Live data from Hacker News

Meta is killing off its AI-powered Instagram and Facebook profiles

theguardian.com

551–560 of 605 posts

Re: Meta is killing off its AI-powered Instagram and Facebook profiles

#551

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As someone who's built something like it in their free time as a hobby project ( https://github.com/rmusser01/tldw ), could I ask what would make it a professional product vs something an intern came up with? Looking for insights I could possibly apply/learn from to implement in my own project. One of my goals with my project I ended up taking on was to match/exceed NotebookLMs feature set, to ensure that an open sou…

I'm going to challenge you to put that first screenshot into ChatGPT/Claude and ask them why it looks like something an intern came up with vs a professional product. I'm not saying that as a slight or an insult, but right now the screenshot looks like a Gradio space someone would use to prove out the underlying tech of a professional product, not a professional product (unless you literally mean professionals are yo…

I could not have said this better myself.

Re: Meta is killing off its AI-powered Instagram and Facebook profiles

#552

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I guess I really don't understand the context because even with this clarification it's not clear what you're asking past "what does it take to add polish to my nascent project", when the reality is by the nature of it's nascent state no one is going to be able to give you more than surface level advice (which the LLM can provide pretty effectively, and in a more tailored way than we random commenters can. Isn't that…

You’re making assumptions about my original question. I wished to know their opinion on what made NotebookLM ‘look like an Intern’s project. If what they shared was something I agreed with and relevant than sure I would apply it to my project but I already have plans for improving my project to my own standards. Thanks for sharing your perspective though, I will keep it in mind. I disagree regarding podcasts being a…

plans for improving my project to my own standards.

That’s roughly the implication of my original comment. Many developers, including you, have a higher standard. I’m not gonna use something that looks like an intern slapped a few REST calls together with MUI.

It’s 2025 dude, I can build that in an afternoon. They have to take the product a lot more seriously.

Google’s lack of taste on this front will be the success of another competing product (perhaps even yours).

Re: Meta is killing off its AI-powered Instagram and Facebook profiles

#553
post #314

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It will take me some time to dig up with all the noise around AI, but this reminds me of a paper published around 2018 or so that explored the possibility of two such AI forming an accidental trust by optimizing around each other. For example, if the denying AI used frequency of denied claims as a heuristic for success, and the AI drafting claims used the claim amount for the same, then the two bots may unknowingly s…

Wow, that sounds very interesting, do you have some link to that paper?

I'm on the hunt, but no luck. I've tried a myriad of search terms to dig it up, but none are able to surface the paper through all the vaporware and blog pieces on competitive AI.

Re: Meta is killing off its AI-powered Instagram and Facebook profiles

#554
post #314

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It will take me some time to dig up with all the noise around AI, but this reminds me of a paper published around 2018 or so that explored the possibility of two such AI forming an accidental trust by optimizing around each other. For example, if the denying AI used frequency of denied claims as a heuristic for success, and the AI drafting claims used the claim amount for the same, then the two bots may unknowingly s…

I feel that this sort of autonomous agent co-optimization may happen more often over time as humans step farther away from the loop, and lead to some pretty weird outcomes with nobody around to go "wait what the f---- are we doing?"

Agreed, and I'm even further worried about the plausible deniability these situations would create.

Re: Meta is killing off its AI-powered Instagram and Facebook profiles

#555
post #357

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder why so few companies employ Pixar’s Brain Trust method. You get into a room with a bunch of key execs who are not part of your project and then they tear your product/movie/idea apart. You don’t have to implement any of their suggestions but since these are seasoned execs they see flaws readily. The key is that the process encourages candid feedback without hierarchy or defensiveness. This goes on for a coup…

Requires really secure upper management (think Steve Jobs, or John Lasseter). Those types of folks are not representative of most tech C-Suite denizens.

Damn. You’re probably right.

I find this insight so frustrating though. Isn’t that exactly what upper management is supposed to be doing and what they’re paid for after all?

Re: Meta is killing off its AI-powered Instagram and Facebook profiles

#556
post #555

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Requires really secure upper management (think Steve Jobs, or John Lasseter). Those types of folks are not representative of most tech C-Suite denizens.

Damn. You’re probably right. I find this insight so frustrating though. Isn’t that exactly what upper management is supposed to be doing and what they’re paid for after all?

Yup.

Re: Meta is killing off its AI-powered Instagram and Facebook profiles

#557
post #482
post #424

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, docs have seen this coming from miles away. I don't think anyone having substantial experience in clinical medicine is surprised by those developments, unfortunately. But it doesn't stop here. Insurance companies will be (are) building models to overcome legal barriers. Imagine: you're 20 and healthy, but located somewhere suggesting a higher risk of developing some chronic disease in the future ? Then no insur…

That's one reason (among many) the preexisting condition part of ACA is so important. Without it, health insurance companies would have every incentive to do what car insurance companies do -- buy profiles and records from third parties and use those to adjust rates and willingness to insure. E.g. the obvious step of buying genetic information from 23andme, because it isn't covered by HIPAA

GINA prohibits health insurance companies from using genetics to deny coverage or set premiums.

https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/special-topics/g...

Re: Meta is killing off its AI-powered Instagram and Facebook profiles

#558

You know what AI profiles I want more of? Clueless grandma/grandpa that accepts scammer calls and waste their time. Such as UK's O2 Daisy: https://news.virginmediao2.co.uk/o2-unveils-daisy-the-ai-gra...

It's a funny thought on the surface, but the people working these scams are typically slaves, more or less. I'd rather go after their slavers than waste electricity to waste their time.

It's sad you're downvoted, because you're right. So called "anti-scammers" who make a fortune on Youtube or that Reddit apparently considers heroes, are in effect preying on the poor. The real culprits are the bosses, not the ones doing the phone calls.

Re: Meta is killing off its AI-powered Instagram and Facebook profiles

#559

This reminds me of the experiments FB was doing to control user emotion. Vibes of the same sliminess. But beyond that, has social media not isolated people enough--soon, a large portion of people using it won't even interact with other actual people... I don't see how a platform meant to "connect" people to others--scratch that, a platform meant to connect people to ad's makes perfect sense.

The only reason I can think that this atrocity got deployed was from an engineering perspective, creating AI profiles to engage theoretically gives FB a powerful lever to increase engagement, because you'd have this entire new field to collect data, experiment and test people's responses. In other words, it would turn engagement into a form tractable to optimisation algorithms.

Re: Meta is killing off its AI-powered Instagram and Facebook profiles

#560
post #202

What happened to the Metaverse? Not snarky, but it also seems like it has been killed off in favor of AI investments?

The feeling I'm getting is management took such a huge stance (the capex, the name change, etc) on it it'd be humiliating to turn 180 and ditch it now (they've spent 50 billion on Reality Labs so far). So they're quietly pushing it aside and one day when people aren't looking, they'll take it to the back of the house and shoot it in the head. Probably call it an "internal re-org" or something like that.
Post reply on HN