Live data from Hacker News

Cheddar

cheddarapp.com

131–140 of 150 posts

Re: Cheddar

#131

Sweet, it's completely useless! I can't dump a task from command line or vim. Can't script it to pull things to the calendar automatically. Can't send an email to put a task directly into it. Can't dump tasks to a text todo list to put at the top of the code or document im writing to remember what I need as I write. Will not use. And, even if those features show up, won't consider due to lack basic thought in initial…

You have a point, the service should come with an API.

Re: Cheddar

#132
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It takes me around 4 seconds to type in a task with MyLifeOrgainzed. (Can be 2-3 seconds for short tasks.) No need to open the app, it's always open, just press a shortcut key to bring up a dialog for adding a task.

Wow... that's one really ugly UI. http://www.mylifeorganized.net/i/sshots/myLife-ssh012.gif

Holy hell did they ever boil the ocean on that one.

Looks more like a project management suite mislabeled as a to-do list.

Re: Cheddar

#133
I know there's a ton of todo apps out there, I've tried Remember the Milk, Evernote, Wunderlist, Reminders.app, and probably a couple other iOS todo apps.

I picked Wunderlist and have used that for a long time because it's on every platform I care about (iPhone, iPad, and Mac) BUT it's absolutely horrible about syncing content and I get duplicates and missing todos all the time. I just tried out cheddar's "push" feature and it's actually enough for me to leave Wunderlist.

Also the Markdown feature is awesome

Re: Cheddar

#134

Hackers love to make todo lists. It's like some musicians' work remixing pop songs.

Ironically I've yet to find an online todo list I like. My favorite todo list is a pad and a pen, next to my computer. I've not found a feature set in an online tool that works better for me.

After too many years typing I can barely write, so it's Notepad or Wordpad for me.

Re: Cheddar

#135
post #48

Startup request: Please, someone come up with a todo/productivity/project management system whose main feature is _motivation_ to use it, not just technical versions of paper todo lists. I don't know if the solution is necessarily technical. I've tried every major app and still rely on the visceral impact of post-it notes next to my computer to get things done. I'd love to switch to an app but nothing is actually mak…

Try the pomodoro technique (its just a 25-minute timer). I only tried it quite recently, but its working great and quickly becoming a habit. I really appreciate the no-nonsense approach which prevents any yak-shaving[1]. Its simple on the most basic level so its compatibile with more the complex systems like GTD, or task management / team collab apps.

1. http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/yak_shaving

Re: Cheddar

#136
post #48

Startup request: Please, someone come up with a todo/productivity/project management system whose main feature is _motivation_ to use it, not just technical versions of paper todo lists. I don't know if the solution is necessarily technical. I've tried every major app and still rely on the visceral impact of post-it notes next to my computer to get things done. I'd love to switch to an app but nothing is actually mak…

How about this for motivation?

You assign a due date and a dollar amount punishment when you create a todo list or task. When you fail to complete your tasks on the due date, your account is charged the punishment amount.

"How do you verify that the task has been completed?" you might ask.

You don't. If users "cheat" then they're just losing out on the motivation service, otherwise you get the motivation required to do the task on time.

Re: Cheddar

#137
Am I the only one who sees a clear, functional difference between "todo" and "list" apps?

Todo apps: Any.do, Orchestra, 2Do, Do It Tomorrow, TeuxDeux

List apps: Clear, Cheddar, Listary

I always keep one of each one my phone, because they serve entirely different purposes. While they both work by storing lists, there's a big difference for me between tasks and items in a list. When I'm tracking tasks, I want things organized based on timeframes (maybe also assigning priorities, due dates, or categories), and an interface designed around that principle is always going to do that better; you could use Clear or Cheddar to store "Today", "Tomorrow", and "Soon" lists, but that's a poor hack. When I'm simply maintaining a list of things to remember (e.g., grocery list, debts to friends, items I need to buy after moving, songs to buy, 100 push-ups program), all I want is several (separate) lists with items I can add, edit, rearrange, and delete.

I currently use Any.do as my tasks app and Clear as my list app. I really like the design of both of them, but I have reservations of both. Any.do takes a very nice approach of sorting tasks into bins of Today, Tomorrow, This Week, and Later, but aggressively bubbles tasks up (the idea is nice if Tomorrow tasks moved into Today after a day, and This Week into Tomorrow after 6 days, and Later always stayed in Later, but I've had to push the same tasks back into Later and This Week 4+ times per week). Clear lacks syncing of any kind -- this is extremely frustrating because it could easily hook into something like SimpleNote. I really like the focus on syncing from Cheddar, but I have major reservations about the subscription concept (even though experience shows that I move between these apps frequently and will likely not need to pay for many months, a subscription feels like a significant investment whereas a <$5 app doesn't), and I find myself missing Any.do and Clear's gestures.

Re: Cheddar

#138
I don't understand the hate in the comments. Two things:

1) The simplest applications are still hard to polish this much. In fact, simple things can often hide some of the hardest design choices.

2) Three years ago, Twitter apps were the UI design playground of choice. Now that they've told everyone not to write new clients, UI experimentation has shifted to other applications. Compare Cheddar to Clear, for example. Both are nominally to-do lists, both have carefully thought out custom interfaces, but they express very different philosophies about software design.

Re: Cheddar

#139

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why is honest criticism not allowed? Don't you want to know why people are averse to your service so you can perfect it, no less directly from the people who would pay for it?

There's a difference between honest criticism and bashing someones hard work. 75% of the comments on this post are not honest criticism.

What gets me, is that all this hard work could be put into something way more useful. Instead it's wasted trying to re-invent the wheel. This app offers hardly anything if not nothing new.

Re: Cheddar

#140
HOORAY!! Another magincal, spectacular, one of a kind, amazing, beautiful, fabulous, all-synching, to-do-list task! Next up is the world peace I say.
Post reply on HN