Live data from Hacker News

Making a watch from scratch

old.reddit.com

11–20 of 92 posts

Re: Making a watch from scratch

#12
post #8
post #2

This person's build is amazing! Mostly photos, but still super cool to see how "from scratch" it is - if you're expecting "bought a few components from Swiss companies" then, yeah, it's not that! I submitted this a week ago and sadly it sank without trace (poor choice of posting time I suspect), so I'm trying again. I have no affiliation with the builder.

Almost everyone that's not already a large company is buying components. The only truly independent watchmaker I've ever heard of machining absolutely every component is Masahiro Kikuno.

Even the main spring? For some of the components it seems like a significant sacrifice in quality to make it yourself. I appreciate people can make their own, but I also think the obsession some folks have with in house movements is misplaced.

Re: Making a watch from scratch

#15
post #12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Almost everyone that's not already a large company is buying components. The only truly independent watchmaker I've ever heard of machining absolutely every component is Masahiro Kikuno.

Even the main spring? For some of the components it seems like a significant sacrifice in quality to make it yourself. I appreciate people can make their own, but I also think the obsession some folks have with in house movements is misplaced.

Right. Even George Daniels bought mainsprings and hairsprings (along with sapphire crystals and dial engraving, probably rose engine work?) for his 25 handmade watches.

> In total he (George Daniels) created 25 handmade watches which were completely made by himself (23 pocket watches and 2 wristwatches) other than the crystal, the mainspring, the engraving of the dials and the hairspring. One pocket watch remains incomplete and is not included in this total number of pocket watches produced by George Daniels.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Daniels_(watchmaker)

Re: Making a watch from scratch

#16
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even the main spring? For some of the components it seems like a significant sacrifice in quality to make it yourself. I appreciate people can make their own, but I also think the obsession some folks have with in house movements is misplaced.

Right. Even George Daniels bought mainsprings and hairsprings (along with sapphire crystals and dial engraving, probably rose engine work?) for his 25 handmade watches. > In total he (George Daniels) created 25 handmade watches which were completely made by himself (23 pocket watches and 2 wristwatches) other than the crystal, the mainspring, the engraving of the dials and the hairspring. One pocket watch remains inc…

Even Valerii Danevych used a metal spring ...

https://www.ahci.ch/members/valerii-danevych/

https://www.keepthetime.com/blog/valerii-danevych-wooden-wat...

Re: Making a watch from scratch

#17

I can fully appreciate the amount of skill involved here. I'm currently on a journey to make a clock from scratch using traditional clockmaker's methods. I started from pretty much zero knowledge of even basic machining, let alone specific clock and watch work. I'm a couple years in now (working in my spare time between work and family obligations), and I can repair most types of issues with clocks and many watches.…

One of my very vague goals is to build a clock, from scratch, without looking anything up.

It wouldn't have to look like a wall clock; just something that keeps 24-hour time within reasonable tolerances.

(It's been impossible to avoid knowledge of all clockmaking stuff, but I still avoid watching videos on how clocks are made. This is probably going to be something I do once the child is in college!)

Re: Making a watch from scratch

#18

In case you haven't seen it before, my absolutely favorite watch resource: https://ciechanow.ski/mechanical-watch/

This has got to be one of the best explanations of anything I've ever seen in any subject.

Thank you for sharing - hope you have a great day.

Post reply on HN