For example, I have a sentence "Er überreicht ihm ein Geschenk" (He hands him a gift), then I ask GPT to create an image of that situation and it generates a girl giving a gift to a man. :(
Surprising gender biases in GPT
41–50 of 148 posts
Re: Surprising gender biases in GPT
#42> This phenomenon likely reflects that while initiatives to integrate women in traditionally masculine roles have gained momentum, the reverse movement remains relatively under developed. Not really surprising IMHO. Yes, there has been a huge focus on accepting women in the workplace and no, there has not really been a push accepting men as primary caregivers in the family. This likely uncovers underlying motives for…
What’s interesting to me is that (if I understand correctly) they’re using GPT as a source of information to make this claim. Usually you see conclusions like these being drawn from some sort of sociological study. But here they’re just talking to GPT and using its answers to determine things about the real world. Not disputing the claims. But talking to GPT to get answers about the real world that have to do with va…
Re: Surprising gender biases in GPT
#43Earlier quoted context omitted.
It also fits into the larger societal trend of horribly underserving Zoomer and Alpha (maybe young Millennials too) young boys and men. I've heard someone put it very succinctly: people like Andrew Tate are asking the right questions, but giving abominable answers. I can drop some very simple statistics: women have been getting more bachelors degrees since the 80s . Most university gender ratios are 40/60 trending to…
I am forever unsympathetic to feminism so long as it's about forcing the pendulum to the other end. As someone who sincerely believes in gender equality, any argument (other than something stemming from unchangable facts of biology) that involves "men" or "women" specifically is hogwash. No, it should be for man as in mankind. Everyone deserves to be treated fairly and equally.
You undermined your own point with such impressive brevity that it could be satire.
Re: Surprising gender biases in GPT
#44> This phenomenon likely reflects that while initiatives to integrate women in traditionally masculine roles have gained momentum, the reverse movement remains relatively under developed. Not really surprising IMHO. Yes, there has been a huge focus on accepting women in the workplace and no, there has not really been a push accepting men as primary caregivers in the family. This likely uncovers underlying motives for…
It also fits into the larger societal trend of horribly underserving Zoomer and Alpha (maybe young Millennials too) young boys and men. I've heard someone put it very succinctly: people like Andrew Tate are asking the right questions, but giving abominable answers. I can drop some very simple statistics: women have been getting more bachelors degrees since the 80s . Most university gender ratios are 40/60 trending to…
People like Andrew Tate are the only ones talking to men in those generations at all. As you said, we've left men behind in schooling which is a bad start in life. After that, we have a lot of programmes for women, both educational ("girls who code", etc.) to business things (women-owned businesses can get 3k eur to help them start in my country, many business-women awards, etc.), to healthcare (especially mental), economic (especially pensions, where up until recently men had to work more years and get lower pensions at same paychecks in my country... this has been fixed a bit recently, but men still live less on average but have to work the same years and get the same pensions even though they'll get them for less time). Also hollywood, where they replaced a lot of the traditional men roles with women (from superheroes to "fun nerds") while making men more and more incompetent (and that's not a new thing, just look at an average sitcom, especially from the 80s).... well, and lets not forget who has to die in wars, if the want to, or not.
So yeah... after all that, there are a few people who actually talk to those men (be it Tate, Milo, or whoever), and give them men-oriented advice (good, or bad), that doesn't revolve around women. ... no shit the kids will like the only fw people who talk to them.
A video version of this made in a fun way, but not far from truth: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rQv8VuLpKN4
Re: Surprising gender biases in GPT
#45Yes, I will accept all the downvotes but I know for sure many more will agree with me.
Re: Surprising gender biases in GPT
#46> This phenomenon likely reflects that while initiatives to integrate women in traditionally masculine roles have gained momentum, the reverse movement remains relatively under developed. Not really surprising IMHO. Yes, there has been a huge focus on accepting women in the workplace and no, there has not really been a push accepting men as primary caregivers in the family. This likely uncovers underlying motives for…
> the traditional feminine roles does not generate revenue This is not the whole story according to the divorce courts, with women often being awarded compensation for their contribution to their husband’s career, recognizing that they are a key enabling factor for the man - and why not? Men who don’t need to spend their time on childcare and household duties can dedicate that time to more work -> more pay.
Re: Surprising gender biases in GPT
#47Earlier quoted context omitted.
I am forever unsympathetic to feminism so long as it's about forcing the pendulum to the other end. As someone who sincerely believes in gender equality, any argument (other than something stemming from unchangable facts of biology) that involves "men" or "women" specifically is hogwash. No, it should be for man as in mankind. Everyone deserves to be treated fairly and equally.
>No, it should be for man as in mankind You undermined your own point with such impressive brevity that it could be satire.
Re: Surprising gender biases in GPT
#48> This phenomenon likely reflects that while initiatives to integrate women in traditionally masculine roles have gained momentum, the reverse movement remains relatively under developed. Not really surprising IMHO. Yes, there has been a huge focus on accepting women in the workplace and no, there has not really been a push accepting men as primary caregivers in the family. This likely uncovers underlying motives for…
What’s interesting to me is that (if I understand correctly) they’re using GPT as a source of information to make this claim. Usually you see conclusions like these being drawn from some sort of sociological study. But here they’re just talking to GPT and using its answers to determine things about the real world. Not disputing the claims. But talking to GPT to get answers about the real world that have to do with va…
Re: Surprising gender biases in GPT
#49> This phenomenon likely reflects that while initiatives to integrate women in traditionally masculine roles have gained momentum, the reverse movement remains relatively under developed. Not really surprising IMHO. Yes, there has been a huge focus on accepting women in the workplace and no, there has not really been a push accepting men as primary caregivers in the family. This likely uncovers underlying motives for…
It also fits into the larger societal trend of horribly underserving Zoomer and Alpha (maybe young Millennials too) young boys and men. I've heard someone put it very succinctly: people like Andrew Tate are asking the right questions, but giving abominable answers. I can drop some very simple statistics: women have been getting more bachelors degrees since the 80s . Most university gender ratios are 40/60 trending to…
I'm guessing it might be at smaller Universities, or country specific?
Re: Surprising gender biases in GPT
#50Looks to me like GPT is able to account for the predictable effects of testosterone in gender-based decision making. I would be absolutely shocked if GPT came out with some kind of gender-based analysis that males and females are the same and moral choices around them make no consideration of their gender nature. GPT is based on a body of content sourced from reality. I'm not the least bit surprised that it took test…
It is not "able" to do anything. It's just spewing most probable tokens at you.