Live data from Hacker News

Why has no one replaced speakerphones yet?

news.ycombinator.com

1–6 of 6 posts

Why has no one replaced speakerphones yet?

#1
To the budding entrepreneurs of Hacker News, I issue a challenge: develop a technology to replace speakerphones. There is nothing like being on the receiving end of a speakerphone and straining to understand what the guy in the back of the room is trying to say.

I can't say how this should work - that's up to you to work out. One solution might entail everyone synchronizing their smart phones. Another solution might involve a receiver and a room full of bluetooth headsets.

Perhaps I am thinking too narrowly about the problem, and some brand new mode of teleconferencing will render speakerphones obsolete. Regardless, thanks for your consideration! I look forward to never having to talk to a speakerphone again.

Re: Why has no one replaced speakerphones yet?

#4
Ohk, so this idea pops up in my mind.

An application to direct calls from your speakerphones when you're at home (or office) [Can be done via NFC or Same Wifi connection]. Without sacrificing the quality of your conversation.

I'd love to see this feature in Android, quite possible.

Pros:

- You don't have to get up for a call every time

- Great Quality

- Hackable for Developers

Cons:

- You have to built a special hardware for that

Re: Why has no one replaced speakerphones yet?

#5

Speakerphones are a get-what-you-pay-for kind of thing. Polycom speakerphones are expensive, but they work really well.

I agree. The polycoms with secondary microphones pick up those guys in the background you care about.

Being entrenched in the corporate culture, if you tried to sell my department on a brand new "speakerphone" that required the use of my cell phone, or was enhanced by my cell phone, I'm going to ask why my phone isn't corporate issued then, if I have to use it on all of my work conference calls.

If everyone used their own phone, then you might as well dial into a bridge, and I think that's a solved problem.

Re: Why has no one replaced speakerphones yet?

#6

Speakerphones are a get-what-you-pay-for kind of thing. Polycom speakerphones are expensive, but they work really well.

Enable G.722/HD Voice and use a set of satellite microphones for the room, problem solved.

I love Polycoms and was sad to see my employeer recently replace them with Cisco units (who designed the button layout of the 7937?).