Live data from Hacker News

Facebook forces all users over to Facebook.com e-mail addresses

arstechnica.com

161–170 of 208 posts

Re: Facebook forces all users over to Facebook.com e-mail addresses

#161

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is no fine line here. Facebook changed a personal attribute of their users. This particular action is not justifiable under any circumstances I can see.

The only justification i can see is that it's facebook, and this is pretty much the sort of behaviour i expect from facebook. i have a hard time getting outraged over behaviour that is totally in character.

Explanations are not justifications.

Re: Facebook forces all users over to Facebook.com e-mail addresses

#162

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I assume you're running iOS 6, yes?

Yes indeed.

I'm afraid the details of the iOS 6 features other than what's announced in WWDC are still under NDA (which you signed when you gain access to the developer beta). So perhaps you want to remove that comment.

Re: Facebook forces all users over to Facebook.com e-mail addresses

#163
Alright, I'm tired of this. Can everyone please shut the hell up about Facebook 'forcing' people to change their e-mail address? Facebook isn't forcing you to do shit.

They changed the default e-mail address that appears in your profile. I'm happy about this. It means all my Facebook friends have a way of contacting me that isn't my primary e-mail address, meaning that type of communication is easily compartmentalized and thus taken care of.

Re: Facebook forces all users over to Facebook.com e-mail addresses

#164
Reminds me of foursquare. I can't, for the life of me, get it to post pictures to my facebook feed any longer. I've tried reinstalling, posting with a camera picture, posting with a gallery picture, relinking facebook, tapping the icon on and off, making sure picture is public, etc..

I'm pretty sure they disabled this functionality so they can show the map instead which gets them more clicks into their site proper and helps their traffic. Really pisses me off because I take a picture every check in and think they are more interesting and don't think people should be forced into foursquare to view them and don't want to have to post them separately - then in their marketing material for the new face lift they even show a picture of a facebook post with a picture. Lies.

Re: Facebook forces all users over to Facebook.com e-mail addresses

#165
With Facebook making this change, I guess anyone who is unaware of this and syncs their Facebook contacts to their phone (either directly or via apps) stands to lose the 'real' email addresses of their friends and especially once they sync back to their desktop/cloud/gmail etc!!

Re: Facebook forces all users over to Facebook.com e-mail addresses

#166
post #165

With Facebook making this change, I guess anyone who is unaware of this and syncs their Facebook contacts to their phone (either directly or via apps) stands to lose the 'real' email addresses of their friends and especially once they sync back to their desktop/cloud/gmail etc!!

On my Android the Facebook details are in a separate bucket than my Gmail contact details. So the Facebook sync hasn't overridden the email addresses that were manually entered by me or have been synced by Google's Contacts.

But on the other hand I'm seeing a lot of new Facebook email addresses in my contacts.

Re: Facebook forces all users over to Facebook.com e-mail addresses

#167
post #21

There are three discussions about this on the front page :-/ . I think this is just might be one of those things which would ticks us off as techies... but techies are the minority audience for sites like facebook. Do emails sent to the facebook id go to the standard facebook 'message system'? If so, for a majority of people this will probably make sense... want to message somebody on facebook? You don't have to logi…

> If so, for a majority of people this will probably make sense... want to message somebody on facebook? You don't have to login to facebook! Email them at xyz@facebook.com. There are easy ways to advertise this fact, without changing anyone's personal info in their Facebook account. It could be as simple as adding the text "You can also send messages to JaneDoe@facebook.com" to JaneDoe's profile page.

I do agree - it could have (and possibly should have) been done differently. I was trying rationalize facebook's action. It's a hugely successful company run by people smarter than I.

Re: Facebook forces all users over to Facebook.com e-mail addresses

#168
post #72

This morning my mother was complaining that many of the email addresses in her Droid Razr contacts had been replaced with Facebook ones. It would seem the Facebook app had been populating her address book with emails and contact photos, and decided to migrate all her Facebook-using contacts over to this convenient new system. That seems like a much greater controversy to me than Facebook hiding people's email address…

Facebook's android app is the most laggy, power hungry app I have. I use alternate apps to access Facebook. This is just one more reason to do so.

Re: Facebook forces all users over to Facebook.com e-mail addresses

#169
So I just disabled the Facebook contacts sync on my phone, because as of today it is useless for me. I'm also thinking of uninstalling the Facebook app, because the web interface is good enough for me, and I kept the Facebook app just for the contacts sync.

Re: Facebook forces all users over to Facebook.com e-mail addresses

#170

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes indeed.

I'm afraid the details of the iOS 6 features other than what's announced in WWDC are still under NDA (which you signed when you gain access to the developer beta). So perhaps you want to remove that comment.

This much is completely public:

http://www.apple.com/ios/ios6/#facebook

(Click the "Contacts and calendars", and see that contacts can have multiple addresses, even with Facebook sync.)

Post reply on HN