Live data from Hacker News

Boston Dynamics robot Atlas goes hands on [video]

youtube.com

11–20 of 220 posts

Re: Boston Dynamics robot Atlas goes hands on [video]

#11
post #5

While humanoid robots are neat, if not uncanny, I would love to see robots with forms optimized for their work. A large octopus with legs would be ideal for this sort of parts handling job.

The legs do seem like a huge overcomplication. I can't think of many situations where they would be worth the added cost/complexity (compared to simple wheels). Sure they can walk stairs, but a place that employs freaking robots could easily make it robot accessible too, it would seem.

Re: Boston Dynamics robot Atlas goes hands on [video]

#12
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Imagine you're working your 35-hour shift at the Fulfillment™ Center and all around you there's robotic eldritch horrors scurrying through the two-storey high shelves

Factory robots that move in general are kind of gimmicks, except for those roomba things for Amazon warehouses. An assembly line with robotic arms has been standard for a long time now. And having many such arms working at the same time is normal. And each robotic arm will be doing one extremely narrowly defined task. Anything involving autonomous judgment and mobility introduces uncertainty.

Neuralink-equipped wageslaves mind-projecting into robo-octopuses, traversing the storehouse-grid with the aid of their many-suckered appendages. Navigating via implicitly interfacing with the warehouse's AI overseer.

Re: Boston Dynamics robot Atlas goes hands on [video]

#13
post #5

While humanoid robots are neat, if not uncanny, I would love to see robots with forms optimized for their work. A large octopus with legs would be ideal for this sort of parts handling job.

Optimization isn't efficient on the grand scale of things. Think of these robots more as exchangeable worker units. Lets say the warehouse isn't accepting many packages that day. So you don't need as many robots at the loading dock. But we have a lot of product that needs to be inventoried or shelved. Send a couple over and have them start doing it right away.

You actually end up running a warehouse with less robots because they can easily be repurposed for other duties.

Re: Boston Dynamics robot Atlas goes hands on [video]

#16
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Factory robots that move in general are kind of gimmicks, except for those roomba things for Amazon warehouses. An assembly line with robotic arms has been standard for a long time now. And having many such arms working at the same time is normal. And each robotic arm will be doing one extremely narrowly defined task. Anything involving autonomous judgment and mobility introduces uncertainty.

Neuralink-equipped wageslaves mind-projecting into robo-octopuses, traversing the storehouse-grid with the aid of their many-suckered appendages. Navigating via implicitly interfacing with the warehouse's AI overseer.

sudo Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn

Re: Boston Dynamics robot Atlas goes hands on [video]

#17

See, this is a real video. Compare it with the obvious cgi fake that was put out a few months ago by Figure: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sq1QZB5baNw I still can't believe how noone has called them out on that one.

How do you know the figure 1 demo was fake?

Re: Boston Dynamics robot Atlas goes hands on [video]

#19
post #7
post #5

While humanoid robots are neat, if not uncanny, I would love to see robots with forms optimized for their work. A large octopus with legs would be ideal for this sort of parts handling job.

I think the exact point they’re trying to make is that a humanoid robot can pick up one shift exactly where a human left off. No custom robotics, no workplace changes, etc. This is huge for the industry. Smarter Every Day visited a frisbee factory and they had automated a bunch of things. However, every automation point was extremely protected (fenced off) so that a bumbling human couldn’t walk somewhere and get a li…

This ^

The effort required to change a process shouldn't be underestimated.

Especially considered that industrial environments are already (a) automated for lowest-hanging fruit things (e.g. moving stuff around at human height) & (b) optimized around human capabilities for the remaining things. Substituting a not-humanlike robot would require reconfiguring a lot of existing automation around it.

If you have "like a human, but costs less" that can be plugged into any existing still-human process? You can literally swap them in.

Eventually we'll get to hyperoptimized machines, but an easier sales story to say "We automate your existing human processes."

Re: Boston Dynamics robot Atlas goes hands on [video]

#20
post #8

Compare this to the human controlled puppets Tesla demonstrated. Tesla made a big show of something Disney could do years ago. While Boston Dynamics is quietly building the real thing and showing us footage of it actually working.

Tesla has footage of Optimus working autonomously. Not bad progress for something that has been under development for two years.

https://x.com/Tesla_Optimus/status/1846797392521167223

Post reply on HN