Live data from Hacker News

Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F

sfchronicle.com

81–90 of 449 posts

Re: Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F

#81
post #11
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Obviously you do surrender all of your travel privacy to the data broker. That's why they are making self-driving cars in the first place. But you're already doing all of that by carrying an Android phone.

> That's why they are making self-driving cars in the first place It is? I thought they wanted to disrupt transportation.

I mean the most obvious reason is making money.

But other things like making the roads safer is a nice side effect.

Re: Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F

#82

Based on anecdotal evidence, I strongly suspect these are remotely driven cars, not completely self-driving, which means there is a remote saftey operator ready to take over if the ride starts to go bad. "Self-driving" sounds sexier and is the ultimate goal, but if it were my company I'd probably lead with "remotely monitored by safety driver" to calm any fears people might have. I'm guessing the percentage of people…

Waymo has been pretty clear about this: they do have remote navigators/coaches who tell the cars what to do if it gets stuck/confused, but they're not directly driving the car, they're telling it where to go, like a navigator in the front passenger seat.

Remote operation is considered dangerous due to possible issues with network connection latency or stability. If it was actually happening, Waymo is big enough now (IIRC they said 50,000 paid rides each week) to where someone would've leaked such a secret.

Re: Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F

#83

Cool. Can I take one without my identity and travel patterns being tracked? Like, suppose I want to get picked up from work and dropped off at my girlfriend's house in San Mateo. Something I might not want my soon-to-be-ex's lawyer to be able to subpoena. There's one of those machines onboard that are all over the place in supermarkets where I can feed bills right? Or maybe not. Okay then, Luxor Cab it is. Cheaper, b…

In what was is Google a data broker? Where can you buy this data?

Re: Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F

#84
post #80
post #7

We recently started using Waymo more often: - Quality of Lyft and Uber rides have gone down significantly. - Consistently spacious, clean and quiet cars. You know what you'll get. - AC always works and not up to the whim of the driver. - No chatty driver to disturb our sleeping baby. Negatives: - Rides have usually 10% mark up over Lyft and Uber. - Pick up and drop off tend to be a small walk from requested locations…

From my experience prices for Waymo are at least double that of an equivalent Lyft/Uber ride and wait times are usually 20+ minutes. It is a great novelty but nowhere near where it needs to be to handle real scale.

This won’t last long. Waymo has a treasure chest waiting to be deployed as soon as they start expanding more.

Re: Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F

#85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> - Consistently [...] clean [...] I don't expect this to hold true once Waymo become generally available, alas.

I do. It'll be easier to keep the fleet on a cleaning schedule, and won't be left to the whims of individuals.

By this logic public transportation should be the cleanest of them all. But, it is unfortunately far from that.

Re: Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I do. It'll be easier to keep the fleet on a cleaning schedule, and won't be left to the whims of individuals.

The metric will be "cost of time spent cleaning" / "cost of sending out a dirty car." If this ratio is > 1 the "recommended cleaning schedule" will be the lowest priority item in the entire fleet.

The cost of cleaning goes way down when you do it in bulk at a service center rather than individual lyft/uber drivers trying to do it. A standardized car also helps.

Re: Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F

#87
post #84
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From my experience prices for Waymo are at least double that of an equivalent Lyft/Uber ride and wait times are usually 20+ minutes. It is a great novelty but nowhere near where it needs to be to handle real scale.

This won’t last long. Waymo has a treasure chest waiting to be deployed as soon as they start expanding more.

I genuinely expect that there will be a point at which manufacturing becomes the bottleneck.

That's going to be a lot of cars to build.

I really wonder if and when they expand to a lot more car manufacturers and models, just to avoid supply chain issues.

Re: Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F

#88
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I do. It'll be easier to keep the fleet on a cleaning schedule, and won't be left to the whims of individuals.

By this logic public transportation should be the cleanest of them all. But, it is unfortunately far from that.

> public transportation should be the cleanest of them all

Privately operated public transport (e.g. jitneys and ferries) frequently are when positioned at a premium, as Waymo is.

Re: Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F

#89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I do. It'll be easier to keep the fleet on a cleaning schedule, and won't be left to the whims of individuals.

I have a good friend who's a Lyft driver. According to him, all drivers are rated on cleanliness by passengers; if you're dinged for a weird smell, there are lasting financial consequences (even if it was for reasons outside of your control, e.g. using a Lyft provided rental while repairing from a traffic accident). We'll see how Waymo handles it! It will definitely be Waymo's problem to solve, though.

I think the difference is that as an individual driver you have an incentive to keep your car clean, so that Lyft continues to dispatch riders to you. For Waymo the selective pressure is less direct and also spread across their entire fleet. They can accept a level of dirtiness, given some probability that the rider would reject the car x cost of rider requesting a (partial) refund x etc. etc.

More cynically, there are simply too many people that won't take care of "public" property. If every 3rd rider (exaggerated for rhetorical purposes) trashes the car, it's gonna be dirty no matter what.

Re: Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F

#90
post #7

We recently started using Waymo more often: - Quality of Lyft and Uber rides have gone down significantly. - Consistently spacious, clean and quiet cars. You know what you'll get. - AC always works and not up to the whim of the driver. - No chatty driver to disturb our sleeping baby. Negatives: - Rides have usually 10% mark up over Lyft and Uber. - Pick up and drop off tend to be a small walk from requested locations…

Does that 10% markup account for the Uber/lyft driver tip?
Post reply on HN