Live data from Hacker News

Launch HN: Trellis (YC W24) – AI-powered workflows for unstructured data

news.ycombinator.com

111–120 of 124 posts

Re: Launch HN: Trellis (YC W24) – AI-powered workflows for unstructured data

#111

Very cool - I've been working on an open source python package that lets you do some similar things ( https://github.com/expectedparrot/edsl ). Here's an example of the Enron email demo using the edsl syntax/package & a few different LLMs: https://www.expectedparrot.com/content/6607caa1-efc5-439f-85...

That is very cool, thank you for sharing.

Re: Launch HN: Trellis (YC W24) – AI-powered workflows for unstructured data

#112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Appreciate the note. 1. I completely agree. Last-mile accuracy is crucial for enterprise buyers, and the challenge isn't just the AI. It's about mapping their business logic and workflows to the product in a way that demonstrates fast time to value. 2. Thanks for the feedback. We're still refining the messaging and don't want to be overly focused on just the extraction aspect. Do you think positioning it as ETL for u…

2. I think that "AI" and "unstructured data" sounded "cool" 5 years ago :) I'd be mindblown if you said, "We turn PDFs into structured data with 99.99% accuracy. Here is how:" And then tell me about fine-tuning human-in-the-loop stuff.

[deleted]

Re: Launch HN: Trellis (YC W24) – AI-powered workflows for unstructured data

#113
post #106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I created automated descision suppport systems in asset based finance. For daily needs you get customer financials and other risk data from both official national sources and the likes of Dunn and Bradstreet, Graydon etc. The choice of providers depends on both the customer and deal risk/size. While the "api"'s to these providers might be clunky (putting structured request file on an ftp server and polling for a resp…

Thanks. I see the context now. Our asset managers are indeed lucky to have Bloomberg and such, which are easily integratable (and indeed, have been "SQL" for more than a decade now). I'm aware of the third party providers of customer financial information. Lucky to operate in a niche that is not served by them. Graydon (the only one I've been in contact with) is facing a massive disruption though. Their higher tiers…

"think their data quality should be exceptional and then use end user computing MacGyver style models"

The choice they have is submit a formal request to IT, be rejected 95% of the time with the remaing 5% being put in the planning with an eta 2-5 years in the future, or, DIY it with tools at hand. In an ideal world this would not be needed, in reality it is DIY or nothing.

Re: Launch HN: Trellis (YC W24) – AI-powered workflows for unstructured data

#114
post #111

Very cool - I've been working on an open source python package that lets you do some similar things ( https://github.com/expectedparrot/edsl ). Here's an example of the Enron email demo using the edsl syntax/package & a few different LLMs: https://www.expectedparrot.com/content/6607caa1-efc5-439f-85...

That is very cool, thank you for sharing.

thanks! B/c it got some positive reaction here, I did a little thread on how you can turn this flow into an API: https://x.com/johnjhorton/status/1823672992624242895

Re: Launch HN: Trellis (YC W24) – AI-powered workflows for unstructured data

#115

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We use a combination of fine-tune LLMs models that're specialized at extraction, data validation and parsing and large foundational models for more general reasoning tasks. Model routing architecture has been quite interesting to explore.

Have you tried the Structured Output feature that OpenAI released last week?

I'd be curious to know the answer to this also.

Re: Launch HN: Trellis (YC W24) – AI-powered workflows for unstructured data

#116

Interesting! One quick question, how did you validate your data and ensure its correctness, since the ground truth is unstructured?

Not OP but based on their writeup it sounds like you do need to provide at least a target schema, so what data you need or expect to extract from the unstructured input.

I assume that in the validation step if you don't get all those data points, then that routes to an error state for further review or something.

Re: Launch HN: Trellis (YC W24) – AI-powered workflows for unstructured data

#117

Very cool - I've been working on an open source python package that lets you do some similar things ( https://github.com/expectedparrot/edsl ). Here's an example of the Enron email demo using the edsl syntax/package & a few different LLMs: https://www.expectedparrot.com/content/6607caa1-efc5-439f-85...

Thanks for sharing! It handled the emails very well.

Re: Launch HN: Trellis (YC W24) – AI-powered workflows for unstructured data

#118
post #102
post #93

> a major commercial bank I work with couldn’t improve credit risk models because critical data was stuck in PDFs and emails. Great use case! Worked on exactly this a decade ago. It was Hard™ then. Could only make so much progress. Getting this right is a huge value unlock. Congrats!

Make sure you have an on-premise option for this type of customer. I've worked at two software companies in Europe with tangentially similar products related to document analysis. On premise is a key requirement. Even though it's 2024, banks, financial institutions like insurance companies etc. tend to be _very_ cautious with valuable documents involving customers. There are also regional regulations that prevent thi…

On-premise will be a lot more difficult than just launching a few pods in Kubernetes. These AI tools (LLMs / vision models) will require some high powered gpus as well.

Re: Launch HN: Trellis (YC W24) – AI-powered workflows for unstructured data

#119

Interesting! One quick question, how did you validate your data and ensure its correctness, since the ground truth is unstructured?

The users specify the schema and output format and a validation rule and we make sure the system adheres to that.

Re: Launch HN: Trellis (YC W24) – AI-powered workflows for unstructured data

#120
post #93

> a major commercial bank I work with couldn’t improve credit risk models because critical data was stuck in PDFs and emails. Great use case! Worked on exactly this a decade ago. It was Hard™ then. Could only make so much progress. Getting this right is a huge value unlock. Congrats!

Who is liable when the ML model hallucinates™ while parsing some critical data?

Better still if it can then become a source of truth for further departures from reality.

Post reply on HN