Live data from Hacker News

You must read at least one book to ride

ludic.mataroa.blog

21–30 of 155 posts

Re: You must read at least one book to ride

#21
The section about reading "the right books" is important. I tried reading some self-help books in high school, but after reading a few, you'll realize they are mostly "fanfic" as the author says. I noticed some other patterns in these books.

1. Constant self-questioning while reading - "Is this obvious? did I already know this?"

2. Lots of examples or stories

3. Try to turn a simple metaphor/slogan into a complete philosophy for life - i.e "skin in the game"

Re: You must read at least one book to ride

#22

I very much agree with this premise. My skills fall into three camps: That which I have invented myself, from first principles; That which I have read one book on; and That which I am bad at. One of the things I am bad at is finding books. Books are everywhere, most books are rubbish, and yet every book I've had recommended has been amazing . So, does anyone have a good book on finding good books?

Gnod is the classic reccomendation engine that works great and doesn’t harvest your data. It has a search for books: https://www.gnooks.com/faves.php General Gnod: gnod.com

Wow, this has existed for at least 10 years, although the domain has had some wayback machine snapshots since like 2002 but I was too lazy to pinpoint where the project started.

I love finding stuff like this that have been going for so long.

Re: You must read at least one book to ride

#23

It's not the reading books, it's the wanting to read books.

School is not cool and that’s a problem.

It's even more general than that: effort is antithetical to cool. Being seen making effort is as embarrassing as failure itself, perhaps moreso -- there's a peculiar glory in spectacular failure. Parents these days are taught (well, speaking for myself here) to praise effort over results. As if parents can overturn culture so easily...

Re: You must read at least one book to ride

#24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Gnod is the classic reccomendation engine that works great and doesn’t harvest your data. It has a search for books: https://www.gnooks.com/faves.php General Gnod: gnod.com

Wow, this has existed for at least 10 years, although the domain has had some wayback machine snapshots since like 2002 but I was too lazy to pinpoint where the project started. I love finding stuff like this that have been going for so long.

Yes I thought it used to be FOSS but perhaps it is not to avoid corporations stealing the capability.

Beyond that I find just asking someone also interested or finding a forum about the topic to be a good place to jump into the basics. Usually someone has already asked the question, “what else like this?” somewhere online.

I have a weekly meetup for an unrelated hobby but I find asking “anyone see any good movies lately” to be a great way to talk about both old and new movies and break the ice during the social portion. Sometimes someone drops something I haven’t heard of related to the old or new movie.

Re: You must read at least one book to ride

#25

It's not the reading books, it's the wanting to read books.

I agree with you! Correlation is not causation. Being particularly motivated about a subject causes you to read more books, and both combined cause you to improve on that subject. Setting the goal to arbitrarily read more books just because you think it will make you more successful will fail you in the long term.

The key is to learn not to ignore/suppress your internal drive.

Re: You must read at least one book to ride

#26

Prefacing that I agree - The returns probably manifest at a senior level, where job security is already a non-issue and one has the privileges and power to make this knowledge actionable. This could be why the readers find it redundant and stick to coasting. I'd like to finish reading the Algorithm Design Manual, SICP and others, but it won't get me my next job, because I won't even be in the same room as someone who…

I always think about this - how many great engineers might be out there that are hard to spot/hire because there's no indication anywhere that they're great? And simultaneously, how many crap engineers out there are hired simply because they know how to play the "thought leader" game?

And as a thought exercise: How would you yourself like to be found / hired? What would you do to show the company that you are indeed great / knowledgeable? Is it Leetcode, or is that too much to ask? Is it a take-home project? Is it a lengthy interview that shows off your skills? A lengthy probationary period? What would you be willing to do to make up for your lack of "bs"?

Re: You must read at least one book to ride

#27
post #6

I very much agree with this premise. My skills fall into three camps: That which I have invented myself, from first principles; That which I have read one book on; and That which I am bad at. One of the things I am bad at is finding books. Books are everywhere, most books are rubbish, and yet every book I've had recommended has been amazing . So, does anyone have a good book on finding good books?

I have started using large language models for book recommendations. I can be very specific about what I am looking for and the recommendations are hyper personalized. If you use some sort of tool that pairs LLMs with realtime data like Gemini the results are even better.

How often does it recommend Blindsight when you're asking for SF, or Malazan when you're asking for fantasy?

Re: You must read at least one book to ride

#28

I very much agree with this premise. My skills fall into three camps: That which I have invented myself, from first principles; That which I have read one book on; and That which I am bad at. One of the things I am bad at is finding books. Books are everywhere, most books are rubbish, and yet every book I've had recommended has been amazing . So, does anyone have a good book on finding good books?

I can't suggest a book on it, but I think there's nothing wrong with just finding them through recommendations. If that's not happening organically, then there's:

1) recommendations/references in books you've read and liked

2) other books by an author you've read and liked

3) other books in a series (be it a novel, or some set of technical books on a particular theme for example) you've read one of and liked

Re: You must read at least one book to ride

#29
He's a good writer, but I think he underestimates the implicit skills that an experienced engineer has that beginners don't have. Sometimes it just seems like common sense, but it isn't, and the result is often a lack of empathy.

To build up that empathy, being around children or the elderly probably helps. Also, helping a relative who is struggling but you're on their side.

Also consider the difference between a native speaker of a language who just kind of knows how to say what they want to say, versus someone struggling to learn the language.

Post reply on HN