Live data from Hacker News

60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

londonherald.co.uk

21–30 of 56 posts

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#21
post #3

I wonder what the ratio of people actively deactivating to people silently never returning to the website/app is. At least 1 to 10 is my guess.

I somehow managed to mess up 2FA in my Twitter account shortly after Elon bought it. I think it was around when some 2FA options were only available to paid accounts. I was trying to delete it, so I decided the account was pretty well locked and just left it.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#22
post #14
post #6

There's not much more a person can do for freedom than to cowardly run once people, who don't agree with you, get to open their mouth without being banned.

One has to be terminally online if they A care about twitter, B think it has anything to do with "freedom"

Why? There's no free speech environment if it lacks spaces that upset you for existing. X's existence in the name of "freedom", even if you disagree with the characterization, in turn protects your free speech. In fact, nothing else really does.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#23

Few things I despise more than an absolute number provided with no context. Is 60K a lot? A little? The usual? How much does it deviate from the norm?

Indeed. And on a site with 611 Million monthly active users, that means 0.01% are deactivating their accounts each day. 3% after a year. Sounds insiginificant to me.

I think you've overlooked something: people can leave a social media site without deactivating their account. I haven't used Digg or Slashdot in at least a decade, for example, but never got rid of my accounts. I've also got a few alt Reddit accounts that I haven't logged into in a long time.

I'd expect in general the number of people who leave a site but don't bother to actually go through the steps of deactivating the account to be quite a bit higher than the number that do deactivate.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#24
post #6

There's not much more a person can do for freedom than to cowardly run once people, who don't agree with you, get to open their mouth without being banned.

It's not cowardly to leave your abusers. It is a very bold act. People decided they were tired of abusive Twitter users, and so they left.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#25
I always hated twitter, but I have to say I started using it in the last month or so.

It's the only social network that feels unfiltered and not the typical politically correct crap.

I can understand left wing people leaving the platform and they account for half of the population so the numbers make sense.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#26
X, as a platform, is absolutely cooked. I'm sure it will remain around the same way Truth social is around. A small group of right wing folks will hang out there and argue to their last breath that it's more free speech or something, but increasingly having an X account will be seen as kind of a weird trait.

It'll make for some interesting stories a decade from now when we'll all reminisce about "remember how Musk fucked Twitter? Oh shit, is it still running?"

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#27
post #22
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One has to be terminally online if they A care about twitter, B think it has anything to do with "freedom"

Why? There's no free speech environment if it lacks spaces that upset you for existing. X's existence in the name of "freedom", even if you disagree with the characterization, in turn protects your free speech. In fact, nothing else really does.

People should touch some grass instead of debating if insulting groups of people online is what the founding fathers meant by freedom of speech, or if it actually brings anything of value to society. Twitter is still censoring a lot of shit, it just changed side and now that it's yours it's "freedom"

btw freedom of speech doesn't exist anywhere to begin with. Even in the self proclaimed "land of the free" you can't swear on public tv lmao, libel, slander, obscenity, fraud, &c. are all illegal. Meanwhile nobody talks about freedom of press even though the US ranks closer to Hungary than western europe, so much for freedom of speech...

Reminder that twitter is a bubble in the internet, which itself also is a bubble, and that real life exists out there.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#28
post #13
post #6

There's not much more a person can do for freedom than to cowardly run once people, who don't agree with you, get to open their mouth without being banned.

If I wanted replies to my posts to be the most offensive thing the person could think of just for the keks I would just go to 4chan where at least it's more creative. You can call it running away but it's not out of fear, it's because the quality of discussion dropped to nothing. It didn't used to be that bad when a post broke containment. I've had great discussions on HN with people who disagree with me on very fund…

Low quality responses aren't a part of a discussion: they're simply to be ignored. This is part and parcel for the internet, everywhere and for everyone. Unless one chooses not to ignore them, but that's their specific choice to participate.

Where exactly is there "quality of discussion", if we include low quality responses in that rating, in any political space that isn't siloed? It doesn't exist today, and if the space is siloed then it also doesn't exist by definition.

It's okay to want to go where people agree with you more, even if it's because others aren't allowed in. But call it what it is, and note what it isn't.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#29
post #6

There's not much more a person can do for freedom than to cowardly run once people, who don't agree with you, get to open their mouth without being banned.

Eh? No-one is running. People are leaving a thing which has become shit. Like, if a local restaurant starts giving people food poisoning and people stop going there, you don't say people are running away from the restaurant, you say that they're no longer going there because it is bad.

"You cowards! Come back! We've got multiple drug resistant e coli on special this week!"

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#30
post #27
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why? There's no free speech environment if it lacks spaces that upset you for existing. X's existence in the name of "freedom", even if you disagree with the characterization, in turn protects your free speech. In fact, nothing else really does.

People should touch some grass instead of debating if insulting groups of people online is what the founding fathers meant by freedom of speech, or if it actually brings anything of value to society. Twitter is still censoring a lot of shit, it just changed side and now that it's yours it's "freedom" btw freedom of speech doesn't exist anywhere to begin with. Even in the self proclaimed "land of the free" you can't s…

That makes no sense, in total.
Post reply on HN