Live data from Hacker News

List of 200 UK companies that moved to 4-day working week

future4days.com

71–80 of 96 posts

Re: List of 200 UK companies that moved to 4-day working week

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Personally, I don’t see how it helps in their current political climate. Inflation and energy costs are a huge problem in the UK right now and that would lead to the assumption that people need to earn more. Going to a 4 day work week seems counter to the idea of earning more. Perhaps at the very high end (corporate management, etc) where companies can afford keep salaries the same without expecting more output, but…

There is also aspect of having 1 extra day and no money to do anything meaningful with it. UK wages are already poor and cost of living is insane. Are you going to spend that day in your sorry mould ridden flat with other housemates also skint with nothing else to do? Where do you even go? Shops are dead, public transport is unaffordable and state of it resembles soviet union near its collapse, entertainment, attract…

This is a bit dramatic, sure some people have to share a mouldy flat but most software engineers I know are doing ok

Re: List of 200 UK companies that moved to 4-day working week

#72
post #49
post #38

36 hours is the standard in my country- it's called progress. A century ago it was probably 80 hours for everyone over 12 lol.

However, the free market dictates that you will be outcompeted by anyone who is willing to work 40+ hours. So much for progress.

That's not necessarily true.

Maybe people can't produce more than 4 days of work per week or 5 hours per day; in that case the productivity would be the same and people working more are essentially wasting time.

My empirical evidence say otherwise (sample_size=1) I can be quite productive up to ~70hrs doing knowledge work (I've been on it for 8 months, hours are tracked and connected to tasks, no idling is counted), but that's pushing it and it might not be sustainable for longer period of time. My will to live is certainly at historical lows.

Lawyers in big law can also do 60-80 hours (while ruining their life) so I think it's reasonable.

I've heard people in other professions (eg. nurses) pushing 90-100hrs but they are not actively thinking all their working time.

Re: List of 200 UK companies that moved to 4-day working week

#73
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

would you be twice as productive working 80 hours a week as you are at 40? surely there's diminishing returns, and it doesn't seem obvious that 40 is the sweet spot.

You can barely even have a single income household anymore these days, thanks to the free market. If progress exists, it's going in the wrong direction.

we don't have a free market, it's highly regulated

Re: List of 200 UK companies that moved to 4-day working week

#74
post #38

36 hours is the standard in my country- it's called progress. A century ago it was probably 80 hours for everyone over 12 lol.

36 hours is 5 days a week, unless you work ridiculously long days.

9 hours is considered ridiculously wrong?

Re: List of 200 UK companies that moved to 4-day working week

#75
post #33

I am co-founder of a 5 year old tech startup with 50 staff that introduced a 4dww / 32hr work week a little over 2 years ago. Since are a lot of questions surrounding 4dww - Thought I might be able to offer some insights. 1. “four days but actually working longer” or “four days with reduced hours”. -- We offer 32hrs work week, rather than the standard 40hrs in our home country. This is generally taken as 4 days, but…

Professional salaries in NZ are less than half of those in the US.

I can see how this makes sense, if this perk is enough to stop your low cost labor from chasing greenbacks instead.

Re: List of 200 UK companies that moved to 4-day working week

#76

Just like remote work, this turns into a culture war issue every time (and the comments turn into a cesspit). I really wish people would stop arguing and let the market show us what's actually more effective.

The market is strongly influenced by the culture though. For example nothing now is actually different to before covid. The only thing that has changed is the culture - people like working from home and are less willing to give it up. Working hours is simply a negotiation between employers (who obviously want more hours for the same price), and workers (who want the opposite). Again culture has a large influence on t…

Sure, but the point I'm making is that figuring out whether this stuff works is easy - you let companies decide, you let them fairly pay employees, and you see which companies turn out on top.

Re: List of 200 UK companies that moved to 4-day working week

#77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

... Except the obvious argument for a 4 day week is that in a knowledge economy, downtime is more critical to meaningful work. People like Tolkien don't just write 9-5, there's no reason consultants or programmers should work that way, it just doesn't scale.

Knowledge work does require time where you are mulling over the problem, rather than executing, but that isn’t downtime. Reducing working hours, in most cases, will reduce time spent doing both those tasks. If Tolkien took an additional day off each week, it absolutely would have increased the time taken to complete his works.

... are you not at all more productive the week right after a holiday than when you've been crunching for 5 months straight with no time off? Because I bloody know I am. Knowledge work really can't just be conveniently bundled into units of productive vs unproductive time like making widgets.

Re: List of 200 UK companies that moved to 4-day working week

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Knowledge work does require time where you are mulling over the problem, rather than executing, but that isn’t downtime. Reducing working hours, in most cases, will reduce time spent doing both those tasks. If Tolkien took an additional day off each week, it absolutely would have increased the time taken to complete his works.

... are you not at all more productive the week right after a holiday than when you've been crunching for 5 months straight with no time off? Because I bloody know I am. Knowledge work really can't just be conveniently bundled into units of productive vs unproductive time like making widgets.

There’s no quality evidence that reducing hours worked below 40 hours increases productivity per hour.

All research done to date shows that productivity per hour is flat until about 60 hours or even higher for low skill work.

What you’re doing is called motivated reasoning. You want to believe that you can work less and still get the same amount done, so you cling to whatever nebulous explanation you can find to support it.

The reality is that you work less hours, you get less done.

Re: List of 200 UK companies that moved to 4-day working week

#79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

International competition is the interesting thing for me, if we can prove a 4 day week in any form would be similarly efficient, that could give a great incentive to hiring the top talent and convincing them to migrate to the nation's that standardized it. If it turns out that it's less efficient in the long run, then it would cause the whole nation to fall behind, reducing total comp possible, and leading to the mo…

Alternatively, international worker solidarity should be the model we work for, as we did with the current 5-day work week. It was neither productivity studies nor economic competitiveness that solidified the 5-day work week, it was workers demanding it under threat of violence and agreeing (or being coerced) not to break strikes even internationally. Throughout human history, this has always been the only model that…

You’re living in the past.

That model worked when people were much more equal in output, before the ambitious could leverage skills and tools to become an order of magnitude more productive than average.

It’ll never work today, because there’s too many people in too many industries who outperform the average worker 10:1.

Collective bargaining is quite unfair to those people and they’ll never accept it.

Re: List of 200 UK companies that moved to 4-day working week

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is also aspect of having 1 extra day and no money to do anything meaningful with it. UK wages are already poor and cost of living is insane. Are you going to spend that day in your sorry mould ridden flat with other housemates also skint with nothing else to do? Where do you even go? Shops are dead, public transport is unaffordable and state of it resembles soviet union near its collapse, entertainment, attract…

This is a bit dramatic, sure some people have to share a mouldy flat but most software engineers I know are doing ok

"doing ok" or "barely keeping head above water". Is not a good look, when you have people doing demanding engineering jobs that require skill and years of education, that they have to keep themselves up to date learning past 9-5. I know married senior developer with two kids, 20 years of experience, still saving for deposit for a flat (as house is now out of reach). Rents are going up and so the property prices so they can't catch up. His wife can't work full time, because of children and nursery etc is unaffordable. They have not been on holidays since Covid and employer is talking about downsizing. Man is 40 and looks like 50 due to stress. I know a couple of developers who are single, yes they do "okay", but they are nowhere near in a position to start a family. It's grim. Then you have wage compression where really doing warehouse job doesn't get you much worse living standard than typical developer. You will have shittier flat, maybe extra housemate and you will shop in Aldi instead of Waitrose. That's very much the difference right now.
Post reply on HN