Live data from Hacker News

Has Canada Become a Jamaican Bobsled Team?

jaymartin.substack.com

11–14 of 14 posts

Re: Has Canada Become a Jamaican Bobsled Team?

#11
post #3

>I don’t feel pride in being Canadian because pride, to me, is reserved for accomplishments >I had no part in being born in Canada, nor shaping this lovely country ... a country filled with opportunity and beauty, where hard work is rewarded, and life is governed fairly and predictably >I am proud of my ancestors ... who crossed oceans, who spoke no English, and settled in the rugged, frozen prairies of Saskatchewan.…

All your points are examples of luck compounded over time. Let's take your example of not being born in a hut in Tanzania. That bit of luck is called the birth lottery and has a major influence on one's life. It defines the resources you have growing up, including school systems, community, and medical care. Then, it extends into networks known by your parents, influencing where you get into college/university and wh…

I believe it's actually...

This is ten percent luck, twenty percent skill Fifteen percent concentrated power of will Five percent pleasure, fifty percent pain

Re: Has Canada Become a Jamaican Bobsled Team?

#12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's not luck. See my reply to the other guy. You are your parents' son. Unless your parents are Tanzanian hut-dwellers, there was no chance of that occurring.

I suggest spending more time reading up on the impact of the birth lottery. the OP didn't choose to be born to Canadian parents any more than the that a child chose to be born to Tanzanian parents. In either case, the child's life trajectory has been significantly constrained by their parents' social standing, wealth and health. https://www.technologyreview.com/2018/03/01/144958/if-youre-...

No amount of reading is going to make this possible. It's not chance. It's not a lottery.

The foal doesn't choose to be born to a mare any more than a lamb to a ewe.

Re: Has Canada Become a Jamaican Bobsled Team?

#14
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I suggest spending more time reading up on the impact of the birth lottery. the OP didn't choose to be born to Canadian parents any more than the that a child chose to be born to Tanzanian parents. In either case, the child's life trajectory has been significantly constrained by their parents' social standing, wealth and health. https://www.technologyreview.com/2018/03/01/144958/if-youre-...

No amount of reading is going to make this possible. It's not chance. It's not a lottery. The foal doesn't choose to be born to a mare any more than a lamb to a ewe.

That's the whole point. You have no agency over who your parents are or who the child is. When there is no ability to choose and no agency, what you get is a matter of luck.
Post reply on HN