Live data from Hacker News

Scramble: Open-Source Alternative to Grammarly

github.com

51–60 of 174 posts

Re: Scramble: Open-Source Alternative to Grammarly

#51
post #9

Grammarly grammar checking predates modern LLMs by many years, so I assume they’re actually using some kind of rule-based engine internally.

I was a big fan of Grammarly, as dyslexic, so often write the wrong word then ten minutes later when re-reading spot i used the wrong word/spelling etc.

It worked extremely well, as you say I think by using basic rules engines.

I’ve canceled my subscription recently as found it getting worse, not better, I suspect because they are now applying LLMs.

The suggestions started to make less sense and the problem with LLM suggestions is all your writing takes the tone of the LLM, you loose your personality/style in what you write.

The basic rules approach worked much better for me.

Re: Scramble: Open-Source Alternative to Grammarly

#52
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

everyone stands on the shoulders of giants.

Things standing on the shoulders of proprietary giants shouldn't claim to be free software/open source.

Their interfacing software __is__ open source; and, they're asking for your OpenAI api key to operate. I would expect / desire open source code if I were to use that, so I could be sure my api key was only being used for my work, so it's only my work that I'm paying for and it's not been stolen in some way.

Re: Scramble: Open-Source Alternative to Grammarly

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, but the API at the end is providing the core functionality. Simply swapping out one LLM model for another - let alone by a different company altogether - will completely change the effectiveness and usefulness of the application.

everyone stands on the shoulders of giants.

My older brother who got me into coding learned to code in Assembly. He doesn't really consider most of my work writing in high level languages to be "coding". So maybe there's something here. But if I had to get into the underlying structure, I could. I do wonder whether the same can be said for people who just kludge together a bunch of APIs that produce magical result sets.

Re: Scramble: Open-Source Alternative to Grammarly

#54
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Code is only copyrightable if it has any element of creativity. This repo is _only_ really 7 sentences, like "Please correct spelling mistakes in the following text: " (these https://github.com/zlwaterfield/scramble/blob/2c1d9ebbd6b935... ) Everything else is uncreative, and possibly un-copyrightable, boilerplate to send those sentences to OpenAI. All of the creative software happens on OpenAI's servers using proprie…

Why would you even say 'please' in a prompt ?

There has been evidence that better responses are sometimes provided with politeness for some LLMs.

And some people just try to be polite and it only costs a couple tokens.

Re: Scramble: Open-Source Alternative to Grammarly

#55
post #6

Nice job—I'm always a fan of 'bring your own key' (BYOK) approaches. I think there's a lot of potential in using LLMs as virtual copy editors. I do a fair amount of writing and have actually put together several custom GPTs, each with varying degrees of freedom to rewrite the text. The first one acts strictly as a professional editor—it's allowed to fix spelling errors, grammatical issues, word repetition, etc., but…

> I'm always a fan of 'bring your own key' (BYOK) approaches.

"Bring your own key" has the same amount of syllables as "BYOK"

Re: Scramble: Open-Source Alternative to Grammarly

#57

After years with Grammarly, I wanted a simpler, cheaper way to improve my writing. So I built Scramble, a Chrome extension that uses an LLM for writing enhancements. Key features: - Uses your OpenAI API key (100% local) - Pre-defined prompts for various improvements - Highlight text and wait for suggestions - Currently fixed to GPT-4-turbo Future plans: add LLM provider/model choice, custom prompts, bug fixes, and im…

Rookie question: the openAPI endpoint costs extra right? Not something that comes with chatGPT or chatGPT+.

Re: Scramble: Open-Source Alternative to Grammarly

#59
post #28

I have been using LanguageTool[1] for years as "an open source alternative to [old school] Grammarly". It doesn't do that fancy "make this text more professional" AI stuff like this or Grammarly can now do, but they offer a self-hosted version so you don't need to send everything you write to OpenAI. If all you want is a better spelling/grammar checker, I highly recommend it. [1] - https://github.com/languagetool-org…

And you can write your own custom rules. It's great as a reward for spotting an error in your writing you get to write a tiny little bit of code to spot it automatically next time. I've collected hundreds.

Is there a way to add and use niche custom terminology?

Re: Scramble: Open-Source Alternative to Grammarly

#60
post #28

I have been using LanguageTool[1] for years as "an open source alternative to [old school] Grammarly". It doesn't do that fancy "make this text more professional" AI stuff like this or Grammarly can now do, but they offer a self-hosted version so you don't need to send everything you write to OpenAI. If all you want is a better spelling/grammar checker, I highly recommend it. [1] - https://github.com/languagetool-org…

It's great. I had a subscription for Grammarly for a couple of years and used both tools in parallel, but found myself mostly using languagetool increasingly. It is strictly better, I'd say even for English but certainly if you need other languages or deal with multilingual documents. So I canceled Grammarly and didn't miss it since. You also can self-host and we do that at my workplace, because we deal with sensitiv…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN