Live data from Hacker News

The Bluesky Bubble: This is a relapse, not a fix

theatlantic.com

11–20 of 64 posts

Re: The Bluesky Bubble: This is a relapse, not a fix

#12
The Twitter replacement for me isn't Bluesky, it's a combination of Bluesky and being less online. I won't get attached to Bluesky. If it significantly degrades like Twitter I'll move on from it pretty easily. I've already started to get mildly turned off by Bluesky since it began interrupting profiles and feeds with "suggestion" blocks. The engagement hacking has started.

Re: The Bluesky Bubble: This is a relapse, not a fix

#13
post #9
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

[flagged]

"Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re: The Bluesky Bubble: This is a relapse, not a fix

#15
post #7

Strange article, social media isn’t going anywhere, it’s just evolving. The decline of X is due to Elon, that’s all.

[flagged]

X's mandatory self-reported figures in the EU show they lost about 6 million monthly active users in the first half of 2024. There doesn't seem to be similar data for the US and UK, but other metrics, like Similarweb, show declines in those places as well.[0]

[0]https://www.socialmediatoday.com/news/x-formerly-twitter-los...

Re: The Bluesky Bubble: This is a relapse, not a fix

#16
Has a clone of a social media site ever replaced an original? The closest I can think of is Tiktok being kinda similar to Vine but that feels like a stretch.

I don't think Bluesky will succeed unless it offers something different to the basic Twitter experience. It's hard to picture enough people giving up Twitter (or using both) for it to reach the critical mass required to sustain it.

Re: The Bluesky Bubble: This is a relapse, not a fix

#17
post #8
post #6

> I have written before in The Atlantic about a problem that I see as superordinate to all of these others: People just aren’t meant to talk with one another this much The irony of publishing an article intended for a mass audience about how people shouldn't talk to each other. Obviously journalists are the only ones who can be trusted with such power...

publishing != talking

publishing == talking down to

Re: The Bluesky Bubble: This is a relapse, not a fix

#18
post #7

Strange article, social media isn’t going anywhere, it’s just evolving. The decline of X is due to Elon, that’s all.

[flagged]

I just proved your point down below. You don't like voting, do you?

Also, it's advertisers that stay away, and it's X challenging them in court over it. The world is getting weirder by the day.

Do you have an uncle that can't stop ranting and calling people names? People just leave his presence. That behavior is just the worst and we're not born to suffer it, passively. That's the whole point of the free speech fallacy. Now the shouters are in power, so they can pour their trauma down our throats, as if this were some therapy. No, it's just abuse and it's perverse. That's why people leave X. They have a target on their back.

Re: The Bluesky Bubble: This is a relapse, not a fix

#19
post #10

Unless Bluesky or Threads tap into the Zeitgeist, Twitter isn't going anywhere. As much as whatever political side would love to see it falter, those invested in its downfall might have to temper their expectations. Twitter is a mirror of the human fabric — messy, contradictory, brutal. For all its flaws, it's the only service that reflects society's pulse in real-time.

[flagged]

Re: The Bluesky Bubble: This is a relapse, not a fix

#20

Has a clone of a social media site ever replaced an original? The closest I can think of is Tiktok being kinda similar to Vine but that feels like a stretch. I don't think Bluesky will succeed unless it offers something different to the basic Twitter experience. It's hard to picture enough people giving up Twitter (or using both) for it to reach the critical mass required to sustain it.

Have fascists ever taken over America before? We live in unprecedented times.
Post reply on HN