Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Double – Design and invest in your own stock index

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 103 posts

Re: Show HN: Double – Design and invest in your own stock index

#41
post #25

This is cool. There is a lot of hesitation to move significant assets from my Charles Schwab brokerage account. That's going to be my main hurdle. I need to understand the safety, trust, trading mechanics, flexibility that I have with Charles Schwab, all of those things become very valuable when talking about high amounts for retirement purposes. I don't really know what you can do there to attract such clients? Will…

>> There is a lot of hesitation to move significant assets from my Charles Schwab brokerage account. I'm incredibly double-minded about this. M1 offers essentially the same service and they do it very well. I've compared M1 vs Fidelity Basket Portfolio (which also offers yet almost the same service.) Here are my takes - M1 is easy to use (mostly, though same super-strange UX choices) - M1 is a pleasure to use - M1 do…

> accounting info is held separately in APEX

So the good news is that M1 doesn't use apex for clearing anymore

The bad news is that... things got worse? After they swapped to doing clearing in house, they dropped like a month of incoming wires without reaching out at all, until I noticed on my monthly login. Turns out that they had changed the underlying wire instructions (makes sense), but sent an email saying that nothing would change on transfer instructions (not true).

Then the next month, they still dropped wires even with the correct instructions, because... ???? unknown reason. Again no contact, until I reached out and asked wtf. Third month, everything worked even though nothing was changed from the prior month.

So there's a reason why I won't put more than SIPC worth in M1 or any other new fintech. And yes, it's backend incompetence as the primary reason.

Re: Show HN: Double – Design and invest in your own stock index

#42
In regards to making a "S&P - company/sector" portfolio, how can you compete with other ETF issuers? I feel like you wouldn't be able to get an expense ratio close enough to other large ETFs for the risk weighted return to overcome it. You can maintain a low expense ratio that down weights a sector by combining ETFs. But instead of having a high AUM to reduce churn, that expense is on me.

Re: Show HN: Double – Design and invest in your own stock index

#43
If I were to set up a customized S&P500 (with some tweaks) and over time companies leave and/or are added to the index. Will those changes be reflected in my custom S&P500? In the months or years in the future will it buy or sell these new currently unknown companies?

Re: Show HN: Double – Design and invest in your own stock index

#45

This is great, exactly what I was looking for, but how do I know I can trust you? I'm a bit hesitant to wire large amounts of money to a startup. Also, how do you make money?

Why trust us? 1. We're working with Apex Clearing, a large US Custodian with more than $100B of assets. Your account is in your name there. 2. We're well funded and backed by reputable investors (YC, Matrix, Youtube Cofounder, and many others). 3. We are registered with the SEC as an registered investment advisor. 4. I personally am in the process of transferring nearly my entire net worth onto the platform. We event…

PFOF is a deal breaker. If everyone but Fidelity is doing it thats a huge selling point for Fidelity. Go against the grain and do what is right for your customer if you want to have the net worth of people who care about their money and thus more trust than Robinhood.
Post reply on HN