Live data from Hacker News

Purelymail: Cheap, no-nonsense email

purelymail.com

61–70 of 221 posts

Re: Purelymail: Cheap, no-nonsense email

#61

Do you want free email for multiple addresses on multiple domains with all the features of a Gmail? Just setup Cloudflare to manage your email, create rules to forward to regular Gmail accounts, which you can configure to send email from your domains. 100% free.

iirc with this setup, Google just changes the "reply-to" and someone can still figure out your actual Gmail address.

Re: Purelymail: Cheap, no-nonsense email

#62
They're a very nice service. I set it up with a custom domain a few years back and forgot about it and recently realized I had negative $9 in credits. I couldn't log into the webmail to access the emails there and it seems they stopped accepting emails. But as soon as I paid the $9 and topped up with a little more credit I was able to access everything.

Re: Purelymail: Cheap, no-nonsense email

#63
post #59

An interesting service, and very competitively priced. But for me, my email is fairly mission-critical. It's not something I'm prepared to endow in a one-man shop. I don't mean to offend, but it looks like something that might be used as something of a novelty. Were I to use it, I'd be backing up my email locally.

You should be backing up your email locally regardless, even if you use Google Workspace or Fastmail.

Re: Purelymail: Cheap, no-nonsense email

#64

Do you want free email for multiple addresses on multiple domains with all the features of a Gmail? Just setup Cloudflare to manage your email, create rules to forward to regular Gmail accounts, which you can configure to send email from your domains. 100% free.

I do want all the features of a Gmail, I just don’t want Google going through it.

Re: Purelymail: Cheap, no-nonsense email

#65
post #27

How difficult is exporting from one provider into another (e.g. from gmail into proton or purely)? I guess normies like me are a bit hesitant due to the risk of messing it up (would be a disaster to lose years of emails, as some are important for record-keeping). Curious to hear from people who've done(/attempted) it and how it went? Was it hard? Were there risks? Any regrets?

Last year I migrated from my hosting providers email service to Proton Mail after 20 years. I too was worried about preserving mails.

I have used Thunderbird for everything, set to download everything and never delete, so had my primary backup there. I take regular backups of the profile directory as secondary measure, which are kept on my NAS and offsite.

What I did was to just decide to do a hard break. I renamed the old IMAP accounts, added the Proton Mail accounts using the IMAP bridge, and then configured my DNS to point to Proton.

DMARC and all that was easily set up as well thanks to Proton having nice guides and active verification.

Now I still have access to my old mail in my old account folder, and I can use the Proton Mail app on my phone for new stuff.

I also migrated a secondary mail, which was not using my domain and which I've had for almost three decades. There I had to do the laborious task of changing any accounts tied to it, and notify people still using it. I've been keeping it operational for a year and still get the occasional mail, but at a point where I'll be retiring it soon.

Overall been very happy. It showed me it was easier than I feared as long as I have Thunderbird and mail accounts under my own domain.

Re: Purelymail: Cheap, no-nonsense email

#66
post #61

Do you want free email for multiple addresses on multiple domains with all the features of a Gmail? Just setup Cloudflare to manage your email, create rules to forward to regular Gmail accounts, which you can configure to send email from your domains. 100% free.

iirc with this setup, Google just changes the "reply-to" and someone can still figure out your actual Gmail address.

I think you can still add an SMTP server in Gmail, and it will use that (with a proper From header, DKIM and all).

Re: Purelymail: Cheap, no-nonsense email

#68

Do you want free email for multiple addresses on multiple domains with all the features of a Gmail? Just setup Cloudflare to manage your email, create rules to forward to regular Gmail accounts, which you can configure to send email from your domains. 100% free.

Could you say more? Is there a tutorial I could follow?

Re: Purelymail: Cheap, no-nonsense email

#69
post #63
post #59

An interesting service, and very competitively priced. But for me, my email is fairly mission-critical. It's not something I'm prepared to endow in a one-man shop. I don't mean to offend, but it looks like something that might be used as something of a novelty. Were I to use it, I'd be backing up my email locally.

You should be backing up your email locally regardless, even if you use Google Workspace or Fastmail.

I don't agree with you. A key reason to host your email with a reliable cloud storage provider is to have backups handled for you. Fastmail is particularly good in that respect, since it takes periodic backups for you, allowing deleted items to be accessed.

To put things in perspective, I dare say that many large commercial organisations who rely on Office 365 are not backing up emails locally. They do likely have fancy retention holds preventing nefarious actors who compromise access to the account nuking things. I think Fastmail's backup is limited to 7 days. Outside that is a risk; it's one I'll take.

Maybe we have different perceptions of risk. But I think one can reasonably take the view it is unnecessary to have an independent copy in this scenario.

Post reply on HN