Live data from Hacker News

60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

londonherald.co.uk

11–20 of 56 posts

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#11

Few things I despise more than an absolute number provided with no context. Is 60K a lot? A little? The usual? How much does it deviate from the norm?

Agreed. "For one week, an average of 60K per day left the platform." So... 420K that week (feels appropriate, lol). That's a bit under 0.1%. With 600M reported users, X can do this every day for 27 years.

But I'm betting this week was an outlier for some reason or another.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#13
post #6

There's not much more a person can do for freedom than to cowardly run once people, who don't agree with you, get to open their mouth without being banned.

If I wanted replies to my posts to be the most offensive thing the person could think of just for the keks I would just go to 4chan where at least it's more creative.

You can call it running away but it's not out of fear, it's because the quality of discussion dropped to nothing. It didn't used to be that bad when a post broke containment. I've had great discussions on HN with people who disagree with me on very fundamental issues on political topics and I would describe it as polite and informative.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#14
post #6

There's not much more a person can do for freedom than to cowardly run once people, who don't agree with you, get to open their mouth without being banned.

One has to be terminally online if they A care about twitter, B think it has anything to do with "freedom"

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#15

Few things I despise more than an absolute number provided with no context. Is 60K a lot? A little? The usual? How much does it deviate from the norm?

Indeed. And on a site with 611 Million monthly active users, that means 0.01% are deactivating their accounts each day. 3% after a year. Sounds insiginificant to me.

611 million active user IDs. There's a lot of bots, and spammers with multiple user IDs.

I'd be interested in seeing something about user IDs that scroll some minimum amount vs user IDs that just post.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#16
post #6

There's not much more a person can do for freedom than to cowardly run once people, who don't agree with you, get to open their mouth without being banned.

I deleted my account to avoid my valuable "intellectual property" residing in the hands of a single, apparently quite capricious, person.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That should show up in MAU and time-on-site statistics. Which the site should be compelled to report to advertisers.

X does seem to report stats like this to the public. https://x.com/XData/ Obviously there is probably a decent amount of cherry picking of the stats to report.

I'm genuinely curious as to what if any disclosures, and possible business requirements / fraud risks, are presented by not having such disclosures for an advertising-supported business.

Virtually any significant publishing platform has a press kit detailing circulation or equivalent numbers, which are in most cases publicly available, so far as I'm aware. I'm not finding a definitive statement as to whether or not this is required in the US, though most significant publications, and now online sites, provide similar data.

The Alliance for Audited Media (AAM) seems to be the principle source of circulation data in the US, per this Pew article (2023):

"Newspapers Fact Sheet"

https://www.pewresearch.org/journalism/fact-sheet/newspapers...>

That also notes however:

[T]hree of the highest-circulation daily papers in the U.S. – The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal and The Washington Post – have in recent years not fully reported their digital circulation to AAM.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#18

Few things I despise more than an absolute number provided with no context. Is 60K a lot? A little? The usual? How much does it deviate from the norm?

Indeed. And on a site with 611 Million monthly active users, that means 0.01% are deactivating their accounts each day. 3% after a year. Sounds insiginificant to me.

How are they counting deactivation's?

My account got nuked because I changed my birthday date for jokes and it locked me out for being 'too young' when I signed up way back in 2007. I would have needed to provide photos of government ID to re-activate so I let it go.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That should show up in MAU and time-on-site statistics. Which the site should be compelled to report to advertisers.

X does seem to report stats like this to the public. https://x.com/XData/ Obviously there is probably a decent amount of cherry picking of the stats to report.

It looks like the posting stopped in 2019, so Twitter posted stats. X never has.

Re: 60k people deactivated their X accounts on average each day in one week alone

#20

Few things I despise more than an absolute number provided with no context. Is 60K a lot? A little? The usual? How much does it deviate from the norm?

I believe that the appropriate response isn't to get upset about it, but to chalk it up to another article meant to mislead in the avalanche that are printed daily. I mean not only is the number meaningless without the context of relative deviation, as you point out, but new signups aren't addressed either. The article is clickbait in total.
Post reply on HN