account now! Not to mention playlists being gone, though I was able to get data from Google Takeout. That part was the most frustrating for me. I was even a premium subscriber!

And I've made videos for other people that have been around for years that I can't reupload due to the terms of the ban, which is also disheartening. I had started working under a different name before all this for much more artistic and abstract work, at the demand of the people I was working with, which now makes a lot more sense why they were pushing for that. I'm still uncertain if "me" being banned is all my personas or just the one that was banned; there are no obvious connections between them though.

Anyway, self hosting isn't too bad, though certainly need to ensure your hosting is capped so you don't get a giant bill if there is a sudden influx of viewers.

Thankfully I have enough donations to keep running with only a small amount I have to pay to cover the difference. Hopefully I don't have to end up using ads.

However the notable takeaway from all this is that there is no real competitor to YouTube! Nothing even comes close.

Re: Our channel on YouTube has been deleted due to “spam and deceptive policies”

#69
post #13

My channel suffered the same fate. I had a few original songs on it and a few original videos on it. Never got a warning or copyright strike or any sort of notice. Just boom shut down.

Affer the shut down on YouTube, did you post them elsewhere? That way, people can still watch it.

Re: Our channel on YouTube has been deleted due to “spam and deceptive policies”

#70

That's shocking, sinevibes is a legit developer in the music/audio space. They made the FX for dreadbox's Typhon synth and several popular FX plugins for Korg logue synths. I'm subscribed to their newsletter and have never received spam. All their youtube channel had were demos of their products, as far as I recall. Like "here's how the dry synth sounds, here's how it sounds with reverb", can't even imagine how an al…

> can't even imagine how an algorithm thought it runs afoul of a spam or scam policy Could a competitor cause the algorithm to think that, somehow, perhaps by engaging a service that reports the videos, in bulk, repeatedly from a seemingly diverse set of user accounts?

Or just an update in yourtube's new algorithm.

YouTube have 114 million active channels. A small error rate of 0.001% would kill 1000 channels.

Post reply on HN