Live data from Hacker News

Making the Kinopio source code public

pketh.org

21–30 of 63 posts

Re: Making the Kinopio source code public

#25

1. Not technically open source since you can’t use for commercial, but ignoring the pedantry. 2. You’re clearly worried about the commercial risk, why even do it? You have a section on this but even after reading - seems like a non answer.

> The big benefit of open source for me is that it’s another way to share the work that goes into Kinopio.

Re: Making the Kinopio source code public

#27
post #5

Sorry to be pedantic, but since the licence forbids commercial use, the software isn't open source, but rather just source-available.

We definitely need a term, more accurate than source-available, that describes software whose usage and improvements can only orbit in non-commercial space.

For non-software creative works, we have Creative Commons NonCommercial licenses.

Re: Making the Kinopio source code public

#28
post #26
post #5

Sorry to be pedantic, but since the licence forbids commercial use, the software isn't open source, but rather just source-available.

thanks for letting me know, I've changed the title of the post to "Making the Kinopio Source Code Available"

You might be interested in fair.io, launching next month. We ran into a similar problem a year ago that ended up stirring up a lot of drama, so we are now promoting the term Fair Source instead of Open Source.

Fair Source: https://fair.io/

Our drama: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36971490

Lots more context: https://openpath.chadwhitacre.com/2024/the-historical-case-f...

Re: Making the Kinopio source code public

#29
post #5

Sorry to be pedantic, but since the licence forbids commercial use, the software isn't open source, but rather just source-available.

We definitely need a term, more accurate than source-available, that describes software whose usage and improvements can only orbit in non-commercial space. For non-software creative works, we have Creative Commons NonCommercial licenses.

Yes! We aim to launch https://fair.io/ next month to promote the term Fair Source for this purpose. Early feedback is guardedly positive, e.g., ESR's take was "very clever."

https://openpath.chadwhitacre.com/2024/the-historical-case-f...

Re: Making the Kinopio source code public

#30
post #5

Sorry to be pedantic, but since the licence forbids commercial use, the software isn't open source, but rather just source-available.

We definitely need a term, more accurate than source-available, that describes software whose usage and improvements can only orbit in non-commercial space. For non-software creative works, we have Creative Commons NonCommercial licenses.

Why? We all know what "source available" mean and that it's not really open-source.
Post reply on HN