Live data from Hacker News

Updates to H-1B

uscis.gov

11–20 of 1001 posts

Re: Updates to H-1B

#11
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

lmao, what do you mean by backdoor? how else would someone legally immigrate?

Some people get upset that someone on a 'non-immigrant' 'temporary employment' visa can apply for permanent residency, although that is allowed by the H1-B program. Otherwise, one could immigrate through a different visa; there are some employment visas that are explicitly intended for those with intent to immigrate. Or like a family or lottery visa, I guess. I think it's possible to have a permanent residency applic…

It takes around 20+ years to go from H1b to permanent visa/green card. In the meantime your kids born in US have grown up, graduated, you have a house and everything could be yanked at the border when you are travelling.

Meanwhile vast majority of them pay into taxes and social security and leave the US and never see a dime of that money.

Immigrants are the easiest group to exploit by everyone because they have no voice and are vilified by vast majority of the people include the so called intellectuals in here.

Re: Updates to H-1B

#12
Some highlights from the Federal Register:

> 2. Bar on Multiple Registrations Submitted by Related Entities

DHS will not finalize the proposed change at 8 CFR 214.2(h)(2)(i)(G) to expressly state in the regulations that related entities are prohibited from submitting multiple H-1B registrations for the same individual. On February 2, 2024, DHS published a final rule, “Improving the H-1B Registration Selection Process and Program Integrity,” 89 FR 7456 (Feb. 2, 2024), creating a beneficiary-centric selection process for registrations by employers and adding additional integrity measures related to the registration process to reduce the potential for fraud in the H-1B registration process. In that final rule, DHS states that it “intends to address and may finalize this proposed provision [expressly stating in the regulations that related entities are prohibited from submitting multiple registrations for the same individual] in a subsequent final rule,” but that “[m]ore time and data will help inform the utility of this proposed provision.” 89 FR 7456, 7469 (Feb. 2, 2024). Initial data from the FY 2025 H-1B registration process show a significant decrease in the total number of registrations submitted compared to FY 2024, including a decrease in the number of registrations submitted on behalf of beneficiaries with multiple registrations.[1]

This initial data indicate that there were far fewer attempts to gain an unfair advantage than in prior years owing, in large measure, to the implementation of the beneficiary-centric selection process.[2]

Under the beneficiary-centric selection process, individual beneficiaries do not benefit from an increased chance of selection if related entities each submit a registration on their behalf. As such, DHS has decided not to finalize the proposed change pertaining to multiple registrations submitted by related entities.

> C. Summary of Costs and Benefits

DHS analyzed two baselines for this final rule, the no action baselines and the without-policy baseline. The primary baseline for this final rule is the no action baseline. For the 10-year period of analysis of the final rule, DHS estimates the annualized net cost savings of this rulemaking will be $333,835 annualized at a 2 percent discount rate. DHS also estimates that there will be annualized monetized transfers of $1.4 million from newly cap-exempt petitioners to USCIS and $38.8 million from employers to F-1 workers, both annualized at a 2 percent discount rate.

Re: Updates to H-1B

#14
Several positive outcomes, including expanding cap-exemption to non-profit and other research institutions, and stronger enforcement mechanisms.

Re: Updates to H-1B

#15
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some people get upset that someone on a 'non-immigrant' 'temporary employment' visa can apply for permanent residency, although that is allowed by the H1-B program. Otherwise, one could immigrate through a different visa; there are some employment visas that are explicitly intended for those with intent to immigrate. Or like a family or lottery visa, I guess. I think it's possible to have a permanent residency applic…

It takes around 20+ years to go from H1b to permanent visa/green card. In the meantime your kids born in US have grown up, graduated, you have a house and everything could be yanked at the border when you are travelling. Meanwhile vast majority of them pay into taxes and social security and leave the US and never see a dime of that money. Immigrants are the easiest group to exploit by everyone because they have no vo…

Yup, left US after years of working and doubt will ever see social security for self.

Re: Updates to H-1B

#16
Ah, classic regulatory theater. The administration, after 4 years of not introducing these changes, is now suddenly scrambling to roll them out. They’re dropping them right before a major transition, with an implementation timeline conveniently set for after the transition.

It’s a clever little maneuver. When the inevitable reversal happens, they can show up at fundraising galas telling donors, “We tried! We were so close! It’s just those baddies who always come along and pull the rug.”

Re: Updates to H-1B

#17
I’m very happy for everybody on H1-B whose live this improves! Does this include renewal in USA?

But as an American the “bonafide job requirement” makes me nervous. We have a massive ghost job problem that really needs to be a federal crime. Will this make that worse?

Re: Updates to H-1B

#18

I’m very happy for everybody on H1-B whose live this improves! Does this include renewal in USA? But as an American the “bonafide job requirement” makes me nervous. We have a massive ghost job problem that really needs to be a federal crime. Will this make that worse?

Yeah, there really needs to be some worker protection legislation makes ghost jobs a crime.

Re: Updates to H-1B

#19
https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/12/18/2024-29...

The tweet is a super brief summary, reproduced below.

Founders can self petition (& spouses can work)

  - Own >50% of the entity, or have majority voting rights
Roles tied to research institutions cap-exempt

  - Organizations where fundamental research is a key activity now qualify
  - Startups can hire researchers (AI, health, hardware) year-round
Students get seamless transition

  - Cap-gap work authorization extended to April 1
  - Prevents employment gaps for F-1 OPT to H-1B switch
Faster H1-B transfers for job changes

  - Flexibility to start working immediately upon petition filing
Clarification of specialty role

  - Less strict on the direct link between degree/job responsibilities
  - Recognizes that AI may require multiple academic background
Cracking down on fraud

  - Stricter compliance rules
  - Employers must demonstrate a bona fide job exists
  - Site visit codified: refusal to comply = petition denial

Re: Updates to H-1B

#20

I’m very happy for everybody on H1-B whose live this improves! Does this include renewal in USA? But as an American the “bonafide job requirement” makes me nervous. We have a massive ghost job problem that really needs to be a federal crime. Will this make that worse?

they mean "bonafide job offer". What is happening right now is staffing agencies (mainly in India) mass file H1B applications for all their staff, and then once they get picked in the lottery, they find assignments in the US and file the entire petition after. This heavily disadvantages non-staffing companies who file H1Bs for their staff outside the country or those in the US on F1 visas for actual jobs.

This change is meant to close that loophole. This used to not be a problem, because you had to file the entire petition BEFORE you enter the lottery, but now you just pay some nominal fee and get your name in, leading to a highly profitable situation for staffing companies.

Post reply on HN