Live data from Hacker News

Facebook e-mail mess: Address books altered, e-mail lost

news.cnet.com

41–50 of 194 posts

Re: Facebook e-mail mess: Address books altered, e-mail lost

#41
post #29

I just deleted the Facebook app from my iPhone. I have no idea if it altered any of my contacts, but this certainly does scare me enough to warrant deletion.

I wish I could do that. I wonder if Facebook paid HTC a lot of money to make the Facebook app un-uninstallable.

Re: Facebook e-mail mess: Address books altered, e-mail lost

#42
post #4

Well, this is my gripe with their "go fast and break things" mantra. It works as long as you have such a highly desirable product that your users just don't care if you're doing everything right. (Or maybe you're in a non-mission-critical business, or better yet, your customers are a bunch of kids!) I'm all for going fast and sincerely believe in "A sense of urgency", but Facebook is really lucky they're not serving…

Facebook is serving shareholders now. I'm hoping there are some serious repercussions internally at FB for this, because as a shareholder, I'm pissed they messed this up because the user base is upset and will continue to stop trusting Facebook. How's the stock supposed to get back to 38 now?

it isn't.

Re: Facebook e-mail mess: Address books altered, e-mail lost

#43
post #17
post #6

How does this not violate CFAA? This really sounds like a company that believes it is above the law.

Uh, how could it violate CFAA? It's their own systems, and their data (they own it all).

Maybe it's a stretch . . . But it does sound like their system is presently causing changes to occur in external systems that were not authorized. Then again, having your address book linked to FB might be construed as authorization . . .

Re: Facebook e-mail mess: Address books altered, e-mail lost

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Possibly, but just for the sake of an interesting discussion, what is there about this particular blatant “It screws users over but it's good for Facebook” move that is different than all the other moves they’ve pulled?

I think the difference here is that everything they've done before now has been more or less bounded by my own actions. If they screw my privacy, it's my own damned fault for posting sensitive stuff to their site. Hell, even if they track me around the web, I should've been more careful about blocking their cookies. But this is another ballgame. What they've done here is effectively hijack a completely unrelated and…

I don't mean to defend them because this move is stupid, but to help you get this back in control: you can go you your about page and set the @facebook email to be hidden. I had done this in the past and they didn't touch it.

Re: Facebook e-mail mess: Address books altered, e-mail lost

#46
post #40
post #16

As someone who quit facebook a while back, I can't help but feel that this kind of event vindicates me. Sometimes I'm tempted to re-create a minimal account on the service just for findability, but even that small step would have been enough for facebook to hijack my contact info in a friend's phone. There really is no way to have a facebook account at all, no matter how infrequently you use it, without getting screw…

How do you know when someone has deleted their Facebook account? They'll tell you.

Too true. It's getting tiring reading the comments of posts like this because I know it's going to be filled with people boasting about how they've already deleted their accounts/just did it. The HN crowd is a tiny, tiny minority in the pool of Facebook users, our actions are hardly representative of sea change.

Re: Facebook e-mail mess: Address books altered, e-mail lost

#47
post #4

Well, this is my gripe with their "go fast and break things" mantra. It works as long as you have such a highly desirable product that your users just don't care if you're doing everything right. (Or maybe you're in a non-mission-critical business, or better yet, your customers are a bunch of kids!) I'm all for going fast and sincerely believe in "A sense of urgency", but Facebook is really lucky they're not serving…

It works on facebook because no one uses facebook for anything important. But messing with iOS contacts... that's reaching out and breaking things that aren't on facebook.

Re: Facebook e-mail mess: Address books altered, e-mail lost

#48

Why would anyone on God's green earth sync their Address book to facebook!?! It's a social network for crying out loud, not a work place! WT..!! This is what happen's when you mix work and pleasure ha ha, it's a stupid kid's playground to post stupid thing's and do nothing all day! I just can't get past it, why would anyone sync their address book to FB!? ha ha ha

Why on earth do you think that everyone's address books are business-only?

Re: Facebook e-mail mess: Address books altered, e-mail lost

#49
post #41
post #29

I just deleted the Facebook app from my iPhone. I have no idea if it altered any of my contacts, but this certainly does scare me enough to warrant deletion.

I wish I could do that. I wonder if Facebook paid HTC a lot of money to make the Facebook app un-uninstallable.

I have suggested this before on another thread and i'm not sure if you can do it on your phone but here it goes.

Root it and use titanium backup to force uninstall, it's how I removed all the junk.

Re: Facebook e-mail mess: Address books altered, e-mail lost

#50
post #4

Well, this is my gripe with their "go fast and break things" mantra. It works as long as you have such a highly desirable product that your users just don't care if you're doing everything right. (Or maybe you're in a non-mission-critical business, or better yet, your customers are a bunch of kids!) I'm all for going fast and sincerely believe in "A sense of urgency", but Facebook is really lucky they're not serving…

I wish their mantra for anything that touched this much personal contact/privacy information was, "slow down and think things through".

(Granted, a LOT of Facebook touches personal information, but something like this is pretty tendril-y in its reach).

Post reply on HN