Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Radius – A Meetup.com alternative

radius.to

11–20 of 155 posts

Re: Show HN: Radius – A Meetup.com alternative

#12
post #9

Sign up to search is a blocker for me

I probably need to clarify that so thanks for mentioning this - search isn't an active feature at the moment - I'm focusing on the organiser side for now before opening that side up, as there aren't enough events currently for it to be useful. Definitely won't be sign up to search once search is live.

That'll work as long as your organizers are willing to push their attendees to use a new thing, but if you want this to truly become a discovery platform and avoid xkcd 927, it would really be ideal to somehow aggregate/scrape public event info from other sources.

Cause yeah, from the consumer side, I'd love to have a single place that could let me search and link me out to events listed on Facebook, Eventbrite, Ticketmaster, Meetup, Fever, etc., and also provide reasonable tools for cutting through what is sure to be a deluge, through some combination of search tools and machine curation/recommendation.

Re: Show HN: Radius – A Meetup.com alternative

#13

I would be happy to see a good meetup alternative. You might want to consider hiding the numbers of groups and events until you have numbers that are likely to impress anyone viewing them. No shame at all in starting small (there's really no other way to start). But you might turn away potential users who think you're likely to disappear.

But small numbers are a signal to the visitors they are early. Some segment likes that. I think when you are new, embrace the newness.

Re: Show HN: Radius – A Meetup.com alternative

#14
post #8
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for pointing that out! I'll need to update that - guidelines aren't something I've thought about in a great amount of detail, but I'd imagine there are some existing policies out there I can take inspiration from. Open to suggestions if anyone has any. Perhaps there's an open-source set of guidelines somewhere. And yup - definitely need to define a process for that rather than removing groups with zero warning…

TBH that's polish. I'd worry more about how you plan to monetise it/keep it sustainable, and solve the empty shop problem. The problem with hyperlocal is you basically need to launch in every locality to gain critical mass for people to actually use it.

Agreed! Thanks for the feedback.

Initially, I was focusing on feature development on the discovery/search side, but after speaking with some initial groups - none of them cared about discovery (although being found easily would obviously be great for them too) - they just wanted a place to be able to gather RSVPs for events, and a page to post events on easily.

So, the plan is to focus on the organiser side for now and open up discovery if/when I see there's enough demand for groups to actually use it, and we have a good amount of events.

As for launching in every locality - I had planned to focus on one geographic area at a time but that's something I'll need to think about more. I've seen a few different approaches to search, like having pages dedicated to cities/countries rather than just a single search page - that seems like a good intermediate step to have before going all out on a single search page.

RE: monetizing - the rough plan for now is just to have some premium organiser features, which would be aimed at larger groups.

Re: Show HN: Radius – A Meetup.com alternative

#16
I've been using Meetup heavily for years, and I've met most of my friends in my current city at Meetups. I also used to host one in my previous city.

However, the Meetup website and app are garbage (especially with things being slow or straight-up failing to load) and have only been getting worse (other than the recently-added Connections feature, which is nice in theory but basically nobody uses). So naturally, a competitor would be of interest to me.

That said:

> Meetup excludes too many groups by not offering a free tier for smaller/non-profit groups which make up for a huge number of small communities. So many groups just end up dying because one person has to pay the fees.

While true, a side effect of this is that groups that aren't active anymore eventually get deisted, because nobody wants to pay Meetup's prices to keep a dead group online. Once you get discovery up and running, I'd be curious to see how cluttered the website gets with inactive groups, especially over time.

> FWIW, I also think they have a marketing issue with the name Meetup.

Genuinely curious what you think the marketing issue here is. If anything, I think they've cornered a term pretty well.

Re: Show HN: Radius – A Meetup.com alternative

#17
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I probably need to clarify that so thanks for mentioning this - search isn't an active feature at the moment - I'm focusing on the organiser side for now before opening that side up, as there aren't enough events currently for it to be useful. Definitely won't be sign up to search once search is live.

That'll work as long as your organizers are willing to push their attendees to use a new thing, but if you want this to truly become a discovery platform and avoid xkcd 927, it would really be ideal to somehow aggregate/scrape public event info from other sources. Cause yeah, from the consumer side, I'd love to have a single place that could let me search and link me out to events listed on Facebook, Eventbrite, Tick…

If they were going to aggregate, having corresponding events tagged (e.g. the same event posted on Meetup, Facebook, and Instagram all showing up linked under the same page) would be helpful, or even necessary.

Re: Show HN: Radius – A Meetup.com alternative

#18

Plenty of folks are sick of Meetup, so there should be a fertile audience. One question I would have before migrating an existing group is what your plans are for making this sustainable. People don't want to jump to a new platform that is great, only to find it migrate in the direction of the platform they've just left. On the other hand, people don't want to migrate to a platform that is going to go under because i…

Such a simple thing as a meetup clone does not cost much to host, and is therefore immediately economically sustainable. The real concern is, as usual: is it easy to move from meetup to there, will my friends do it, etc, which depends on:

- how simple it is to register an account

- how certain are we this is not going to take the same path to profit than meetup

An example I often consider is that of bewelcome.org, that become huge after Covid when couchsurfing decided to preserve its margins by raising prices. The service is simple, non-profit, its management is open, and it's free. It mostly replaced couchsurfing, at least in the cities in europe where I used it.

Can the same be done with meetup? Maybe, I'm not sure people are frustrated by meetup as much as they were from couchsurfing, but I strongly believe that ruby-on-rail is not the distinguishing feature that will win the argument.

Re: Show HN: Radius – A Meetup.com alternative

#19
I signed up because meetup failed me too. I used to be a host of events, but after things got so much about making money, the group just sucked.

However, I signed up for yours but there is no way to see other groups etc. so, I don't think what you have is meetup yet, just private event hosting. I hope you decide to make some groups have a public option so the events can find people outside their network to come.

Post reply on HN