Live data from Hacker News

Craig Wright said he invented Bitcoin – lawyers proved him wrong

ft.com

51–60 of 113 posts

Re: Craig Wright said he invented Bitcoin – lawyers proved him wrong

#51
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There was no potential upside of becoming fabulously rich. Nobody can “extract” those keys.

No need to extract keys, the Bitcoin devs could just change the code. Even lock up the original and mint new ones for Craig. It's just code in the end. Similar to how Eth changed the code to nullify the DAO hack.

It's my understanding that simply changing the code doesn't really have an effect until all the nodes in the system update to use it.

Re: Craig Wright said he invented Bitcoin – lawyers proved him wrong

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He attempted to sue Bitcoin core devs to alter the algorithm to hand over Satoshi's coins. On the basis that he lost the keys and that the maintainers have a duty to him to help him recover them. Every part of the lawsuit was just batshit insane. The most insane part was that an UK court allowed the lawsuit to be heard, and forced dozens of people not living in UK to pay big money to defend themselves.

>The most insane part was that an UK court allowed the lawsuit to be heard, and forced dozens of people not living in UK to pay big money to defend themselves. Minor correction: according to the wikipedia article on Wright, the Crypto Open Patent Alliance sued Wright, not the other way around. However, IIUC Wright's attempts over many years to fraudulently extract patent licensing fees and other undeserved benefits f…

I think that was a different court case. Wright has been involved in several.

Re: Craig Wright said he invented Bitcoin – lawyers proved him wrong

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Ethereum DAO rollback fork was (for better or worse) widely supported by the community. It's not likely that a court-ordered fork to reassign Satoshi's coins to Wright would have anywhere near the same level of support.

But if it were to happen, what are the chances a fork of Bitcoin (that doesn’t respect this ruling) becomes more mainstream than Bitcoin? Less than 10%, and that’s generous.

I see it the other way. 10% chance that the Craitoshi fork of BTC becomes mainstream.

Re: Craig Wright said he invented Bitcoin – lawyers proved him wrong

#55

So, to recap, a large global industry is built on a foundation that the true identity of a particular currently-anonymous person must never be identified and certainly not posthumously.

I think the crypto industry would go on. It's just Satoshi would rather keep his head down.

Re: Craig Wright said he invented Bitcoin – lawyers proved him wrong

#57
post #47

This man is a true hero …to liars everywhere. He lied, he forged documents, he filed suits. Most people will never go to these lengths to back up their lies, no matter how big the potential windfall. You have to respect the dedication if nothing else.

It's certainly interesting, but he's not a hero.

Re: Craig Wright said he invented Bitcoin – lawyers proved him wrong

#58

It was always sad to me that most of the people I met who believed him were non-native English speakers. Just my experience with his followers in person. Made me suspect they couldnt detect nuance or bullshit in our language.

It's frightening to think about the implications of this when generalized toward mainstream topics.

Re: Craig Wright said he invented Bitcoin – lawyers proved him wrong

#59

> …lawyers picked apart Wright’s claims that some of his computer documents had been typed before 2008, using evidence from font designers. The witnesses testified that some fonts “hadn’t even been created until years after the alleged date of the document”… https://craigwright.net/ Fascinating.

Fun fact: A Microsoft font also helped expose corruption by Pakistan's former PM, Nawaz Sharif [1]. Apparently, documents dated to 2006 were typed up using Calibri, a font that only went into public distribution around 2007. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2017/7/12/15961354/pakistan-calibri...

I guess it's prudent to remember to always use Times New Roman when committing fraud.

Re: Craig Wright said he invented Bitcoin – lawyers proved him wrong

#60

If he's not Satoshi and doesn't have Satoshi's keys the what is the point of saying he is Satoshi? Seems like a long way to go for some notoriety and no financial gain.

He attempted to sue Bitcoin core devs to alter the algorithm to hand over Satoshi's coins. On the basis that he lost the keys and that the maintainers have a duty to him to help him recover them. Every part of the lawsuit was just batshit insane. The most insane part was that an UK court allowed the lawsuit to be heard, and forced dozens of people not living in UK to pay big money to defend themselves.

> forced dozens of people not living in UK to pay big money to defend themselves.

At the risk of not being able to enjoy castles and blood pudding on vacation, couldn't they just ignore the suit?

Post reply on HN