Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft breached antitrust rules by bundling Teams and Office, EU says

apnews.com

1–10 of 808 posts

Re: Microsoft breached antitrust rules by bundling Teams and Office, EU says

#4
Why is it okay for Office to include Word, Excel, or PowerPoint but not a chat application? Does the EU get to decide what is reasonably considered part of a productivity suite? Or is the only requirement that a competitor complains?

This sure seems to say it's illegal to bundle any products together if a competitor for one of the products complains about it.

Re: Microsoft breached antitrust rules by bundling Teams and Office, EU says

#5

Why is it okay for Office to include Word, Excel, or PowerPoint but not a chat application? Does the EU get to decide what is reasonably considered part of a productivity suite? Or is the only requirement that a competitor complains? This sure seems to say it's illegal to bundle any products together if a competitor for one of the products complains about it.

Legality is not science, most of the time, the definition of what's wrong is blurry and humans have to debate about it.

Re: Microsoft breached antitrust rules by bundling Teams and Office, EU says

#6

Why is it okay for Office to include Word, Excel, or PowerPoint but not a chat application? Does the EU get to decide what is reasonably considered part of a productivity suite? Or is the only requirement that a competitor complains? This sure seems to say it's illegal to bundle any products together if a competitor for one of the products complains about it.

Legality is not science, most of the time, the definition of what's wrong is blurry and humans have to debate about it.

Laws shouldn't be written without clear lines - how can a person who wants to avoid breaking the law do that if we have an ever growing list of laws full of gray area and blurry lines?

Re: Microsoft breached antitrust rules by bundling Teams and Office, EU says

#7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Legality is not science, most of the time, the definition of what's wrong is blurry and humans have to debate about it.

Laws shouldn't be written without clear lines - how can a person who wants to avoid breaking the law do that if we have an ever growing list of laws full of gray area and blurry lines?

does this concern your everyday life?

Re: Microsoft breached antitrust rules by bundling Teams and Office, EU says

#8
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Laws shouldn't be written without clear lines - how can a person who wants to avoid breaking the law do that if we have an ever growing list of laws full of gray area and blurry lines?

does this concern your everyday life?

Blurry lines and gray areas in law? Absolutely, I'd rather not accidentally break a law that is only defined after the fact in court.

Re: Microsoft breached antitrust rules by bundling Teams and Office, EU says

#9

Why is it okay for Office to include Word, Excel, or PowerPoint but not a chat application? Does the EU get to decide what is reasonably considered part of a productivity suite? Or is the only requirement that a competitor complains? This sure seems to say it's illegal to bundle any products together if a competitor for one of the products complains about it.

Don’t know what’s hard to understand there? Microsoft didn’t have a chat product (worth anything, Skype was a mountain of crap). Slack comes along and builds a great product, Microsoft goes “oh, the office suite now includes teams!” So everyone gets it “for free” if they have the office suite, murdering slack in the market. And of cause everyone will have to pay for Teams as the price of the office package rises to I cover the costs, no free lunch and all that.

It had been a different story if Teams had always been a part of office, and slack came along and tried to compete. But come on this is a 100% clear cut abuse of a monopoly on windows office programs by Microsoft abused to outcompete a competitor that they couldn’t fight honestly.

Post reply on HN