Live data from Hacker News

Three years in North Korea as a foreigner (2021)

mydiplomaticlife.com

271–280 of 307 posts

Re: Three years in North Korea as a foreigner (2021)

#271

I wish to know more about this time-capsule country. Currently the country seems to experience an extraordinary construction boom (modern apartment buildings). All we have are 20 years old pictures.

The concentration/prison camps are not often mentioned. I think there was a post about them on HN previously.

The crazy negatives and activities of the NK government are the only aspect of the country that I see mentioned, usually.

Re: Three years in North Korea as a foreigner (2021)

#272

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's seeing aspects of a fundamentally different form of government that's the appeal. If it was just seeing "Korean" culture, I'd have gone to South Korea years ago. (BTW, a good friend of mine told me he's been skiing in view of the DMZ, and they just laugh at the NK guards watching them ski with binoculars.)

I'd counter that the South is an interesting place in its own right. Skipping it because it's too much like Western countries is to miss out on all the fascinating ways it isn't. Furthermore, I'd question the value of finding out for yourself what life is like under a famine-stricken, xenophobic, totalitarian, hereditary absolute monarchy. What is it you're hoping to get out of an experience like that?

You're trying to adjudicate why someone thinks something is interesting when you do not by attempting to formulate a rational reason for why their interest is wrong. A difficult challenge.

Re: Three years in North Korea as a foreigner (2021)

#273
post #243

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm surprised you're surprised. I guess people from countries with fully functional monetary systems don't have an intuitive view how things work where money are essentially worthless. Most communist countries were like this during the centralized and hence highly disfunctional economy. You were paid a wage but essentially could shove it up your ass coze there was little to nothing to buy with it. Which made barter t…

> Non-fungible goods: alcohol, cigarettes and coffee. Aren’t all of these fungible?

Less fungible

Re: Three years in North Korea as a foreigner (2021)

#274

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Meanwhile instead of some fancy building, their embassy over here is... Well, a little more domestic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embassy_of_North_Korea,_London

I went in once. They had an open-day demonstrating the skills of north Korean artists. The artwork was decent, and the experience a good one overall. Every room had a picture of Kim, obviously.

Every public room in my state's DMVs has a picture of the governor, so that last bit may not mean as much as you think it does.

Re: Three years in North Korea as a foreigner (2021)

#275

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am intersted in your version of my answer. I don't think picking at elements from my list and just saying "no" is fruitful.

I disagree, and am deliberately not trying to start a protracted debate here. I'm just offering a data point, nothing more.

Well, it seems we have arrived at an impasse.

Re: Three years in North Korea as a foreigner (2021)

#276

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The concentration/prison camps are not often mentioned. I think there was a post about them on HN previously.

The crazy negatives and activities of the NK government are the only aspect of the country that I see mentioned, usually.

Are there positives? Probably not.

Anything positive would require some effort to spin it that way.

Re: Three years in North Korea as a foreigner (2021)

#277

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's seeing aspects of a fundamentally different form of government that's the appeal. If it was just seeing "Korean" culture, I'd have gone to South Korea years ago. (BTW, a good friend of mine told me he's been skiing in view of the DMZ, and they just laugh at the NK guards watching them ski with binoculars.)

I'd counter that the South is an interesting place in its own right. Skipping it because it's too much like Western countries is to miss out on all the fascinating ways it isn't. Furthermore, I'd question the value of finding out for yourself what life is like under a famine-stricken, xenophobic, totalitarian, hereditary absolute monarchy. What is it you're hoping to get out of an experience like that?

I don't understand why you're trying to push me to visit a country I have no interest in visiting. (There's plenty of places I'd rather visit before South Korea.)

In the case of North Korea: It's difficult to explain unless you're in a listening mode, but I'll try:

First: I would never go under the current government. Full stop. I won't go somewhere where I don't feel safe.

Second: I don't endorse their government in any way.

For me, the best analogy would be traveling to East Germany in the early 1990s after the fall of communism. IE, visit the Berlin Wall, and maybe listen to some locals tell their story.

So, assuming North Korea's government changes in my lifetime, I'd love to visit and "see it" before it gets torn down.

One of the things I like hearing is how people work around constraints and obstacles. These are the kinds of stories I'm interested in.

Re: Three years in North Korea as a foreigner (2021)

#278

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I went in once. They had an open-day demonstrating the skills of north Korean artists. The artwork was decent, and the experience a good one overall. Every room had a picture of Kim, obviously.

Every public room in my state's DMVs has a picture of the governor, so that last bit may not mean as much as you think it does.

That just means that US and North Korea are weird in the same way.

Re: Three years in North Korea as a foreigner (2021)

#279

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I went in once. They had an open-day demonstrating the skills of north Korean artists. The artwork was decent, and the experience a good one overall. Every room had a picture of Kim, obviously.

Every public room in my state's DMVs has a picture of the governor, so that last bit may not mean as much as you think it does.

What state do you live in? I can't imagine that happening here in Washington state, even if our DMVs are all one big room.

Re: Three years in North Korea as a foreigner (2021)

#280
post #96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Curious if anyone knows of any more recent descriptions about what life is like in North Korea, like in the last 5-10 years. Most things I've read including this article are decades old. How much have things changed there in terms of technology, food security etc?

There's hours and hours of NK footage if you search for North Korea Travel / Vlog in simplified chinese. They tend to have much laxer guides/minders, fluent in mandarin vs western travellers with minders with shit English (and I presume more suspicious / cautious). Very few of Chinese vlogs have auto subtitles which can be translated to english unfortunately. Example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kZgzAquCs-o&list=…

They won't let Americans in, except during the mas games, and even otherwise you can usually get in with a Chinese tour group. One of my American coworkers in Beijing went back in 2011 or so, and didn't have any problem, although I got the feeling it wasn't as interesting as she thought it would be.

Educationally speaking, the DPRK would catch up pretty quickly if they were able to liberalize their economy as much as China, even without all the help they could get from ROK, Japan, USA. It isn't Afghanistan (where liberalization wouldn't stick), or even Laos where there is a lot of work to do on modernizing society, which makes its current state even more depressing.

Post reply on HN