Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Ask PG: Any chance of an update on "What I've learned from Hacker News"?

paulgraham.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

91–100 of 105 posts

Re: Ask PG: Any chance of an update on "What I've learned from Hacker News"?

#91

Post by RageKit »

politician wrote: post #83
RageKit wrote: post #39

Great article, but i don't really understand the last paragraph about games and social media, and the correlation between usefulness and self-fulfillment. Especially the part where games = crack = bad.

This person's username is green, their comment is graying, and they are the only green name on the thread. RageKit has simply asked a question asking for clarification. Given this post is already a meta discussion, what factors influenced the downvote? From what I see, it could be that the general nature of the comment is tangential to the tack that the general nature of all of the other comments took, that the user…

I've used this sentence construction because english isn't my first language and it was the easiest/fastest way to say what i wanted to say.

The downvote system is automatic ? I thought user could downvote each other threads

I'm still asking for clarification on why games are compared to crack. I'm a gamedesigner you see, and i went a little bit crossed-eyed on this sentence.

Edit : i don't see my comment grayed.

Re: Ask PG: Any chance of an update on "What I've learned from Hacker News"?

#92

Post by RageKit »

doesitwork wrote: post #88
joshlegs wrote: post #43

I must say, I enjoyed reading this. It seems I have noticed a lot of changes in the last few weeks. And I suppose it's time to fess up ;) I had another account that got hellbanned recently. Because the comment guidelines were what I felt a bit ambiguous, and because I had seen other comments that I thought seemed reflective in nature that had been downvoted (perhaps because they expressed a view that is contrary to w…

I have had 3 accounts hell banned. Each time was slightly mysterious to me, but let me relate the context and maybe someone can enlighten me. - The first ban was after I posted a comment that suggested that some venture capitalists that fund start ups may be exploiting young naive technologists. My guess was that saying anything bad about VCs or the startup culture merits a ban. - The second ban was after a post wher…

Hum, i'd like to know more about all these bans. Is the ban system automatic ? Or did someone (admin/moderator) actually banned you on purpose ?

Re: Ask PG: Any chance of an update on "What I've learned from Hacker News"?

#93

Post by ramblerman »

Skimming the discussion, I'm intrigued to see that no one has tackled the elephant in the room.

PG finishes with an honest open question, is Hackernews genuinely contributing to productivity or is it a giant timesink for 99% of it's members.

I'm inclined to agree with the latter.

Re: Ask PG: Any chance of an update on "What I've learned from Hacker News"?

#94

Post by dbaupp »

RageKit wrote: post #91
politician wrote: post #83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This person's username is green, their comment is graying, and they are the only green name on the thread. RageKit has simply asked a question asking for clarification. Given this post is already a meta discussion, what factors influenced the downvote? From what I see, it could be that the general nature of the comment is tangential to the tack that the general nature of all of the other comments took, that the user…

I've used this sentence construction because english isn't my first language and it was the easiest/fastest way to say what i wanted to say. The downvote system is automatic ? I thought user could downvote each other threads I'm still asking for clarification on why games are compared to crack. I'm a gamedesigner you see, and i went a little bit crossed-eyed on this sentence. Edit : i don't see my comment grayed.

Your comment is no longer grayed because others have upvoted it, likely because politician's comment pointed out that the downvotes were not deserved.

Re: Ask PG: Any chance of an update on "What I've learned from Hacker News"?

#95

Post by doesitwork »

RageKit wrote: post #92
doesitwork wrote: post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have had 3 accounts hell banned. Each time was slightly mysterious to me, but let me relate the context and maybe someone can enlighten me. - The first ban was after I posted a comment that suggested that some venture capitalists that fund start ups may be exploiting young naive technologists. My guess was that saying anything bad about VCs or the startup culture merits a ban. - The second ban was after a post wher…

Hum, i'd like to know more about all these bans. Is the ban system automatic ? Or did someone (admin/moderator) actually banned you on purpose ?

I honestly don't know. The first ban, my comments disappeared, but another person was kind enough to let me know it had happened. I could still see my comments, but nobody else could. The person who let me know was in the middle of a thread/conversation with me, had very high karma, took a look at my account and couldn't find any reason for the ban.

I looked for somewhere to ask for clarification on how or why, but there is nowhere to do so. The whole thing happens in secret, with no explanation and no recourse, which is about as antithetical to open and transparent discourse as is possible.

The intent, I believe, is for every person to develop a 'silent policeman' that asks them before every post 'Is this controversial? Is this an unpopular position on this forum? Does this position agree with the position of the owners/moderators of this forum.' In other words, the intent is discourage dissent from the predominant world view.

Well, that's how I see it. When this account gets banned, this comment will disappear as if it never existed, into the 'memory hole', and no one will ever know that someone disagrees. How that encourages rational debate is beyond my comprehension, perhaps I'm just not smart enough to be here.

Re: Ask PG: Any chance of an update on "What I've learned from Hacker News"?

#96

Post by roel_v »

doesitwork wrote: post #88
joshlegs wrote: post #43

I must say, I enjoyed reading this. It seems I have noticed a lot of changes in the last few weeks. And I suppose it's time to fess up ;) I had another account that got hellbanned recently. Because the comment guidelines were what I felt a bit ambiguous, and because I had seen other comments that I thought seemed reflective in nature that had been downvoted (perhaps because they expressed a view that is contrary to w…

I have had 3 accounts hell banned. Each time was slightly mysterious to me, but let me relate the context and maybe someone can enlighten me. - The first ban was after I posted a comment that suggested that some venture capitalists that fund start ups may be exploiting young naive technologists. My guess was that saying anything bad about VCs or the startup culture merits a ban. - The second ban was after a post wher…

"The second ban was after a post where I said that Flouride is rat poison. I understand this is controversial, but it is also an indisputable fact. Flouride is used in rat poison."

Maybe you were just being banned for expressing stupid reasoning, to the point where it's probably not just a slip of the brain but something fundamentally wrong with your capability to reason. Take this analogy: "Water is an atomic bomb. It's an indisputable fact, water is used in atomic bombs". See?

Also, it's 'fluoride', not 'flouride'.

Re: Ask PG: Any chance of an update on "What I've learned from Hacker News"?

#97

Post by doesitwork »

roel_v wrote: post #96
doesitwork wrote: post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have had 3 accounts hell banned. Each time was slightly mysterious to me, but let me relate the context and maybe someone can enlighten me. - The first ban was after I posted a comment that suggested that some venture capitalists that fund start ups may be exploiting young naive technologists. My guess was that saying anything bad about VCs or the startup culture merits a ban. - The second ban was after a post wher…

"The second ban was after a post where I said that Flouride is rat poison. I understand this is controversial, but it is also an indisputable fact. Flouride is used in rat poison." Maybe you were just being banned for expressing stupid reasoning, to the point where it's probably not just a slip of the brain but something fundamentally wrong with your capability to reason. Take this analogy: "Water is an atomic bomb.…

I didn't express that reasoning in the original post, but thank you for clarifying that inferred stupid reasoning and spelling errors are sufficient to have your account banned.

Water is not used in atomic bombs either. Hydrogen is used in thermonuclear weapons. The term 'atomic bomb' most commonly refers to fission weapons whereas thermonuclear is the term used for fusion weapons.

Re: Ask PG: Any chance of an update on "What I've learned from Hacker News"?

#98

Post by RageKit »

doesitwork wrote: post #95
RageKit wrote: post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hum, i'd like to know more about all these bans. Is the ban system automatic ? Or did someone (admin/moderator) actually banned you on purpose ?

I honestly don't know. The first ban, my comments disappeared, but another person was kind enough to let me know it had happened. I could still see my comments, but nobody else could. The person who let me know was in the middle of a thread/conversation with me, had very high karma, took a look at my account and couldn't find any reason for the ban. I looked for somewhere to ask for clarification on how or why, but t…

This hole thing is kind of frightening. I'm not sure i like the philosophy here.

Re: Ask PG: Any chance of an update on "What I've learned from Hacker News"?

#99

Post by doesitwork »

RageKit wrote: post #98
doesitwork wrote: post #95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I honestly don't know. The first ban, my comments disappeared, but another person was kind enough to let me know it had happened. I could still see my comments, but nobody else could. The person who let me know was in the middle of a thread/conversation with me, had very high karma, took a look at my account and couldn't find any reason for the ban. I looked for somewhere to ask for clarification on how or why, but t…

This hole thing is kind of frightening. I'm not sure i like the philosophy here.

I think a lot of people find it comforting. Internet forums admittedly attract bullies in the form of trolls, astroturfers and people who are just plain mean. I agree in principle with a moderation system, but to have a secret moderation system, with no transparency and no recourse is susceptible to corruption and abuse, like any secret system is.

At any rate, those who find it comforting that 'big brother' is keeping the comments safe for them will stay around, and those with dissenting views will be banned to oblivion and eventually leave, making the community a small selection of people who both agree with the philosophy, and find it uncomfortable to deal with views that challenge their philosophy.

This is very similar to what happened in Academia in the past 30 years, and succeeded in pushing out all of the interesting, eccentric and creative people, leaving only those who knew the party line, and moderated their speech accordingly. I think this is not healthy for creativity, but then, that's just my opinion, and obviously the forum owner/moderators disagree.

Re: Ask PG: Any chance of an update on "What I've learned from Hacker News"?

#100

Post by RageKit »

doesitwork wrote: post #99
RageKit wrote: post #98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This hole thing is kind of frightening. I'm not sure i like the philosophy here.

I think a lot of people find it comforting. Internet forums admittedly attract bullies in the form of trolls, astroturfers and people who are just plain mean. I agree in principle with a moderation system, but to have a secret moderation system, with no transparency and no recourse is susceptible to corruption and abuse, like any secret system is. At any rate, those who find it comforting that 'big brother' is keepin…

You could think it might be different in a community promoting startups and out of the box thinking ...
Post reply on HN