Live data from Hacker News

Someone Stole Sherlock's 300,000 Likes

spottedsun.com

51–57 of 57 posts

Re: Someone Stole Sherlock's 300,000 Likes

#51
post #47

Looks like it's back now, with 300,000+ likes. Thanks on behalf of the internet, whoever works at Facebook and saw this. :-) https://www.facebook.com/ModernSherlock

Definitely. Thank you Internet, and thank you to the people at Facebook who looked into this.

Re: Someone Stole Sherlock's 300,000 Likes

#52
post #42

There should be some way to distinguish between a fan page, and an official page. So, that people who want to follow either have a choice.

There is: it is called a "community page". This person flagrantly violated this mechanism, against Facebook's terms of service, in order to capitalize on the fame of a television show he did not create and was not involved in.

This feature wasn't exactly around when the page was made.

Re: Someone Stole Sherlock's 300,000 Likes

#53
post #5

The moral of the story here is that you shouldn't invest your time and emotional energy into things that actually belong to other people. You didn't own a website here. You didn't write code, you didn't set up servers, and you didn't sit around worrying about whether you were monetizing well enough to keep the site from imploding under its own popularity. You volunteered to be the curator of an entry in a database ow…

I actually came to write that the big takeaway for me was to care about things that actually exist. Pouring your life into a fan site that can one day disappear seems incredibly depressing. In that time others have built companies, relationships and a happy life and you have built: a collection of fan art for an obscure tv show. Isn't there something better one could be doing?

[deleted]

Re: Someone Stole Sherlock's 300,000 Likes

#54
Don't stop with this post. I think the girl with blog of the school lunches in Scotland showed a modern method to solve any similar customer service issue. Start a blog and continually update it with whatever your issue is in a factual non-opinionated way. Wait for them to try to shut you down, then go to the media and social avenues so that it becomes hot topic, and they'll fix it. Then they may screw you again and you'll have to go to the media again and then they'll fix it again. Perfect solution.

Re: Someone Stole Sherlock's 300,000 Likes

#55
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The same argument could be flipped on you! I believe you post a lot on Hacker News, but you don't own the code, servers, etc. You are a volunteer commenter. What if someone blocked and deleted all of your comments? Wouldn't you feel the slightest bit of loss?

Actually, that is one of the things I rather like about HN. The "loss" is built in: after a couple of days, nobody is going to read or respond to any of my comments. Everything I write here will effectively disappear several days from now. And that, somehow, is very refreshing: I don't have to worry about posterity or the future. HN is my way of indulging in the present. No plans, no worries, no future. Very relaxing…

It depends; more than once I remember reading something on here from some time ago and I do a site:news.ycombinator.com search.

It's sort of interesting to see discussions about technology that has long since moved on.

Re: Someone Stole Sherlock's 300,000 Likes

#56
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A more Zenlike takeaway would be to realize that everything has an end and to accept that. There is nothing that can't be taken away from you.

I read that as "there is nothing that can be taken away from you" Same frame of mind I think, slightly different way of expressing it. :P

“Music is the space between the notes” – Claude Debussy

Re: Someone Stole Sherlock's 300,000 Likes

#57
post #50

My name is Fred Wolens, and I work for Facebook’s Policy Communications Team. We apologize for the temporary inconvenience caused by the migration of the Page’s content and Likes. We have already restored the Page, and there shouldn’t be any remaining issues. Unfortunately, the Sherlock Page was not the official BBC fan Page for the show; this caused the Page to be flagged as a violation of our terms and we mistakenl…

Hi Fred. Thank you for posting this explanation -- I do have a question though, the current "Sherlock" page -- is that an official page? How long will it take for these changes to appear in Facebook search?

Yes. The current Sherlock Page (https://www.facebook.com/pages/Sherlock) is official. Search should populate in the next couple days, the re-crawl shouldn't take more than a week or so.
Post reply on HN