Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What indoor CO2 monitor do you recommend?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 71 posts

Re: Ask HN: What indoor CO2 monitor do you recommend?

#34
The main thing I would consider is that you want a sensor that actually measures CO2, which is usually an NDIR device. A lot of cheaper monitors and even some very fancy professional HVAC devices use “TVOC” meters and calculate a “CO2 equivalent”, and the performance of these devices is wildly variable.

(The AirGradient devices are often configured with CO2 and separate SGP41 TVOC/NOx sensors. It’s entertaining to plot both raw TVOC and CO2 and to observe that they’re clearly showing similar diurnal variation, but the CO2 data is much cleaner.)

Aside: the SGP41 data sheet doesn’t really recommend looking at the raw data, but you can. I have an esphome fork that does this.

Re: Ask HN: What indoor CO2 monitor do you recommend?

#35
I have a handful of these in my home and really appreciate the small form factor, long battery life, and options for accessing the data (on-screen live values via eInk display, encoded recent history displayed via QR code, or simple http server endpoint over wifi): https://github.com/davidkreidler/OpenCO2_Sensor. It was straightforward to integrate the accessories into my homebridge instance for ongoing monitoring and notifications as well.

You can make one yourself from the information in the repository or buy one from the author at their Tindie storefront: https://www.tindie.com/products/davidkreidler/open-co2-senso....

Re: Ask HN: What indoor CO2 monitor do you recommend?

#36
I have a uHoo for a few years, and it’s still working fine, but the app is pretty bad and the device paywalls the raw data behind a subscription which always felt scammy to me. Also the refresh interval is 1min.

So recently I went the diy route and pretty happy with a setup from m5stack: an SCD41 sensor plugged in to an AtomS3, running EspHome. I set the resolution to 5 seconds (can go down to 1 second), and then data goes to HomeAssistant -> InfluxDB and I plot it in Grafana. Cool to see the quick changes when using gas stove or opening up window.

https://shop.m5stack.com/products/co2l-unit-with-temperature...

https://shop.m5stack.com/products/atoms3-dev-kit-w-0-85-inch...

Re: Ask HN: What indoor CO2 monitor do you recommend?

#37

Genuinely curious, what are the advantages of a CO2 monitor? I mean, I get you can “track air quality” but what exactly does that mean on day to day basis?

It means you know when to open the windows more to maintain fresh air.

I think much better and am in a better mood when CO2 levels are lower, or when air is fresher generally (the two generally correlate).

But I don't want to keep my windows wide open all the time because that wastes AC or heat.

So if the monitor is reading above 650, I open windows a little bit. If it's reading over 800, I open them wider. If it's under 550, I'll go back to closing them.

It's just a few times a day, but it really helps. And it's not something I can "tell" otherwise easily, because if I have brain fog or am in a bad mood then high CO2 is just one of many possible reasons -- is my blood sugar low? Did I get enough sleep? Etc.

A CO2 monitor feels just as essential to my health as weighing myself every day, no bright or blue lights two hours before bed, not overeating carbs, and so forth. It really helps with my overall alertness and productivity in a major way.

Re: Ask HN: What indoor CO2 monitor do you recommend?

#40
post #12
post #3

https://aranet.com/products/aranet4-home

These are great. I have two of them and access the readings over Bluetooth using some Python code: https://github.com/Anrijs/Aranet4-Python (there's also a mobile app which I've never used) The eink display is really nice and if you disable Bluetooth the battery seems to last forever. It's 40% off right now which makes me tempted to pick up a third!

That 40% off is a bit misleading, more like 10% off, as you've been able to get them for ~$165 on Amazon forever.
Post reply on HN