Live data from Hacker News

Google is a monopoly – the fix isn't obvious

theregister.com

1–10 of 524 posts

Re: Google is a monopoly – the fix isn't obvious

#4
1. Forbid Google from paying Apple and Android OEM’s to be the default search engine. Also, detach Google search from Android and forbid Google from forcing it to be included on every Android phone.

2. Give Google search competitors access to Google’s search data so these new AI search engine companies can compete. Without these huge amounts of data, they have no chance.

Done!

Re: Google is a monopoly – the fix isn't obvious

#5
I agree that Google has an inordinate amount of power in the market and that it has to be restrained. That said, I do not like the 'better' qualifier here. It depends too much on who is reading it. Hell, it is not impossible average user will dislike the change ( but they always do).

Re: Google is a monopoly – the fix isn't obvious

#6
I think Google can win this easily by using the public opinion against the regulators.

They just need to say that they are gonna start charging for all their services because without the level of integration they have it doesn't make sense to keep running businesses that otherwise would lose money.

Re: Google is a monopoly – the fix isn't obvious

#8
post #4

1. Forbid Google from paying Apple and Android OEM’s to be the default search engine. Also, detach Google search from Android and forbid Google from forcing it to be included on every Android phone. 2. Give Google search competitors access to Google’s search data so these new AI search engine companies can compete. Without these huge amounts of data, they have no chance. Done!

2 is not how the US breaks up monopolies

Re: Google is a monopoly – the fix isn't obvious

#9
post #4

1. Forbid Google from paying Apple and Android OEM’s to be the default search engine. Also, detach Google search from Android and forbid Google from forcing it to be included on every Android phone. 2. Give Google search competitors access to Google’s search data so these new AI search engine companies can compete. Without these huge amounts of data, they have no chance. Done!

Then do the same for Microsoft with Windows?

Re: Google is a monopoly – the fix isn't obvious

#10

breaking it up will also weaken US Dominance in Tech, the fact that Android and Chrome are under them same umbrella helps them share IP across the company and decreases RD costs because some of the costs are shared.

Um, I agree with your first sentence, but I don't think I follow the rationale. What are you trying to say?
Post reply on HN