Live data from Hacker News

Sparrow acquired by Google

sprw.me

181–190 of 393 posts

Re: Sparrow acquired by Google

#181
Once again, kids: recurring revenue models. It appears to be the only way to build sustainable, quality software these days.

I love, love thick clients (even though I'm an ambivelent web guy) but every time I see an app as a one-time $10 or even $99 shot, I think: how are they gonna survive in the long run?

Re: Sparrow acquired by Google

#182

This is a huge accomplishment for the Sparrow team. Now lets hope Google doesn't do what they do best and ruin this beautiful app.

They won't ruin it, because they have announced their intention to stop development.

Where did they say that? It says in their announcement that they are going to continue to support it. Do you just mean active development?

Re: Sparrow acquired by Google

#184
post #46

This is getting extremely frustrating. Sparrow is a fabulous email client both for iOS and Mac. I love and use both daily and this is fairly devastating. I was really looking forward to the products development, growth, and future releases. To read this announcement and hear that they won't be working on their apps but on Google projects is sad. To bigger companies: chill out with the "acquihires." If anything, do wh…

> This is getting extremely frustrating. Sparrow is a fabulous email client both for iOS and Mac. I love and use both daily and this is fairly devastating. I was really looking forward to the products development, growth, and future releases. To read this announcement and hear that they won't be working on their apps but on Google projects is sad.

I think it's a matter of perspective. As someone who doesn't use and has no intention of ever using OS X or iOS, this is great news for me! I've been hearing a lot about Sparrow's revolutionary UI, but haven't benefited at all because they don't support Linux, Android, or Windows. Now, there's a very good chance that some of Sparrow's UI features will be incorporated into the Gmail web UI and into the Gmail apps for Android phones and tablets.

Re: Sparrow acquired by Google

#185
Happy for the Sparrow folks, not so happy for my fellow users and me. I am using it since the beta and they kept promising from that version on that they would add the one missing feature for me (and a dozen of other users): undo support. I stopped using Sparrow for this only reason; then at 1.6 I started using it again; just to see where it was at; lovely UI but one CPU hogging little app. Sad to see these show-stoppers will now never be picked up in the future Sparrow. Who will be the new kid on the block?

Re: Sparrow acquired by Google

#186
Maybe there is a small chance a window client might shows up in the pipeline :)

Anyway, there is a mail client (that began as a project of midori's author) that looks a little bit like sparrow: http://redmine.yorba.org/projects/geary/wiki

It's very early in its dev. stage though.

Re: Sparrow acquired by Google

#187

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They won't ruin it, because they have announced their intention to stop development.

Where did they say that? It says in their announcement that they are going to continue to support it. Do you just mean active development?

From the announcement: "... we do not plan to release new features for the Sparrow apps."

Support is not "development" if you are just fixing outstanding issues, that's "maintenance".

Re: Sparrow acquired by Google

#188
post #116
post #101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A good app has been EOL'd so the developer(s) can go work on a known crappy app. We've gone from "known good" to "hopefully this will work out and the gmail iOS app will be good"... how is that not frustrating if you're a fan of the iOS apps? As for the Sparrow desktop app, well, obviously Google isn't going to be developing a native desktop app for Gmail...

Sorry, but Gmail isn't a crappy app in my way of thinking. It was the best webmail in 2004, and it still is. You may not like it, but that doesn't extrapolate to crappiness. Although I'm sorry that Sparrow is being end-of-lifed, Gmail is a best of breed web app. well, obviously Google isn't going to be developing a native desktop app for Gmail. Sounds like a feature to me, not a bug. Desktop software is going out. Wh…

I quite like being able to answer email when I'm in a railway tunnel, on a transatlantic flight or in a 3G dead zone.

Desktop software is quite useful if you haven't bought into all the post-PC hoopla and still like typing things on a keyboard.

Re: Sparrow acquired by Google

#189
post #18

My first reaction was - oh fuck. Am I alone.

Right there with you. Sparrow is effectively done now. Gmail itself doesn't need the improvements, the clients need to improve, which won't happen if they join the gmail team.

Google is essentially lobbying against actual mail clients. They think gmail is all you need. They'll just buy anyone who disagrees :-P

Re: Sparrow acquired by Google

#190
post #127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If the entire mission of the company was to make a Gmail-only mail client, why did they allow the use of other IMAP services? They should have stuck with Gmail only if that was their true mission.

To add value and broaden the appeal. The first version of Sparrow for Mac only supported Gmail. Even after adding IMAP, there was no reason anyone who didn't use Gmail would buy Sparrow, because everything it did differently from the standard Mac Mail app was oriented around Gmail.

The primary good thing about Sparrow for the Mac is the simplicity and lack of bloat compared to Mail.app. Lack of bloat is nice regardless of what mail server you use.
Post reply on HN