Live data from Hacker News

Miqt: MIT-licensed Qt bindings for Go

github.com

91–92 of 92 posts

Re: Miqt: MIT-licensed Qt bindings for Go

#91
post #58
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's your definition of "useful", not mine. "political aversion"? We are talking about money and business here. If a commercial company wants to ship a product without reinventing all the wheels, they are going to use code with permissive licenses, and skip projects with GPL license or similar in a heartbeat. You could even argue quite the contrary -- when you make your project GPL/AGPL etc, and if it is big/impact…

Apple literally offered the clang/LLVM copyright to the FSF to be released under the GPL. This was basically just ignored. https://gcc.gnu.org/legacy-ml/gcc/2005-11/msg00888.html Furthermore there were real technical problems with gcc, certainly at the time. There were good reasons to start a new compiler project. The license was always more of a detail, rather than the main thing.

I doubt licensing is a "detail" -- various comments say it matters a lot, e.g. https://stackoverflow.com/a/14488011/3831197

> The GPLv3 was the final straw that ended Apple's interest in contributing to GCC which is the reason Apple ended it at GCC 4.2.x.

I guess GPLv2 is still GPL, but here we end up talking about copyleft licenses (GPLv3) affecting business decisions anyway.

Re: Miqt: MIT-licensed Qt bindings for Go

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How are you going to run on X11 systems if you have ruled out making IPC calls to a separate process in order to put together a GUI? Anyway, the primary advantages of the separate process you speak of is that it: 1. Deals with the LGPL concerns for you. 2. Deals with the pains of compilation, and especially cross-compilation for you. That is why you might consider it. Of course, it comes with many disadvantages too.…

> How are you going to run on X11 systems if (...) I'm not sure you understood the question I asked.

Perhaps it is actually you who misunderstood my question?
Post reply on HN