Live data from Hacker News

The engineering behind the San Antonio River Walk

practical.engineering

31–40 of 54 posts

Re: The engineering behind the San Antonio River Walk

#31
Interesting and refreshing choice to stick to a pure textual description without the usual torrent of photos. Needs frequent looking up of terms though :-)

As for the river walk itself, living in Amsterdam predisposes you to treat the bone-dry, car infested asphalt and concrete jungles we call cities as weird places where humanity aggregates for ritualistic suffering. Discovering that San Antonio is different was a great and pleasant surprise.

Re: The engineering behind the San Antonio River Walk

#32
I just watched the gate replacement video with my mom 2 days ago. She's from SA. It's neat that they thought to turn it into a tourist thing rather than fill it in. Sometimes, the most expedient choice isn't the best one.

If you're ever downtown, checkout the Chihuly installations in the main library. https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/fiesta-tower

Re: The engineering behind the San Antonio River Walk

#33
post #17

The first time I visited San Antonio I'd never heard of the river walk. We were simply walking along the street downtown and saw some stairs leading down and many people taking them so we went down and a whole magical world opened up. (I went back later and it wasn't nearly as magical).

You make it sound like Rivendell

Re: The engineering behind the San Antonio River Walk

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because it goes against the everything is bigger in Texas narrative. It’s just hard to express how small it is until you’ve been there. Once you are there, it’s just underwhelming.

Doesn’t the small size make it more impressive that the Texians held out for so long?

Not really. At the time of the battle the complex covered several acres, with the buildings built in a squarish shape around a courtyard. The Mexican army burnt most of the buildings down out of spite as they retreated, and like most other ruins it was mined for stone and brick to build new buildings with.

Really only the chapel is left, and that was never intended for anything other than church services for a few hundred people.

Re: The engineering behind the San Antonio River Walk

#35
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why does a building have to be large in order to be historically important?

Because it goes against the everything is bigger in Texas narrative. It’s just hard to express how small it is until you’ve been there. Once you are there, it’s just underwhelming.

You may have misunderstood what you were looking at. All that is really left is the chapel. It’s just a church sized for a few hundred people. All of the houses, offices, barracks, work rooms, stables, storehouses, defensive works, etc, etc are all gone. They were left to rot when the place was abandoned for a decade or two, then cleaned up when there was an army present, heavily damaged in a certain famous battle that you might remember, partially repaired by the occupying Mexican army, then burnt down again as they left. Only the chapel remains, and that’s because the walls were built of limestone blocks four feet thick. They were too solid to tear down and couldn’t be burnt.

Re: The engineering behind the San Antonio River Walk

#36
post #8

Having grown up in San Antonio, I have many memories of spending time as a teenager downtown and around the river walk. The best time to visit is during the riverboat parade after Thanksgiving. Everything is lit up and many restaurants along the route offer dinner and nice views. Going during the summer can be incredibly hot and uncomfortable.

Yes, agreed! The first time I visited San Antonio (as a Brit who was based in Dallas for some months) happened to be at exactly that time. We didn't know anything about it, but found ourselves on the river walk in the evening, and along came the parade of boats bringing Pancho Claus & co... it was a lovely surprise and a beautiful evening.

Re: The engineering behind the San Antonio River Walk

#37

Interesting and refreshing choice to stick to a pure textual description without the usual torrent of photos. Needs frequent looking up of terms though :-) As for the river walk itself, living in Amsterdam predisposes you to treat the bone-dry, car infested asphalt and concrete jungles we call cities as weird places where humanity aggregates for ritualistic suffering. Discovering that San Antonio is different was a g…

> Interesting and refreshing choice to stick to a pure textual description without the usual torrent of photos. Needs frequent looking up of terms though :-)

It's the transcript of a video (at the top), so there is little reason to bother with pictures: if you want visuals you can watch the video, or use it as a slideshow.

Re: The engineering behind the San Antonio River Walk

#38

I thought the way he referenced the hydraulic pumps compared to electric motors with gear shafts was interesting.

I spent much of the video wishing for an expansion of the pros and cons though, and why electric motors had been selected originally, and hydraulic pumps had been selected as their replacement.

Re: The engineering behind the San Antonio River Walk

#39

Grew in San Antonio as well and one of the best parts about the Riverwalk is that it offers a fantastic pedestrian corridor across almost the entirety of downtown San Antonio and connects a lot of really interesting places, The missions down south, Pearl Brewery and it's shopping district, downtown mall and Convention center as well as La Villita and The Art Museum. Sure you can walk the streets but getting around vi…

San antonio is easily my favkrite city in the US. Awesome, food, events, bars, music scene (saw some sweet ultraviolence bads there) etc. The city is pretty, clean,easy to navigate. Its just great

[deleted]

Re: The engineering behind the San Antonio River Walk

#40
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As someone who went to public school in Texas, the textbooks in Texas are vetted by revisionists who still claim the Civil War was about states rights and not slavery, my civic teacher argued this repeatedly in the 1980s. A lot of kids are indoctrinated with the BS that downplay the slavery aspect, it's like the Big Lie of the south.

1984 / George Orwell: 'Who controls the past controls the future. Who controls the present controls the past.'

[deleted]
Post reply on HN