Live data from Hacker News

Judge stops FTC from enforcing ban on non-compete agreements

computerworld.com

111–120 of 222 posts

Re: Judge stops FTC from enforcing ban on non-compete agreements

#111
post #105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know if you're being good faith, prisoners are forced to work https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prison_farm

> The study examined 62 private prisons contracts in 21 states. It found that the majority of these contracts guarantee that the state will supply enough prisoners to keep between 80 and 100 percent of the private prisons’ beds filled. https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/do-p... (2013)

The US does not falsely convict and jail innocent people en masse as policy. If anything. A much bigger problem is that the US does not convict and jail criminals en masse as policy.

There is no better time and place to be a criminal in the US than today. Criminals are being coddled, which is why most Democrat cities are so crime-ridden.

Re: Judge stops FTC from enforcing ban on non-compete agreements

#113

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not at all! I'd prefer that the power of the executive be stripped down to the point where neither party can accomplish any of their campaign promises without passing laws in Congress. Both parties have pivoted their entire strategy towards making presidential campaign promises, delivering them as temporary administrative rules (i.e. this from the Democrats, immigration law from the Republicans), and then frantically…

This is why I think the US's Presidential system is fatally flawed, and should be abolished in favor of a parliamentary system, similar to those in the two countries that the US helped set up such systems: Germany and Japan.

>Japan

Sweet baby Jesus NO.

Japan is literally a 1.5 party state (LDP with Komei Party latching on as yes men), and the last time the Japanese electorate decided to give the minority JDP a shot it resulted in the worst manmade nuclear disaster in post-war history and the JDP collapsing into two different and irrelevant parties (CDP and DPFP).

And today the LDP party leader election stems from a leaderless leader (Kishida) failing to both lead his country (stagnant economy and policies) and manage his party (politicians from mere Parliament members to cabinet ministers engaging in literal tax evasion).

All the while the Japanese electorate's sentiment is "o rly" because nobody couldn't care less who becomes the new LDP leader and thus next Japanese Prime Minister because nothing will really change. I haven't met a single Japanese voter who understands how Parliament members are elected, either.

I frankly much prefer the American shithouse, at least it's fun and even makes sense (yes, including the Electoral College) once you actually study it.

Context note: I'm Japanese-American.

Re: Judge stops FTC from enforcing ban on non-compete agreements

#114
post #105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know if you're being good faith, prisoners are forced to work https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prison_farm

No US prisoner is forced to work in any meaningful sense of the word "forced". They can just not work, they won't get beaten for it, they won't get killed for it. In some states, they are required to work. It's not the same as being forced to work. Being a criminal does not entitled them to free room and board on the taxpayer dime, in fact in a just world, society would be entitled to restitution from the criminal. T…

> No US prisoner is forced to work in any meaningful sense of the word "forced".

"Refusal to work can be met with solitary confinement and physical beatings"

https://web.archive.org/web/20240224172720/https://www.washi...

Re: Judge stops FTC from enforcing ban on non-compete agreements

#115

Question from an outsider: Why is that 95% of the times I see something get stopped or overturned, it is from a court / judge in Texas?

Reflects the bias of your news reading. Federal courts mirror the politics of their location. Naturally this leads to circuit splits.

Re: Judge stops FTC from enforcing ban on non-compete agreements

#116
post #99

In Europe if you want to force a non-compete you need to pay full salary for the duration, so if someone enforced non compete for 5 years I could sit home and play games while earning salary

Europe is not a single country, and even a single country would usually not have perfectly homogenous laws in all is regions.

...But in the near future they will have to agree on the common directive on this topic, which for now considers them as nonbinding, except for very specific corner cases, if even: https://competition-policy.ec.europa.eu/document/download/ad...

Re: Judge stops FTC from enforcing ban on non-compete agreements

#117
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The Heritage Foundation, sometimes referred to simply as "Heritage", is an activist American conservative think tank based in Washington, D.C. Yeah, thanks for that unbiased source.

Bias does not change facts. There is no better time and place to be a criminal in the US than today. Criminals are being coddled, which is why most Democrat cities are so crime-ridden.

I’m not sold on this narrative. Which Republican cities are you comparing to?

Re: Judge stops FTC from enforcing ban on non-compete agreements

#119

Question from an outsider: Why is that 95% of the times I see something get stopped or overturned, it is from a court / judge in Texas?

A couple reasons:

1) Recency bias, you probably remember more of these cases from Texas right now because that's the subject of this article.

2) The district and appelate courts in the US vary widely in their judicial ideologies, and usually align closely with their local political leanings. In today's political landscape with a democratic administration, it's unsurprising that courts in conservative districts frequently rule against federal agencies. Notably this judge was appointed by Trump, and is citing recent rulings and legal theory from the current radically conservative Supreme Court. Judges in liberal areas are still under some obligation to take precedent into account, so the case may have gone the same way even with a liberal judge, now that the Chevron Doctrine is more or less dead due to the Supreme Court. But liberal judges still often diverge from the legal theory conservative supreme court justices are using today.

3) Judge shopping, ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forum_shopping#United_States ) the case was intentionally filed in a district that is known for conservative judges that are friendly to corporations, were appointed by Trump, and align closely to the supreme court's legal ideology. The Northern District of Texas were this case was decided is a common choice for such shopping, especially because they explicitly ignore policy guidelines (that are sadly nonbinding) to prevent judge shopping.

Re: Judge stops FTC from enforcing ban on non-compete agreements

#120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Bias does not change facts. There is no better time and place to be a criminal in the US than today. Criminals are being coddled, which is why most Democrat cities are so crime-ridden.

I’m not sold on this narrative. Which Republican cities are you comparing to?

The 10 most violent cities in the US are either democrat or independent controlled: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-53991722
Post reply on HN