Live data from Hacker News

Looking for the best forum software to start a new forum community in 2025

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 46 posts

Re: Looking for the best forum software to start a new forum community in 2025

#21

For shared hosting I guess Flarum would be the best choice. However, if you want to go with more advanced you can use Discourse but it does not work with shared hosting

Hi! Thanks for your comment. I strongly appreciate this, and would take into consideration.

Re: Looking for the best forum software to start a new forum community in 2025

#24
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

seconded. I love forums that use this. Easy to spin up as well.

I agreed. But I plan to run this forum on a shared hosting through, and I don't think it is possible.

Discourse can be self-hosted as well

Re: Looking for the best forum software to start a new forum community in 2025

#25

Comment castles: https://github.com/ferg1e/comment-castles (I'm the developer)

Do you have any suggestions on deploying? I looked over the readme. I’m not understanding how to go from clone to cloud. Meetup sucks and I’m wondering if this might be a good replacement for local groups.

Re: Looking for the best forum software to start a new forum community in 2025

#26
post #25

Comment castles: https://github.com/ferg1e/comment-castles (I'm the developer)

Do you have any suggestions on deploying? I looked over the readme. I’m not understanding how to go from clone to cloud. Meetup sucks and I’m wondering if this might be a good replacement for local groups.

Yeah, here is what you need to do:

- install Node.js, Redis and PostgreSQL

- start the Redis server

- start PostgreSQL, create a database and run structure.sql: https://github.com/ferg1e/comment-castles/blob/master/sql/st...

- get all the source code for the actual app (ie. the code from the comment castles repo)

- figure out all your environment variables (the ones I list in the README)

- now you can run the node app (you probably want to use pm2 if on Linux)

- then connect that running node app to the public internet (I use something random for the HTTP_PORT environment variable, like 3333, and then I Nginx reverse proxy that to port 80 on my domain name (I will try to get this Nginx code and post it here later))

- and then I run the let's encrypt certbot for https

Re: Looking for the best forum software to start a new forum community in 2025

#28
post #5

I mean the obvious answer, given that this is HN, is that you should make it yourself. A basic text forum in PHP wouldn't be super difficult. But practically speaking, and unfortunately, hosted forums are a dead technology. All of the attention is on social media, Discord and federated solutions like Mastodon and Lemmy. If what you actually want to do is create a community rather than write software, you could consid…

As someone who makes his money from hosting “forums”, I can NOT confirm that forums are dead. Maybe the classical ones, but not places like HN, where the content is interesting and peoples opinions are appreciated.
Post reply on HN