Live data from Hacker News

Mixxx: GPL DJ Software

mixxx.org

81–90 of 140 posts

Re: Mixxx: GPL DJ Software

#81
post #2

What does GPL stand for?

Not sure whether to be dismayed or excited at the fact that this is a question on Hacker News, but those who are new to it; definitely worth doing your homework.

It's the legal jiu-jitsu that has enabled Linux and countless other "Open Source" projects to remain free by preventing people from taking the code for free but then locking it back down.

Re: Mixxx: GPL DJ Software

#82

I use it simply as an audio player. I like the way I can queue up songs and then let the Auto DJ play. I know other audio players can in principle do that but in Mixx it is very explicit. I also like to see key and BPM just to satisfy my curiosity.

Never thought of this, I use it mostly for live mixing but I probably never tried the Auto DJ feature. I need to give it a try, it would probably be a lot more inspiring to play my collection that way instead of in a traditional music player. Great tip!

Re: Mixxx: GPL DJ Software

#83

I want to do scratching by pushing a button on my laptop keyboard (instead of dragging the spinning record with my mouse-cursor). Can Mixxx do this?

Not sure if that's mappable, but I don't think that would provide enough control to get satisfying results.

Re: Mixxx: GPL DJ Software

#84

RekordBox is a well known piece of s** and it's great to see someone try to enter the arena. Now we need a legit competitor to the DJM / CDJ's which cost, all told, >$10k for a standard, club-ready setup.

I didn't know it was well known but that's exactly how I felt when I recently tried to use it. My local bar bought an integrated 2 deck Pioneer DJ player, but turns out it doesn't store analyzed BPMs or waveforms and to get that you need to use RekordBox to analyze your tracks and export that to your USBs. When I tried to install the software it requires signing up for an account and a subscription and what not. I still couldn't get it to work and abandoned it. I won't be going back to it the experience isnt worth it. I'm instead having more fun just beatmatching by ear with the pitch fader :)

Re: Mixxx: GPL DJ Software

#85

Been using Mixxx since 2015, I haven't liked every update they put out, but its always been solid software.

I have also probably used it on and off for 10+ years, but don't recall any bad updates. What did you encounter that you didn't like if I may ask?

Re: Mixxx: GPL DJ Software

#86
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I considered renting out some Pioneer equipment to add RekordBox playlist writing support, mainly because I'm in a similar situation. Mixxx does have support for reading USBs & SD cards, but not writing ;_; Unfortunately it's far down my priority list given the cost, my unfamiliarity with Mixxx development and that I rarely do anything without Mixx. But this is absolutely what ecosystem grants/bounties should be for.

> But this is absolutely what ecosystem grants/bounties should be for. I'd be down to fund a bounty/grant for this (and I'm clearly not alone), if anyone is looking for booty :)

I'm a bit annoyed by the requirement of having to use rekordbox exports on some DJ devices and would probably chip in to this because I will definitely not try to install rekordbox again :D

Re: Mixxx: GPL DJ Software

#89
post #5

Been using it for the past few years, nothing bad to say about it, lovely piece of software. Vendor lock-in is very present in this field, with different brands of controllers supported by a myriad of proprietary DJ applications all more interested in onboarding you to their music subscription services rather than implement useful features or support open protocols. Meanwhile, Mixxx allows you to write your own adapt…

To be fair, every commercial competitor (like Rekordbox and Traktor) also supports mapping MIDI devices that are not officially supported. But in my experience, you'll never be able to control the jogwheel as precisely as in officially-supported hardware-software combo.

In Rekordbox's case Pioneer have restricted the jogwheel mapping to Pioneer hardware only. So, you pretty much need Pioneer hardware to use Rekordbox. And seeing as Pioneer decks are almost industry standard in clubs and you need Rekordbox to organise your playlists, they have the DJ hardware market sewn up. Which is very frustrating because Rekordbox has to be the most resource intensive (& therefore inefficient) DJ software available.

Re: Mixxx: GPL DJ Software

#90
I use it as my main software for my Traktor Kontrol S2.

Some Lights are buggy and the fix is not yet out.

Also Highlighting Tracks based on a fitting Key is only availible in the Alpha Branch of the software, which obivously has lots of other issues.

Besides that its an easy software which can handle all of my other feature requirements and it runs really nice.

So i would really recommend it ;)

Post reply on HN