Live data from Hacker News

L402: The Missing Piece in the Internet's Payment Infrastructure

l402.org

1–10 of 146 posts

Re: L402: The Missing Piece in the Internet's Payment Infrastructure

#5
I'm not seeing anything in the protocol that stops the first human from paying for the resource and then sharing their macaroon+preimage with everyone else. Normally, I'd account for that by associating the preimage with a specific human (account) but this seems to be intended for use without accounts?

Re: L402: The Missing Piece in the Internet's Payment Infrastructure

#6

Can anyone tell me why this is any better than just logging in? This seems like its solving a problem that doesnt exist.

Different problem?

Having created a micropayment network, you quickly discover that infrastructure does not exist where you want to use it. Web APIs are kind of the obvious use case, but because there was no micropayment system they trended to an account and batch payment method by necessity.

This aims to fill that infrastructure gap. Of course, there's a huge chicken-and-egg bootstrap problem, but you have to start somewhere!

Re: L402: The Missing Piece in the Internet's Payment Infrastructure

#8

I'm not seeing anything in the protocol that stops the first human from paying for the resource and then sharing their macaroon+preimage with everyone else. Normally, I'd account for that by associating the preimage with a specific human (account) but this seems to be intended for use without accounts?

Presumably the macaroon itself contains a shortish timeout.

You can rate-limit (runes do this, which are simplified macaroons) but then the server is no longer stateless. Pretty sure I've ranted about this in HN comments before, could dig it out if you're interested?

Post reply on HN