Live data from Hacker News

Amazon EC2 Instance Comparison

ec2instances.info

11–20 of 98 posts

Re: Amazon EC2 Instance Comparison

#11
post #6

This is awesome. I was starting some instances this morning, and it's shocking how poorly Amazon describes what they offer. I had three browser windows and a calculator open just to figure out which instances are being offered, and at which relative prices. You'd think they would spend more time on this stuff.

What can we do better? What don't we tell you that would help you to make a more informed decision?

Re: Amazon EC2 Instance Comparison

#12
post #6

This is awesome. I was starting some instances this morning, and it's shocking how poorly Amazon describes what they offer. I had three browser windows and a calculator open just to figure out which instances are being offered, and at which relative prices. You'd think they would spend more time on this stuff.

What can we do better? What don't we tell you that would help you to make a more informed decision?

I think it would make sense to merge the pricing and instance type sections (in a similar way to the linked page), and to also have all of that information in the new instance flow of the management console.

It would also be great if you could show estimated monthly/weekly pricing for each instance type, with comparisons for reserved and on demand versions.

Re: Amazon EC2 Instance Comparison

#13
post #6

This is awesome. I was starting some instances this morning, and it's shocking how poorly Amazon describes what they offer. I had three browser windows and a calculator open just to figure out which instances are being offered, and at which relative prices. You'd think they would spend more time on this stuff.

What can we do better? What don't we tell you that would help you to make a more informed decision?

Not the person you asked the question to but, if I may, I would suggest a 2 (or maybe 3) step drilldown. A high level, more condensed, summary-type of chart (kind of like the one seen in the original post) that would give a clear overview of the differences between the various types of instances (OnDemand, Reserved, Spot). And then a way to drill down into instance types and see the details (AZ, Linux vs Windows, etc...)

My issues with the current layout are:

- all the text blocks in between charts that are not really informative after you've read them once.

- The fact that the instance types, data transfer, EBS, etc... are all listed at the same logical level when I make a clear distinction between, on the one hand, all the different instance types and, on the other hand, everything that pertains to an instance (logically underneath an instance).

Re: Amazon EC2 Instance Comparison

#14
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What can we do better? What don't we tell you that would help you to make a more informed decision?

I think it would make sense to merge the pricing and instance type sections (in a similar way to the linked page), and to also have all of that information in the new instance flow of the management console. It would also be great if you could show estimated monthly/weekly pricing for each instance type, with comparisons for reserved and on demand versions.

I can't upvote more

Re: Amazon EC2 Instance Comparison

#15
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What can we do better? What don't we tell you that would help you to make a more informed decision?

I think it would make sense to merge the pricing and instance type sections (in a similar way to the linked page), and to also have all of that information in the new instance flow of the management console. It would also be great if you could show estimated monthly/weekly pricing for each instance type, with comparisons for reserved and on demand versions.

That's excellent feedback. I will make sure that the team is aware of it tomorrow morning.

Re: Amazon EC2 Instance Comparison

#16
There has been a lot of discussion on HN about dedicated hosting at Hetzner vs Amazon, and while they offer different pros and cons, Amazon appears to be a lot more expensive for comparable or even worse specs. Here's a comparison of two servers that have roughly comparable specs, Amazon High-Memory Double Extra Large and Hetzner ex8s:

  cpu:
  hetzner: Intel Xeon E3-1275 (4 physical cores)
  ec2: 4 virtual cores (13 "ecus" where each ecu is ~ 2007 xeon core)

  ram:
  hetzner: 32 GB ECC
  ec2: 34 GB (previous commenters have speculated that it's non-ecc because Amazon only mentions otherwise for compute units)

  disk:
  hetnzer: customizable, cheapest is 3TB disk or 120 GB SSD for 15 euros/month
  ec2: 850 GB (ephermeral)

  network:
  hetzner: 100 Mbit (incoming free, 10TB outgoing free, 7 euros/TB after)
  ec2: unknown speed (incoming free, $0.12/GB outgoing, $120/TB)

  price:
  hetzner: ~$265 for first month, $115 thereafter (includes setup fee, excludes VAT, after euro to usd conversion, 
  includes cheapest hd option)
  ec2: $648/month
There are a lot of other factors like the additional services amazon provides, failover, scaling, bandwidth quality, US ping times, reserved instance pricing, etc. It's not a straightforward comparison, but I would argue that for many users hetzner is the much faster and cheaper option.

edit: formatting, spelling

Re: Amazon EC2 Instance Comparison

#17
would it be a stretch to pull in Rackspace, and any other large EC2-like providers? I think having one of these tables as all in one during a meeting is going to get some managers to reconsider their positions.

Re: Amazon EC2 Instance Comparison

#19
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What can we do better? What don't we tell you that would help you to make a more informed decision?

I think it would make sense to merge the pricing and instance type sections (in a similar way to the linked page), and to also have all of that information in the new instance flow of the management console. It would also be great if you could show estimated monthly/weekly pricing for each instance type, with comparisons for reserved and on demand versions.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN