Live data from Hacker News

Costco Broke into a Surprising New Market: Modular Housing

strongtowns.org

41–42 of 42 posts

Re: Costco Broke into a Surprising New Market: Modular Housing

#41
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Buildings that could have been beautiful and enrich the city and the lives of tenants will end up being stack of containers to bypass government imposed minimum wage and endless regulations. No wonder why soviet union buildings looked like a bland block of concrete. If this is not a cautionary tale on the dangers of regulation, I don't know what is. Congrats to Costco for finding a trick and getting things done, desp…

I don't think the renders of the actual planned development look at all like a stack of containers. That heritage will show inside, though: there's probably not going to be any rooms that are really wide. But modern apartments tend to not have too many of those anyways.

It's a bunch of identical one bedroom apartments, plus shorter studio versions and a corner version with an extra bedroom. The inability to make really wide rooms won't be missed. And the amenity sections do have lots of big rooms. So I don't think it will show.

Re: Costco Broke into a Surprising New Market: Modular Housing

#42
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What about the part where factory-constructed housing is more consistent and higher quality than site-constructed? If I ever build custom, I'd love to use prefab panels, at least.

>What about the part where factory-constructed housing is more consistent and higher quality than site-constructed? If I ever build custom, I'd love to use prefab panels, at least. That's kind of my point. Modular is mostly a design/aesthetic/quality choice for people who can afford it. You would think that the entire purpose would be affordability vs. onsite with the huge labor savings. But these things are so marke…

Hm I wonder why they’re so marked up, any idea? Maybe because the transportation is less efficient because the panels/modules pack less densely than a pile of 2x4s and sheathing?
Post reply on HN